Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Brighton, New York

Brighton, New York, is a hidden gem for food lovers. Despite its relatively small size, this town boasts an impressive array of dining options that cater to every palate. From trendy farm-to-table bistros to classic Italian trattorias, Brighton has it all. The local food scene is known for its commitment to fresh, locally sourced ingredients, resulting in dishes that burst with flavor and creativity. In addition to the delicious cuisine, Brighton offers a charming atmosphere with tree-lined streets and a vibrant arts community. Whether you’re a resident or just passing through, Brighton is a culinary destination that should not be missed.

1. Project LeanNation HQ

Located in Brighton, Project LeanNation HQ is a haven for health-conscious foodies looking to refuel after a workout session or grab a quick, nutritious bite. With top-notch reviews raving about their signature shakes like the PJ&Jacked and The Gladiator, it’s no surprise that customers keep coming back for these flavorful concoctions. The menu boasts options like the #1 with added strawberries and the clockwork orange shake, catering to both fitness enthusiasts and busy professionals looking for a convenient yet wholesome meal option. With a friendly and knowledgeable staff ready to assist, Project LeanNation HQ stands out as a must-visit spot for those seeking delicious, health-focused meals in Brighton.

Rating:
Price:

2. AVVINO

Welcome to this warm and sophisticated eatery, a hidden gem that serves up seasonal American fare and craft cocktails. From the moment you arrive, you’ll be greeted with attentive and friendly staff who will ensure your dining experience is top-notch. The restaurant is clean and organized, with a nice atmosphere that sets the stage for a romantic and fancy evening.

The menu offers a variety of delectable dishes, with standout items like the charred octopus, duck breast, and the ever-popular lamb. The octopus is a delightful appetizer, perfectly cooked and not too chewy. The duck breast is tender and moist, while the lamb, if available, is a must-try, especially when cooked to a mouthwatering medium rare.

Don’t forget to save room for dessert! The chocolate cake is described as “to die for” and is highly recommended by diners. And if you’re in the mood for a unique and well-crafted cocktail, be sure to chat with Ben, the talented bartender who knows how to stir up some amazing drinks while engaging in witty banter.

Overall, this restaurant consistently delivers exceptional service, delicious food, and a wonderful dining experience. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for a memorable meal, this hidden gem is a must-visit.

Rating:
Price:

3. Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Brighton’s culinary scene just got a whole lot cooler with Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard making waves in town. This vibrant spot offers a delightful array of Italian ices and frozen custards that will transport you straight to the streets of Philly or South Jersey. The gelati here seems to be the real showstopper, with patrons raving about its flavor and texture. The option to create your own flight of flavors adds an element of fun and personalization to the experience, ensuring each visit is a unique and exciting adventure. With top-notch service, a welcoming atmosphere, and a commitment to cleanliness, Rita’s sets the bar high for a sweet treat destination in Brighton. Whether you’re a die-hard fan or a newcomer to the world of Italian frozen delights, Rita’s is a must-visit hotspot that promises a taste of pure joy with every spoonful.

Rating:
Price:

4. ROC Cinema

Welcome to the charming and historic cinema that has been a beloved community fixture since 1914. Step into a world of cinematic nostalgia as you settle into the intimate theater with its straight antique look. The staff here is on top of their game, providing fabulous customer service and making your experience truly memorable. But it’s not just about the ambiance – the food here is a real highlight. From delicious cheese quesadillas to cheesy pizzas, there’s something for everyone. And the best part? You can order directly from your seat, thanks to the QR codes that bring up a menu for you. The theater itself may only have one screen, but it’s updated, clean, and features luxury office chairs that surprisingly offer comfort. So grab a seat, sit back, and enjoy the unusual but delightful experience of dining in a theater. Just make sure to choose a seat closer to the front for the best view. This gem of a cinema is a must-visit, and once you’ve been, it will easily become your new favorite.

Rating:
Price:

5. Dogtown

DogTown is a hidden gem in Rochester, offering a unique dining experience. From the moment you step inside, you are greeted with a lively atmosphere filled with cute puppers adorning the walls. The menu boasts an extensive selection of German-style franks, creatively named after dog breeds, as well as mouthwatering burgers and a variety of vegetarian options. The food at DogTown is beyond phenomenal, with each dish bursting with flavor. The true Rochester experience is captured perfectly in their famous garbage plate, which is as delicious as it is Instagram-worthy. The staff is incredibly friendly and the service is top-notch, even during peak hours. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, a visit to DogTown is a must for any food lover looking for a memorable dining experience.

Rating:
Price:

6. Rooney’s Restaurant

Rooney’s, nestled in a residential area, is a hidden gem that offers an upscale American menu and a long wooden bar. From the moment you enter, the staff greets you with professionalism and friendliness. The bar area exudes a warm atmosphere with polished wood and well-stocked shelves, while the dining room has an old world charm with a fireplace and exposed brick. The menu boasts a variety of delicious options, including seafood, beef, and a delightful duck selection. The food portions are just right, and the wine selection is impressive. Despite the lively crowd, the restaurant manages to maintain a cozy and inviting ambiance. Rooney’s is truly a must-visit dining destination, where you are guaranteed an enjoyable experience with exceptional service and delicious food.

Rating:
Price:

7. Sinbad’s

Sinbad’s is a vibrant and flavorful Mediterranean restaurant that offers a wide range of options, including pitas, kebabs, and Mediterranean platters. The food at Sinbad’s is truly fantastic, with each dish having its own distinct and delicious flavor. The gyro is a must-try, with delightfully crispy pita that adds to the overall experience. The appetizer Sambusek was a favorite among diners, and the service was excellent. While the food and atmosphere inside didn’t quite match, the overall dining experience was still wonderful. Sinbad’s is a great place to indulge in unique and delicious Mediterranean cuisine.

Rating:
Price:

8. Jines Restaurant

Nestled in the heart of a trendy neighborhood, Jines Restaurant is a charming Greek diner that guarantees a delightful dining experience. Boasting an all-day breakfast and a delectable spread for Sunday brunch, it’s no wonder this place draws quite the crowd. The menu features a range of mouthwatering options, such as the Mediterranean Omelette and the flavorful spanakopita. And let’s not forget about the unique quiche of the day, like the sweet potato, apple, walnut, dried cranberries, and goat cheese combo. Pair your meal with a refreshing apple cinnamon mimosa, and you’re in for a treat. The staff at Jines Restaurant is known for their exceptional service, with Erika being particularly amazing. While parking might be a bit of a challenge during peak hours, taking a short stroll through the charming streets is well worth it. With their homemade and delicious food, Jines Restaurant has become a mainstay in the Rochester dining scene, providing a reliable option for any meal of the day. So, whether you’re a local or just passing through, make sure to check out Jines Restaurant and enjoy a delightful culinary experience. Bon Appétit!

Rating:
Price:

9. Aladdin’s Natural Eatery

Welcome to this charming cafe with a covered terrace, where you’ll find a delightful menu of soups, salads, and Greek plates made with natural ingredients. As you step inside, you’ll feel the cozy and romantic ambiance, perfect for a special evening with your loved one. The variety of dishes will surely please your taste buds, from the savory cheese ravioli with chicken to the refreshing Gyro salad. The staff is extremely helpful and accommodating, ensuring a pleasant dining experience for all. If you have any dietary restrictions, there’s no need to worry as they are well-equipped to handle food allergies, such as gluten and peanuts. The portion sizes are generous and the prices surprisingly reasonable, making it an excellent value for money. And don’t forget to save room for their mouthwatering pistachio baklava, a must-try treat. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or enjoying a memorable dinner with family, this cafe is sure to leave you excited for your next visit.

Rating:
Price:

10. Max Chophouse

Situated in the vibrant town of Brighton, Max Chophouse stands out as a top-tier destination for steak aficionados and fine dining enthusiasts alike. Renowned for its prime filets and exquisite seafood offerings, this high-end chophouse exudes an air of romance and elegance that captivates guests from the moment they step inside. Patrons rave about the Australian Wagyu steak, a true gem on the menu that promises a culinary experience unlike any other. With a staff described as the epitome of politeness and thoughtfulness, the service here elevates the dining experience to new heights. From the fabulous pork chop to the mouthwatering burger and fries, each dish is crafted with precision and flair, leaving diners eager for more. The intimate setting adds a touch of nostalgia, creating a cozy yet sophisticated atmosphere for guests to savor every bite. Max Chophouse truly shines as a beacon of excellence in the realm of chophouses, where every visit promises a gastronomic journey worth every penny.

Rating:
Price: