Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Columbia, Indiana

Discover the culinary delights of Columbia, Indiana, a charming town bursting with flavor and flair. Situated in the heart of Indiana, this lovely town is a haven for food enthusiasts, boasting a vibrant dining scene that caters to every palate. From cozy cafes to upscale eateries, Columbia is a culinary playground waiting to be explored. As you roam the streets, you’ll encounter a diverse array of eateries offering a fusion of flavors and culinary experiences. Whether you’re craving farm-to-table freshness or international delights, the Best Restaurants in Columbia, Indiana, are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Indulge in delectable dishes while immersing yourself in the rich culture and history this welcoming town has to offer.

1. The Kitchen & Company

Located in Columbia, The Kitchen & Company is a culinary gem that has garnered rave reviews for its exceptional service and top-notch quality. This restaurant, which also caters events, has left a lasting impression on patrons with its diverse offerings, from breakfast buffets to tantalizing taco salads. Guests have been wowed by the creativity and freshness of the Easter grazing boxes, showcasing beautiful and fun ingredients that leave taste buds craving more. The attention to detail shines through, with personalized packaging and gluten-free options showing a commitment to customer satisfaction. Whether it’s a corporate event or a wedding celebration, The Kitchen & Company delivers on both presentation and taste, making it a must-visit spot for food aficionados in Columbia.

Rating:
Price:

2. Copp Farm Supply

Copp Farm Supply in Columbia is not just a restaurant, but a longstanding pillar of the community, serving farm-fresh goodness with a side of heartfelt hospitality. With decades of experience, this family-owned gem offers a menu of local favorites that have patrons raving about the exceptional service and fair pricing. Whether you’re a seasoned regular or a first-time visitor, the warm atmosphere and friendly staff make every dining experience feel like a homecoming. Don’t miss the opportunity to savor a taste of tradition and support a local business that truly knows how to cultivate a loyal following. Your journey to culinary satisfaction starts here at Copp Farm Supply!

Rating:
Price:

3. Old world Cafe

Situated in the charming town of Columbia, Old World Cafe is a delightful gem that promises a unique dining experience. From the intriguing Bacon Apple Grilled Cheese, a surprising yet delectable combination of mozzarella, bacon, grilled apple slices, and apple butter, to the array of chocolate-covered treats like Buckeyes and Amaretto chocolates, this cafe has something for every palate. The attentive staff, exemplified by the accommodating manager who ensured a guest’s favorite French toast was still obtainable, adds a personal touch to the dining adventure. With a cozy atmosphere, friendly faces, and a touch of antiquing post-meal, Old World Cafe is a must-visit spot that offers not just food, but a wholesome experience worth savoring repeatedly.

Rating:
Price:

4. CJ’s Drive in

Located in Columbia, CJ’s Drive in is a nostalgic gem that whisks diners back to the golden era of mom and pop eateries. Boasting quick and friendly service with a touch of old-school charm, this spot is perfect for a wallet-friendly family outing. Indulge in their shredded chicken sandwich or sink your teeth into a classic Coney dog – both absolute winners according to satisfied patrons. Don’t miss out on their famous root beer, a favorite among regulars. With car hop service adding a unique touch, CJ’s Drive in is a must-visit for a delightful blast from the past, complete with fair prices and top-notch hospitality that will keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

5. The NOOK

Step into the culinary treasure trove of The NOOK in Columbia, where every dish tells a story of affordability and flavorful indulgence. This quirky gem has mastered the art of delivering budget-friendly delights that don’t compromise on taste. From sizzling hot fried-to-order treats to the welcoming embrace of an old-school diner with a touch of familial warmth, The Nook has etched its name as a local favorite. Immerse yourself in a world where efficiency meets friendliness, where every bite speaks of genuine care from the dedicated staff who ensure a spotless environment. An experience that beckons you to return for more of their delicious offerings, The NOOK is a must-visit for those seeking a taste of Columbia’s culinary charm and hospitality.

Rating:
Price:

6. The Square

Located in the vibrant town of Columbia, The Square is a hidden gem for food enthusiasts seeking an unforgettable dining experience. With raving reviews like “huge salads and portions” and “delicious seafood, chicken, ribs, steaks, burgers, sandwiches, and desserts,” this restaurant truly offers a diverse and mouthwatering menu. Guests have praised the homemade cole slaw for its unique sweetness and the spicy garlic wings for their perfect blend of flavors. The Valentine’s dinner featuring scallops, lobster linguine, and a warm heart-shaped brownie with champagne has left diners in awe. The exceptional service and welcoming staff have only added to the charm of this establishment, making it a must-visit spot for anyone passing through Columbia. Get ready to indulge in a culinary adventure at The Square!

Rating:
Price:

7. Pickles Cafe

Located in downtown Columbia, Pickles Cafe is a culinary gem not to be missed. With a quirky and cute vibe, this cafe offers a unique dining experience that keeps patrons coming back for more. The menu boasts a delightful array of dishes, from the cranberry goat cheese ham panini to the broccoli potato cheesy soup and garlic smashed potatoes that are simply to die for. The attention to detail in presentation is evident in every dish, making each one a true work of art. And let’s not forget the pick 3 lunch items and the decadent pick 3 dessert plate that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. With friendly and efficient staff, Pickles Cafe exudes small-town charm and hospitality, setting itself apart from ordinary chain restaurants. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, a visit to Pickles Cafe is a must for a memorable dining experience in Columbia City.

Rating:
Price:

8. Big G’s Sports Cafe

Located in Columbia, Big G’s Sports Cafe is a haven for food enthusiasts seeking a delightful dining experience without breaking the bank. With a glowing reputation for its hearty All-American diner fare, this spot exudes a cozy family-friendly ambiance that keeps patrons coming back for more. The menu boasts an array of tantalizing options, from the Big G breakfast that leaves you wanting more to the mouthwatering mushroom burger and crispy onion rings that simply hit the spot. The omelet, loaded with an abundance of bacon and cheese, has garnered a loyal following, with diners raving about its flavor. The staff at Big G’s Sports Cafe shines bright, ensuring prompt service and a warm, welcoming atmosphere that adds to the overall charm of this culinary gem. For a taste of local flavor and a side of community support, Big G’s is a must-visit for both residents and visitors exploring the culinary landscape of Columbia.

Rating:
Price:

9. Chapman’s Brewing Company

Situated in the vibrant town of Columbia, Chapman’s Brewing Company is a culinary gem not to be missed. Guests rave about the mouthwatering BBQ dishes that are a definite crowd-pleaser, while the diverse beer selection adds a perfect touch to every meal. The lively atmosphere and attentive staff ensure a delightful dining experience, making it a top choice for locals and visitors alike looking for a taste of the best in Columbia.

Rating:
Price:

10. Columbia City Nutrition

Columbia City Nutrition in Columbia is a gem for health enthusiasts and community supporters alike. With glowing reviews mentioning the friendliness of the staff and the positive vibes, it’s clear that this spot is a local favorite. Customers rave about the Mega teas and shakes, highlighting them as must-tries. The energy-boosting mega tea bombs seem to be a hit, perfect for busy days. If you’re looking for a place with great food and drinks in a warm and welcoming environment, Columbia City Nutrition seems like the place to be!

Rating:
Price: