Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Bexley, Ohio

Situated in the heart of Ohio, Bexley is a culinary haven waiting to be explored. This lovely town boasts a vibrant dining scene that is sure to delight any food enthusiast. From cozy cafes to upscale eateries, Bexley is home to some of the Best Restaurants in Ohio, offering a diverse range of flavors and culinary experiences. In addition to its gastronomic delights, this charming town also features picturesque parks, historic landmarks, and a bustling local community, making it a must-visit destination for both locals and travelers alike.

1. Scotty’s Cafe

Located in the vibrant town of Bexley, Scotty’s Cafe is a hidden gem that promises an unforgettable dining experience. Boasting an unpretentious American vibe, this cozy spot in a strip-mall setting has been making waves with its exceptional breakfast, brunch, and lunch offerings. Guests rave about the warm hospitality, with mentions of standout server Yvette and the friendly team that goes above and beyond to make you feel at home. The menu is a culinary delight, with dishes like the mouthwatering meatloaf and the tantalizing Jewish Omelette stealing the show. And let’s not forget about the Reuben with pastrami – a flavor explosion that’s a definite must-try. With a reputation for personalized service and delectable fare, Scotty’s Cafe is a true standout in the bustling food scene of Central Ohio. Get ready to be wowed and make sure to visit soon to savor the goodness for yourself!

Rating:
Price:

2. Brassica in Bexley

Located in Bexley, Brassica is a vibrant gem that promises a delightful dining adventure. With a Chipotle-style customization approach, this restaurant stands out for its fresh and top-quality ingredients. The menu features a tempting array of options, from salads loaded with colorful veggies to warm and delicious freshly made pitas. Guests rave about the flavorful brisket, cauliflower soup, and melt-in-your-mouth brisket. The outdoor patio is a lovely spot to savor your meal, and don’t miss out on their refreshing minty pink lemonade on a warm day. Brassica’s blend of healthy, satisfying dishes and friendly service make it a must-visit hotspot in Bexley for foodies seeking a taste bud worthy experience.

Rating:
Price:

3. Johnson’s Real Ice Cream

Johnson’s Real Ice Cream, a local landmark in Bexley, is a must-visit gem for all ice cream aficionados. This quaint spot offers a delightful array of housemade ice cream, sherbet, and frozen yogurt that will tantalize your taste buds. With flavors like the enticing “Rollin’ in the cookie dough” and a menu that extends to sandwiches and soups, Johnson’s caters to both the sweet tooth and savory cravings. Step into this “old school” ice cream shop that seamlessly blends nostalgia with a modern twist, offering a charming ambiance where you can enjoy your treats indoors or al fresco. It’s no wonder this place has become a beloved favorite amongst locals and visitors alike, beckoning all to savor the flavors that have made it a standout in Bexley’s culinary scene.

Rating:
Price:

4. Harvest Pizzeria Bexley

Harvest Pizzeria Bexley in Bexley is a vibrant gem amidst the culinary scene, beckoning all pizza enthusiasts and cocktail connoisseurs. The cozy modern setting sets the stage for an exceptional dining experience, as echoed by delighted patrons. From the Fried Cheese Curd Antipasto to the Blackened Salmon BLT, each dish is crafted with an unmistakable touch of love and greatness. The menu’s diverse offerings, including cauliflower appetizers, salads, and even fried chicken, cater to every palate. Rave reviews about attentive service and thoughtful staff, like Emma, Mia H., Madison L., and Augie R., further elevate this establishment’s charm. An accessible entrance, impeccable cleanliness, and complimentary amenities showcase a commitment to guest satisfaction that truly distinguishes Harvest Pizzeria Bexley as a must-visit destination in Bexley for an unforgettable culinary escapade.

Rating:
Price:

5. The Top Steak House

In the vibrant town of Bexley lies a culinary gem that is a must-visit for all steak enthusiasts – The Top Steak House. This longstanding establishment exudes sophistication with its clubby ambiance, live piano music, and impeccable service. From the rave reviews, it’s clear that The Top is more than just a restaurant; it’s an experience. Diners praise the flavorful steaks, tender ribs, and scrumptious seafood offerings. The standout dish seems to be the full rack of ribs, a steal at $30 with two sides, making it a budget-friendly delight for those in search of a hearty meal. Pair your meal with a creative cocktail whipped up by their talented bartenders, and you’re in for a treat. The old-school charm of the dining room, complete with live piano music, creates a nostalgic atmosphere that adds to the overall allure of The Top Steak House in Bexley. Be sure to swing by and indulge in a culinary journey that promises to delight your taste buds and transport you to a bygone era of classic dining elegance.

Rating:
Price:

6. Khaab Indian Kitchen & Bar

Located in the vibrant town of Bexley, Khaab Indian Kitchen & Bar is a culinary gem that has been creating quite a buzz amongst food enthusiasts. The lunch buffet seems to be a star attraction, with guests raving about the unbelievable value it offers – where else can you find such an array of delectable dishes for just $15? From the Veg Samosa and Aloo Tikki to the Lamb Curry and Chicken Biryani, each bite is a revelation, surprising even the most discerning taste buds. The ambiance of the restaurant perfectly complements the outstanding food, creating an inviting atmosphere for a memorable dining experience. The impeccable customer service only adds to the allure, with a staff that goes above and beyond to ensure every visit is nothing short of perfection. Whether you’re a local or willing to drive from afar like our friends from Hilliard, Khaab Indian Kitchen & Bar is a must-visit for anyone craving fantastic Indian cuisine that’s sure to leave you wanting more.

Rating:
Price:

7. Piada Italian Street Food

Located in the vibrant town of Bexley, Piada Italian Street Food offers a fresh take on traditional Italian cuisine that has locals and visitors alike coming back for more. Embracing a build-your-own concept, this counter-order gem allows guests to craft their perfect meal with wraps, pastas, and salads. The standout dish here is the crave-worthy calamari, described as hot, crispy, and tender, paired with a delectable marinara sauce that elevates the dining experience. The friendly staff, highlighted by mentions of exceptional service and attention to detail, truly shines at Piada. With a diverse menu that caters to both health-conscious diners and pasta enthusiasts, this modern Italian spot is a must-visit for those seeking a delightful culinary adventure in Bexley.

Rating:
Price:

8. Columbus Brewing Company Beer Hall

Situated in Bexley, the Columbus Brewing Company Beer Hall is a gem not to be missed in the realm of beer and bites. Boasting a prime location near the picturesque Franklin Park, this spot is lauded for its pristine new pilot brewery and stunning indoor-outdoor space. Specializing in west coast-style IPAs and top-tier lagers, this brewery holds its own in the Columbus beer scene. Dive into their must-try burger with curry ketchup or savor the flavors of their pepperoni pizza. With a menu that transcends typical “bar food,” this place surprises and delights even non-drinkers with options like soba noodles and sweet potato tacos. The welcoming ambiance, expansive bar, and friendly owners add to the allure, making it a destination worth revisiting for both locals and visitors alike. Indulge in their stellar brews and delectable dishes – it’s a journey for your taste buds that you won’t soon forget!

Rating:
Price:

9. Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

Located in the vibrant town of Bexley, the Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern is a gem for those craving a taste of comforting American classics in a relaxed and welcoming setting. With a spacious bar area and the option to enjoy your meal al fresco on the inviting patio, this casual tavern is a hit for both its ambiance and service. The menu, boasting a lineup of traditional favorites, is sure to satisfy any craving, from fresh and delicious dishes to a long list of beers to complement your meal perfectly. Whether you opt for street parking, the rear lot, or the nearby options, convenience is key here. And with attentive servers and a manager who cares, it’s easy to see why patrons keep coming back for more at this delightful spot in Bexley.

Rating:
Price:

10. The Old Bag of Nails Pub – Bexley

Located in the vibrant town of Bexley, The Old Bag of Nails Pub offers a delightful culinary experience that perfectly blends American comfort food with a British twist. Boasting a welcoming atmosphere and top-notch service, this local gem is a must-visit for food enthusiasts in search of a memorable dining escapade. The signature battered fish ‘n’ chips steal the show, garnering praise from patrons for their generous portions and mouthwatering flavor. Whether you’re craving a hearty meal or a refreshing Watermelon Margarita, this establishment has you covered. With a diverse menu and a charming ambiance, The Old Bag of Nails Pub is guaranteed to leave you planning your next visit before you’ve even left the table.

Rating:
Price: