Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Carmel, New York

Carmel, located in the picturesque state of New York, is a hidden gem for food enthusiasts. Despite its small size, this charming town boasts an impressive culinary scene that is sure to please even the most discerning palates. From cozy cafes serving up freshly brewed coffee and artisanal pastries to upscale restaurants offering innovative interpretations of classic dishes, Carmel has something for everyone. With its close proximity to local farms and markets, the chefs in this town have access to an abundance of fresh, locally sourced ingredients, resulting in dishes that burst with flavor and showcase the rich agricultural heritage of the region. Whether you’re craving a hearty steak, a succulent seafood dish, or a delightful vegetarian meal, Carmel has it all, making it a must-visit destination for food lovers.

1. That Greek Place

Located in the vibrant town of Carmel, That Greek Place has quickly become a local gem for Greek cuisine enthusiasts. Boasting an array of mouthwatering dishes, this spot has garnered rave reviews for its authentic flavors and generous portions. Patrons have praised the warm and welcoming atmosphere, with the family-owned establishment radiating positive energy and exceptional service. One standout dish that repeatedly captures diners’ hearts is the lamb and beef yeero, transporting taste buds to the streets of Greece with its authentic preparation. The Caesar salad and fasolada soup have also left guests impressed, leaving them eager to return for more. If you’re in the mood for a culinary adventure filled with Greek delights, That Greek Place is a must-visit spot that promises to exceed all expectations.

Rating:
Price:

2. Tacoland

Tacoland in Carmel is a vibrant gem that beckons all taco aficionados with its authentic flavors and warm hospitality. With a colorful interior and a welcoming atmosphere, this family-owned establishment has diners raving about their standout dish – the birria grilled cheese, a culinary masterpiece that is a must-try. Pair this delight with their homemade pineapple habanero sauce, a flavor explosion that adds a unique twist to every bite. From traditional street tacos like carne asada and al pastor to innovative offerings like taco bowls and burritos, Tacoland’s diverse menu promises a fiesta for your taste buds. Whether you opt for dining in or taking out, Tacoland is a fresh addition to Carmel’s culinary scene, ready to deliver an unforgettable Mexican dining experience.

Rating:
Price:

3. Luigi’s Famiglia Cucina – Italian Restaurant – Pizza – Catering

Welcome to Luigi’s, a hidden gem in the heart of town. From the moment you step inside, you’ll feel like part of the family. The warm and friendly staff go out of their way to make you feel welcome and ensure you have an unforgettable dining experience. The menu is filled with classic Italian dishes that are bursting with flavor. Don’t miss the chicken rollatini and spicy honey pizza – they are absolute must-tries. And be sure to save room for dessert, especially the heavenly Mama’s Cake. Luigi himself is a true gentleman, always going the extra mile to make his customers feel special. Whether you’re looking for a cozy dinner for two or a festive celebration with friends, Luigi’s is the place to be.

Rating:
Price:

4. George’s Place

Nestled along the Empire State Trail, this charming lakeside restaurant is a must-visit for those in need of a delicious and energizing meal. With a stunning view of the lake out front, it’s the perfect spot to relax and refuel after a long bike trip. The service is top-notch, providing great value and generous portions. The Irish Eggs Benedict is a standout dish, hailed as the best Egg Benedict ever by one satisfied patron. Despite its popularity, the wait time for food was impressively quick, even on a busy Sunday morning. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, evoking a sense of nostalgia with its old-school, hometown feel. The bacon egg and cheese sandwich is a true indulgence, with ample portions of crunchy bacon and gooey cheese. Although slightly pricier than average, it’s well worth the cost for the quality of the food and friendly service. Whether you’re a local or passing through on the trail, this diner is the perfect spot for a comforting and satisfying breakfast.

Rating:
Price:

5. Bliss Dairy Bar & Grill

Located in Carmel, Bliss Dairy Bar & Grill is a culinary gem that consistently delivers fresh, delicious dishes that won’t break the bank. The friendly and professional staff ensure a welcoming atmosphere, making each dining experience memorable. With a focus on quality and affordability, Bliss Dairy Bar & Grill is a must-visit for those seeking a taste of exceptional cuisine in Carmel.

Rating:
Price:

6. Fiddlers Green

Fid’s Bar and Restaurant is a hidden gem that offers delicious food in a friendly and welcoming atmosphere. From the moment you step inside, you are greeted with warmth and hospitality. The menu is extensive, offering a wide variety of options that are sure to please everyone’s palate. The food is consistently flavorful and well-prepared, with generous portion sizes. The selection of beers on tap is impressive, catering to beer enthusiasts. While the restaurant can get quite busy on weekends, it is worth visiting early to enjoy a quieter dining experience. Fid’s is not just a bar; it has transformed into a restaurant that feels like home. Whether you’re catching up with old friends or looking for a family-friendly spot, Fid’s Bar and Restaurant is the place to be.

Rating:
Price:

7. Prato Restaurant and Pizzeria

Welcome to the fabulous world of La Bella Cucina! Nestled in the heart of the city, this charming Italian restaurant promises a delightful gastronomic experience that will transport you straight to the cobblestone streets of Italy. The aroma of the chicken prato dish fills the air, enticing your senses with its tantalizing scent. The chefs have truly mastered the art of cooking, as each bite is a burst of flavor that leaves you craving for more. Pair your meal with one of their signature margaritas, followed by a refreshing Peroni beer. While the atmosphere may get lively, the attentive staff will ensure your comfort and make your visit a memorable one. Just a small suggestion – it’s worth requesting a quieter spot, away from any noisy celebrations. As for the prices, they are reasonable for the quality of the food, though the desserts may be a bit on the pricey side. So, if you’re seeking an authentic Italian dining experience, La Bella Cucina is the place to be. Buon appetito!

Rating:
Price:

8. Thai Golden

Nestled by the picturesque Lake Gleneida, Thai Golden is a cozy family-owned restaurant that promises an authentic Thai culinary experience. With a strong overall rating of 4.5, it is clear that this gem is highly regarded by its patrons. The rave reviews speak volumes about the quality and taste of the food. Diners have praised the perfectly cooked Pad Thai, the well-balanced flavors of the Papaya Salad with Grilled Chicken, and the tantalizing Moo Yang and Chicken Sesame dishes. The menu boasts a variety of options, from classic Thai favorites like red curry and duck rolls to delectable appetizers like roti. The restaurant’s bright and cheery atmosphere, coupled with attentive and friendly staff, creates a welcoming and enjoyable dining experience. Thai Golden is undoubtedly a must-visit restaurant in Carmel, offering a much-needed break from the typical pizzerias in the area.

Rating:
Price:

9. McCarthy’s Grill House

Welcome to the enchanting world of Annie’s Restaurant! Nestled in the heart of town, this hidden gem surprises even the most discerning food enthusiasts. With a flawless event space accommodating up to 60 people, Annie’s is the perfect choice for your special occasions. The delectable cuisine will transport your taste buds to new heights, leaving you craving for more. The professional wait staff ensures that every detail is taken care of, from the impeccable tablecloths to the personalized service. If you’re in the mood for traditional Irish pub food, don’t miss out on the mouthwatering Shepherd’s Pie. Annie’s Restaurant is a culinary adventure you won’t want to miss.

Rating:
Price:

10. Greek Village

Located in the charming town of Carmel, Greek Village is a culinary gem that has patrons raving about its authenticity and flavors. Diners are transported to Greece with each bite of their mouthwatering Greek platters and delightful baklava. The hummus and tzatziki are described as “the bomb,” adding an extra layer of savory delight to the experience. Highlighted by one reviewer as having the best gyro meat ever tasted, Greek Village promises a truly unforgettable dining adventure that brings generations together in a serene and inviting setting. If you’re seeking a taste of Greece in the heart of Carmel, look no further than Greek Village for a culinary journey worth savoring.

Rating:
Price: