Best Restaurants in Green Lake, Michigan

Green Lake’s culinary scene just got brighter with Mimi’s Taqueria making waves as a must-visit Mexican eatery. Located in the heart of town, this gem has patrons raving about its authentic flavors and generous portions. From the delicious Fajita salad to the mouthwatering carne asada chimichanga, each dish tells a flavorful story that will transport you south of the border. The friendly service and vibrant atmosphere perfectly complement the fresh, reasonably priced menu, making every visit a fiesta. Whether you’re a local looking for a taste of home or a traveler seeking the best Mexican cuisine in Northern Michigan, Mimi’s Taqueria promises a culinary experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Situated in the vibrant town of Green Lake, Cicero’s Pizza is a haven for pizza enthusiasts seeking a taste of “up north” flavors. The Buffalo Chicken pizza steals the show with its generous toppings and just the right amount of heat, easily customizable with a dash of habanero hot sauce for the daring palate. Don’t fret if you prefer a crispier crust – just request a well-done bake for that perfect crunch. Amidst the savory pies, the attentive and jovial staff elevate the dining experience, making patrons feel like cherished guests with their top-notch service and infectious humor. With transparent pricing and a welcoming ambiance akin to catching up with old friends, Cicero’s Pizza promises a delightful rendezvous for both locals and travelers seeking a slice of genuine hospitality alongside their delicious pies.

Located in the vibrant town of Green Lake, Oaky’s Tavern is making waves with its impressive remodel and delectable menu. Guests rave about the attentive service, quality of food, and inviting atmosphere that embraces you from the moment you step in. One reviewer highlighted the mouthwatering brisket with creamy mashed potatoes, while another savored the smoky ribs and flavorful blackened chicken tacos. Specializing in smoked meats, Oaky’s also caters to vegans with a specially crafted salad and an impeccable impossible burger. With a diverse menu that includes irresistible wings, tots, and a variety of refreshing drinks, Oaky’s Tavern is a must-visit for anyone seeking a top-notch dining experience in Green Lake.

In the vibrant town of Green Lake, Hofbrau Steak House & American Grille stands out as a gem for both locals and visitors alike. This chophouse exudes a cozy cabin vibe, offering a delectable array of surf ‘n’ turf delights and pasta dishes. Patrons rave about the impeccable service, with shout-outs to Preston the bartender and Jeremy for their warm hospitality. The menu boasts standout dishes like the rodeo tacos, stuffed mushrooms, and hand-breaded chicken tenders that leave taste buds tingling with delight. Whether you opt for the Italian sandwiches or the North Woods pasta, each bite is a testament to the chef’s skill and dedication. With a spacious patio for alfresco dining and a tempting selection of draft beers, Hofbrau is the epitome of a culinary haven where every meal is a flavorful adventure waiting to be savored. A visit here is not just a meal; it’s an experience to be cherished and revisited time and time again. Cheers to unforgettable dining moments at Hofbrau Steak House & American Grille!

Situated in the vibrant town of Green Lake, Bud’s is a bustling counter-serve eatery that effortlessly combines the charm of a woodsy-chic setting with the convenience of a patio dining experience. Boasting an impressive array of offerings, from artisanal espresso to delectable cafe fare and mouthwatering ice cream, Bud’s truly caters to every craving. One standout feature is its cozy ambiance, where regulars are warmly welcomed, creating a sense of community that enhances the overall dining experience. Whether you’re in the mood for a steaming cup of tea, a satisfying meal, or a sweet treat, Bud’s has it all, making it a must-visit destination for those seeking a delightful culinary adventure in Green Lake.

Located in the picturesque town of Green Lake, A. Papano’s Pizza is a must-visit for pizza aficionados. Boasting a diverse menu featuring specialty pies, customizable options, zesty wings, hearty subs, and fresh salads, this simple pizzeria has something for everyone. Rave reviews highlight the unbeatable combination of price and flavor, with a special shoutout to their tantalizing parmesan crust that keeps customers coming back for more. The dedication to exceptional service shines through, as the staff at A. Papano’s Pizza not only accommodates special requests but also goes the extra mile to ensure a safe and enjoyable dining experience for all. For a slice of pizza paradise in Green Lake, look no further than A. Papano’s Pizza!

Located in Green Lake, Stone Cafeteria is a hidden culinary gem that has diners buzzing with excitement. With a diverse menu that includes mouthwatering pulled pork adorned with hummus, a variety of peppers, cheddar cheese, and irresistible cheesesticks, each bite is a flavor-packed adventure. The gluten-free options and inventive dishes like the Cali flour and nutritious salads are sure to please even the most discerning palates. Whether you’re an employee looking for a cozy hangout spot or a proud parent of an Interlochen music enthusiast, Stone Cafeteria promises an unforgettable dining experience that will leave you craving more. Prepare to embark on a gastronomic journey that will redefine your expectations of a truly exceptional meal.

Located in the charming town of Green Lake, Interlochen EZ Mart is a delightful gem that goes beyond your typical convenience store fare. Boasting a friendly atmosphere and top-notch cleanliness, this spot is praised for its tasty lunch options, especially the tempting subs and pizza that are said to be real crowd-pleasers. The reviews rave about the fantastic customer service, with mentions of funny interactions and the sweetest staff member named Pebba in the deli. Whether you’re fueling up your car or yourself, Interlochen EZ Mart seems to have all bases covered, making it a must-visit for a memorable pit stop filled with smiles and satisfaction.