Best Restaurants in Columbia, Indiana

In the bustling town of Columbia, Mom’s Diner stands out as a true culinary gem worth discovering. Boasting a delightful mix of flavors and portions that are bound to impress even the heartiest of eaters, this diner-turned-haven offers a cornucopia of mouthwatering delights. From the tantalizing Breakfast Stromboli that’s been hailed as the stuff of dreams to the gigantic battered fish that could easily feed a small village, each dish is prepared with care and precision. The warm and welcoming atmosphere, combined with top-notch customer service, elevates the dining experience to a whole new level. And let’s not forget about their delectable assortment of ice creams and pies, guaranteed to satisfy any sweet tooth. For travelers seeking a taste of authentic, home-cooked goodness in Columbia, Mom’s Diner is your go-to spot for a memorable culinary adventure that’s sure to leave you planning your next visit before you even finish your meal.

Located in the vibrant town of Columbia, Junee B’s is a culinary gem that promises a delightful experience for food enthusiasts. With a focus on serving delectable treats like soft-serve ice cream, milkshakes, and snow cones from Snow Biz, this spot is a go-to for those seeking a sweet escape. Boasting a cozy outdoor setup with picnic tables, Junee B’s offers a charming al fresco dining experience that adds to its allure. The rave reviews speak volumes about the excellent service and scrumptious offerings, making it a must-visit destination for a flavorsome adventure in town.

Las Islas Mexican Restaurant in Columbia is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered by all Mexican cuisine enthusiasts. With a vibrant atmosphere, delightful music, and a staff that goes above and beyond, this spot is a true fiesta for the senses. One reviewer couldn’t resist mentioning the charming server, adding a touch of whimsy to the dining experience. The menu boasts an array of mouthwatering dishes, with the Chile Verde stealing the spotlight for its bold flavors and just-right level of spiciness. Despite petite tables, the speedy service ensures that piping hot plates of goodness arrive promptly. And let’s not forget the irresistible $1 margaritas that beckon for a return visit. Las Islas promises a culinary adventure that will have you coming back for more, making it a must-visit destination for Mexican food aficionados in Columbia.

When it comes to steakhouse experiences in Columbia, Taylor’s 2 Steakhouse is a real MVP. Situated in the heart of the city, this sports-themed gem boasts a vibrant ambiance adorned with an impressive collection of memorabilia that will surely catch your eye. The star of the show? Their mouthwatering, big, juicy steaks that have been raved about by many diners. From the signature Ribeye steaks grilled to perfection to the generous sides, every dish is a slam dunk. The attentive staff ensures that your glass is never empty, adding a nice touch to the overall dining experience. Whether you’re a sports enthusiast or just a foodie looking for a top-notch meal, Taylor’s 2 Steakhouse is the ultimate choice for a memorable culinary touchdown in Columbia.

Located in the vibrant town of Columbia, the Double D Diner is a cash-only gem that has foodies raving. Patrons appreciate the hot and delicious breakfast options, with a special shoutout to the homemade coconut pie that has diners coming back for more. The welcoming atmosphere curated by the friendly staff, particularly Debbie and Heidi, adds a touch of warmth that makes every visit feel like dining with family. Affordable prices and top-notch service make this diner a must-visit for those craving a taste of comfort food in a cozy setting. Next time you’re in Columbia, don’t miss the chance to experience the Double D Diner!

In the bustling town of Columbia, the Monroe Pizza Company stands out as a gem among the dining scene. With a delightful ambiance adorned with pizza boxes from far and wide, this place exudes a lively charm that sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. The reviews speak volumes – from raving about the speed and friendliness of the service to the mouthwatering pizzas that even the pickiest of eaters can’t resist, it’s clear that Monroe Pizza Company knows how to leave a lasting impression. And let’s not forget the sweet treats like the recommended s’mores dessert that has patrons singing its praises. With a keen eye for catering to all dietary needs without missing a beat, this place is a surefire hit for both flavor enthusiasts and those with specific requirements. So if you find yourself in Columbia, do yourself a favor and make a beeline for Monroe Pizza Company – your taste buds will thank you!

Tantalizing taste buds in Columbia is Pipers Pizza, a beloved gem serving up mouthwatering pies that have locals buzzing. With a pizza so renowned that families have made it a tradition since the 90s, it’s no surprise that Pipers has built a loyal following. Rave reviews praise the generous toppings and perfect cooking, ensuring each slice is a slice of perfection. Whether you’re a fan of classics or looking to try something new, Pipers Pizza promises a flavor-packed experience that’ll have you craving more. Unleash your inner pizza aficionado and savor a slice of the good life at this must-visit spot in Columbia.

Located in the vibrant town of Columbia, Memories is a gem that shines bright among local small businesses. Patrons rave about the delectable cheese curds, a must-try on the menu, paired perfectly with a caramel chilly coffee that hits all the right notes. The speedy service adds to the charm, with the friendly staff creating a welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers coming back for more. Memories isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an experience brimming with flavors and hospitality that leaves a lasting impression. Indulge in a memorable culinary journey at Memories, where every bite is infused with passion and every visit feels like a warm embrace.

Located in Columbia, the Sunoco Gas Station Oakland City is not your average pit stop. Boasting a super clean store with a friendly staff, this place has garnered rave reviews for its standout pizza that keeps customers coming back for more. Patrons have been pleasantly surprised by the unique offerings such as Reese and banana cream cupcakes, setting this spot apart from the usual gas station fare. With convenient service, great prices, and a welcoming atmosphere, this hidden gem is worth a visit for a tasty treat on the go.

Located in the vibrant town of Columbia, On The Fly is a hidden gem that boasts a welcoming atmosphere and top-notch customer service. Patrons rave about the friendly staff, who elevate the dining experience with their warm hospitality. Whether you’re swinging by for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, On The Fly promises a delightful culinary journey that will have you coming back for more. Don’t miss the chance to savor their delectable dishes and experience the charm that sets this eatery apart from the rest in Columbia.