Best Restaurants in Elmira, New York

Located in Elmira, Siam Elephants Thai Restaurant is a culinary gem that has garnered rave reviews for its amazing flavors and top-notch quality. Guests have praised the robust flavors and impressive presentation of dishes like the cut of salmon, crab rangoons that vanish in a blink, and a delightful array of Thai classics from duck salad to green curry. The chef’s expertise shines through, ensuring each bite is a culinary delight. With courteous staff and dishes like fried ice cream and cheesecake rounding off the experience, Siam Elephants Thai Restaurant is a must-visit for those craving an unforgettable Thai dining experience in Elmira.

Situated in Elmira, the Ill EagleTaphouse is a hidden gem just waiting to be discovered. Housed in a historic Federal building that once served as a post office, this restaurant is a feast for the senses. Step inside and be greeted by a variety of seating options, from high tops to cozy chairs, each exuding its own unique charm. The menu boasts delights like jumbo pretzels with cream ale cheese sauce, perfectly crisp wings, and flavorful Mahi Mahi tacos. With a wide array of drink choices, including local ciders and an impressive beer selection, there’s something for every palate. Whether you’re into pool, darts, or simply savoring delicious food in a one-of-a-kind setting, Ill EagleTaphouse promises a dining experience that’ll keep you coming back for more.

Located in Elmira, Lib’s Supper Club is a long-standing gem that promises a banquet-hall-style dining experience like no other. Specializing in classic Italian dishes, succulent steaks, and fresh seafood, this establishment has garnered rave reviews for its generous portions and flavors that transport you to a cozy Italian kitchen. Guests have highlighted the attentive service, with mentions of servers like Linda and Octavia going above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. The ambiance, described as moody, romantic, and classic, sets the perfect backdrop for indulging in mouthwatering dishes like the perfectly cooked haddock, 16 oz filet, and beloved Buffalo shrimp appetizer. With a reputation for hearty meals that guarantee leftovers and a bustling atmosphere, Lib’s Supper Club is a must-visit for those seeking a taste of home-cooked goodness with a touch of elegance in Elmira. Reservations are highly recommended at this culinary hotspot, where every bite feels like a warm embrace of flavors.

Located in the charming town of Elmira, Anne’s Pancakes is a true gem that has left patrons raving about their exceptional food and service. Renowned for their mouthwatering cinnamon toast, corn beef hash, and the aptly named “Anne’s eye opener,” this spot is a must-visit for breakfast enthusiasts. Regulars swear by the pancakes, hailing them as nothing short of phenomenal. The friendly and efficient staff, including standout members like Desiree, Lisa, and Amy, ensure a delightful dining experience every time. With reasonable prices and a cozy ambiance, Anne’s Pancakes stands out as the go-to spot for a hearty and satisfying breakfast in Elmira. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this restaurant promises an unforgettable culinary journey that’s worth every bite.

Located in Elmira, the Turtle Leaf Cafe is a hidden gem for food enthusiasts seeking a chic and relaxed dining experience. Boasting organic and seasonal light fare, this cafe offers a delightful array of dishes that have left patrons raving. With mentions of their delectable espresso drinks and fresh ingredients shining through multiple reviews, Turtle Leaf Cafe stands out as a must-visit spot for those craving a culinary adventure. Experience the essence of Elmira’s dining scene at this charming cafe that promises to tantalize your taste buds and leave you coming back for more.

Located in Elmira, Vincenzo’s is a haven for pizza aficionados and foodies alike. Boasting a perfect slice that one reviewer deemed needing “not one thing… EVEN SALT!” This easygoing spot serves up flavorful slices and pies that have patrons raving about making a 7-hour drive just to savor its delectable offerings. Not only does Vincenzo’s excel in crafting mouthwatering pizzas, but also in providing top-notch service in a clean and welcoming setting. The local touch is evident with stories of contributing to the community, like providing coupons for reading challenges at the nearby library. If you’re in search of the best pizza in town, or even anywhere, make sure to put Vincenzo’s at the top of your list. Your taste buds will thank you!

In the heart of Elmira sits Rye, a culinary oasis that truly dazzles. Whether you’re in the mood for a casual dinner or a celebratory feast, this spot hits all the right notes. With a bar menu that boasts an impressive array of drinks, including a local Friday night favorite, the fish fry available in three different portions (no more oversized servings, hooray!), and a tantalizing lamb Shepherd’s Pie that is a must-try. And let’s not forget the decadent chocolate lava cake that beckons as the perfect sweet ending. The ambiance pairs beautifully with the attentive and friendly staff, making it a top choice for any occasion. Plus, with live music and brunch options on the menu, Rye seamlessly transitions from day to night without missing a beat. Don’t miss out on this Elmira gem – your taste buds will thank you!

Central Hots in Elmira is a bustling hub for food enthusiasts of all ages, offering a vibrant dining experience that’s not to be missed. Visitors rave about the friendly staff who guide you through the menu with ease, ensuring a seamless dining journey. The sweet potato fries paired with the delectable Blue Cheese dressing are a standout, tantalizing the taste buds with each bite. And let’s not forget the iconic garbage plate, a must-try that leaves patrons singing its praises for its well-seasoned perfection and the unbeatable texture of the fries. Prepare to be wowed at Central Hots, where every dish is a savory delight waiting to be discovered.

Situated in Elmira, Pietro & Son is a culinary gem that has diners raving about its authentic Italian fare. From mouthwatering pizzas to perfectly cooked pastas, this corner eatery has captured the hearts of locals and travelers alike. One reviewer highlighted the exceptional value, managing to feed a group while keeping the bill wallet-friendly. Another praised the freshness of ingredients, with the kitchen bustling with deliveries of farm-fresh produce. And let’s not forget the raving reviews on the pizza, hailed as some of the best in town. With each visit feeling like a mini-vacation to Italy, Pietro & Son is a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of la dolce vita.

Located in Elmira, Beijing Garden is a Chinese gem that has captured the hearts of many diners. With a reputation for consistency and perfection, this unassuming cafe-style eatery delivers classic Chinese dishes that leave patrons craving more. The attentive and knowledgeable staff add a touch of magic to the dining experience, going above and beyond to cater to individual needs, whether it’s accommodating vegan requests or surprising guests with thoughtful gestures like honey for tea. The rave reviews speak for themselves, highlighting the stellar service and delicious food that make Beijing Garden a must-visit spot for anyone in the area, promising a delightful culinary adventure with each visit.