Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Brookhaven, New York

Dive into the vibrant culinary landscape of Brookhaven, New York, a haven for foodies and adventure seekers alike. This charming town boasts an array of diverse dining options, making it a culinary hotspot in Long Island. From cozy cafes to upscale eateries, Brookhaven is a gastronomic delight waiting to be explored. Beyond its culinary offerings, this lovely town also beckons with picturesque parks, historic landmarks, and stunning waterfront views, ensuring a perfect blend of dining and leisure experiences. Join me on a virtual tour as we uncover the Best Restaurants in Brookhaven, where every bite promises a taste of culinary excellence.

1. Varney’s Restaurant

Step into the culinary embrace of Varney’s Restaurant, a veteran establishment in Brookhaven that boasts a rich history spanning over four decades. This no-frills eatery exudes charm with its American classics, but the real stars of the show are the fresh mussels and clams that have patrons raving. Imagine indulging in a hot lobster roll, perfectly balanced with just the right amount of butter, or savoring the delicate flavors of the baked clams that are hailed as some of the best around. Pair these delights with a cold Bud Light and experience a slice of Long Island paradise right in the heart of Brookhaven. Varney’s prides itself on fast, friendly service with a touch of authentic Long Island warmth, making each visit a delightful surprise. If you’re seeking an unassuming yet exceptional dining experience, Varney’s Restaurant is your ticket to a culinary journey worth savoring.

Rating:
Price:

2. Painters’ Restaurant

Located in the vibrant town of Brookhaven, Painters’ Restaurant is a trendy gem that stands out for its floor-to-ceiling art, eclectic menu, and weekend live-music scene. Diners rave about the spectacular Easter Brunch, where the art truly shines, complementing the delicious food and drinks. The quirky atmosphere, complete with brown paper-covered tables and crayons for artistic expression, sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. From the moist meatloaf sandwich to the flavorful grilled chicken club and the heavenly roasted squash salad, every dish at Painters’ delights in its fresh and eclectic flavors. Whether you’re craving a mouthwatering burger or a delectable white pie, this restaurant promises a culinary journey worth returning for time and time again. Elevate your dining escapades at Painters’ Restaurant to savor a mix of artistry and gastronomy that will leave your taste buds tingling with joy.

Rating:
Price:

3. Brook House Pizza and Grill

Tucked in the vibrant town of Brookhaven, Brook House Pizza and Grill is a culinary haven that’s been gaining a rapid fan base. This spot is not your average pizza joint – it’s a gastronomic adventure waiting to be explored! From their mouthwatering pizzas that come with a surprise extra pie, to their hearty hamburgers and daily specials that promise to tantalize your taste buds, this place is a true hidden gem that shines through its varied menu offerings. The attentive staff, like the lovely lady with dark hair, add an extra sprinkle of charm to your dining experience. With stick-to-your-ribs comfort foods like the acclaimed Chicken Francese that’s been hailed as the best in town, Brook House Pizza and Grill is a must-visit for foodies looking to savor every bite. Indulge in their fantastic new food items, and get ready to clean your plate because leaving hungry is not an option here. Dive into a symphony of flavors that’ll have you coming back for more at this culinary hotspot in Brookhaven!

Rating:
Price: