Best Restaurants in Cedarburg, Wisconsin

Located in the heart of Cedarburg, PJ Piper Pancake House is a must-visit for those craving a classic American breakfast experience. With generous portions and a menu brimming with traditional staples, this old-school diner has garnered rave reviews from satisfied customers. From the mouthwatering pancakes to the hearty Eggs Benedict over Cornbread, each dish is prepared with precision and served with a side of warm hospitality. The bustling kitchen ensures that every order is fresh and accurate, promising a delightful dining experience. Whether you’re a local looking for your new favorite spot or a visitor seeking a taste of authentic American fare, PJ Piper Pancake House is sure to leave you planning your next visit before you’ve even finished your meal.

Located in Cedarburg, Brandywine is a culinary gem you won’t want to miss. With an array of standout dishes like the smoked tomato basil soup and the Rosemary sourdough focaccia with whipped lemon ricotta, this restaurant promises an unforgettable dining experience. Delight your taste buds with the driftless gnocchetti topped with goat cheese and sage, or savor the chicken parm that’s sure to please. Don’t miss out on their unique ice cream flavors, including the highly recommended sage chocolate chip. With exceptional food, welcoming staff, and a chic ambiance, Brandywine sets the bar high for dining excellence in Cedarburg. Make a reservation to secure your spot at this culinary hotspot for an experience that’s truly top-notch.

Located in the charming town of Cedarburg, The Chocolate Factory is a must-visit gem for those seeking a delightful culinary experience. Boasting a diverse menu ranging from mouthwatering subs to delectable ice cream treats, this local chain truly has something for everyone. Diners rave about the special chicken, avocado, bacon bread, and red onion sub, praising the perfect crunch of the bread and the freshness of the ingredients. The half sandwich option is a hit, allowing guests to indulge without overindulging. Families especially adore the kid-friendly atmosphere and the tantalizing meatball sub. With a dedicated and friendly staff, this restaurant is a standout destination for a scrumptious meal in Cedarburg.

Located in Cedarburg, Le’s Pho is a hidden gem that promises an unforgettable culinary experience. The rave reviews speak for themselves, with diners praising the authentic flavors and top-notch service. Whether you’re a pho aficionado or looking to explore Vietnamese cuisine for the first time, Le’s Pho has something for everyone. From the flavorful Pho with shrimp to the aromatic Bun Bo Hue, each dish is crafted with care and precision. Don’t miss out on the chicken curry that warms you to the core, especially on chilly Wisconsin evenings. With a welcoming ambiance and hospitable staff, a visit to Le’s Pho is a must for any food enthusiast craving a taste of Vietnam in the heart of Cedarburg.

Nestled in the heart of Cedarburg, the Cream & Crepe Cafe offers a delightful escape into the world of French-inspired cuisine with a touch of American flair. Boasting a charming ambiance and attentive service, this cafe has been winning hearts and taste buds alike. The menu, brimming with a delectable array of savory and sweet crepes, alongside hearty American sandwiches and soups, promises a culinary adventure like no other. From rave reviews praising the fantastic service to the nostalgic atmosphere exuded by the historic Woolen Mill building, every visit to Cream & Crepe Cafe is a trip down memory lane fused with gastronomic satisfaction. Don’t miss the chance to savor their famous ham and cheddar crepe or indulge in a warm bowl of cream of broccoli soup while soaking in the picturesque views of Cedar Creek. For a truly unforgettable dining experience in Cedarburg, Cream & Crepe Cafe is a must-visit gem that stands the test of time.

Located in Cedarburg, The Farmstead is a hidden gem offering American comfort food in a 150-year-old fieldstone farmhouse. With a cozy and intimate atmosphere, this restaurant has quickly become a local favorite. Guests rave about the standout dishes like the juicy 22 oz steak with crispy onions that melt in your mouth and the flavorful beef tenderloin dinners. The menu, featuring everything from steaks to seafood, is just the right size, ensuring quality over quantity. Make sure to try the garlic mashed potatoes and coconut chicken curry soup, both highly praised by diners. Despite its slightly off-the-beaten-path location, The Farmstead is well worth the search, offering top-notch service and a welcoming vibe that will make you feel like part of the family. Whether you’re on a date night or a family outing, this restaurant is a must-visit for a truly unforgettable dining experience in Cedarburg.

Located in Cedarburg, Out & Out Eatery and Catering is a culinary gem that has captured the hearts of many food enthusiasts. Renowned for its accommodating service, this spot goes the extra mile for gluten-free diners, ensuring a safe and enjoyable experience for families of all kinds. Known affectionately as the “Mac and Cheese House,” their velvety macs, scrumptious hot sandwiches, and crisp salads are hailed as crowd-pleasers, perfect for a casual lunch or a catered event. Whether savoring a roast beef ciabatta sandwich with impeccably distributed garlic mayonnaise or indulging in their signature custard smoothies, each visit promises a delightful culinary adventure. With a stellar catering department that delivers outstanding tray options like veggie Mac and Cheese and Quinoa Southwest Salad, Out & Out Eatery and Catering is a shining star in Cedarburg’s dining scene, beckoning both locals and visitors alike to revel in its flavorsome offerings.

Located in Cedarburg, Tomaso’s is a charming Italian gem that has captured the hearts (and taste buds) of locals and visitors alike. Renowned for its thin-crust pizza that seems to have a cult following, this cozy eatery offers a variety of toppings that are described as “unbelievably fresh and flavorful.” With options like whole-wheat and gluten-free pasta, Tomaso’s ensures there’s something for everyone. The sweet and fresh sauce, generously topped with sausage, mushrooms, and onions, sets their pizza apart, creating a symphony of flavors that keeps diners coming back for more. The ambiance exudes an old-school Italian charm, while the friendly service and fair prices make it a clear favorite in Cedarburg. Whether you’re a regular or a newcomer, Tomaso’s promises a dining experience that will have you eagerly planning your next visit.

Sal’s Pizza in Cedarburg is a culinary gem waiting to be discovered in this vibrant town. Boasting a unique array of gourmet pizza flavors, this local favorite offers a cozy dining experience both inside and outside. The servers ensure a delightful visit, going above and beyond to make patrons feel welcome. Don’t miss out on their by-the-slice option, a perfect way to savor their fresh and crispy crust creations. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Sal’s Pizza promises a memorable dining experience with each flavorful bite. Make sure to stop by and treat your taste buds to a slice of perfection!

Located in Cedarburg, Rebellion Brewing USA is a vibrant gem that exudes a cool speakeasy vibe with its unique entrance over the original mill. The atmosphere here is truly extraordinary, making every visit a memorable experience. With a focus on exceptional beer and cider options, this spot is a haven for beer aficionados. While the food menu may be limited, what they offer is crafted to perfection, pairing wonderfully with their brews. The staff’s warmth and the owner’s passion shine through, creating a welcoming environment where every visit feels like a special occasion. Join the rebellion at this brewery for a taste of Cedarburg’s finest!