Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Batavia, New York

Set amidst the picturesque landscapes of upstate New York, Batavia is a culinary treasure trove waiting to be discovered. This charming town boasts a vibrant dining scene, offering a plethora of gastronomic delights for all palates. From cozy cafes to upscale eateries, Batavia is a paradise for food enthusiasts seeking culinary adventures. Explore the Best Restaurants in Batavia and indulge in a diverse array of flavors, ranging from traditional American fare to international cuisines. After a satisfying meal, immerse yourself in the town’s rich history and culture, with attractions like the Holland Land Office Museum and Jell-O Gallery Museum.

1. Eli Fish Brewing Co.

Located in Batavia, Eli Fish Brewing Co. is a vibrant hub for beer enthusiasts and foodies alike. The rave reviews speak volumes about the quick service, diverse brew selection, and delectable dishes that keep patrons coming back for more. From the raspberry hard cider to the nitrous Scotch ale, the array of beverages promises a delightful experience for every palate. The attentive staff, highlighted by a standout waitress, adds a personal touch to your dining experience, ensuring you feel right at home. Don’t miss out on their signature beer brined chicken paired with a refreshing beer flight for a true taste sensation. Eli Fish Brewing Co. is a must-visit gem in Batavia, promising a memorable culinary adventure that will have you planning your next visit before you’ve even left.

Rating:
Price:

2. Main Street Pizza Company

Tantalizing taste buds in Batavia, Main Street Pizza Company crafts a delightful experience for pizza aficionados and wing enthusiasts alike. Picture this – a cozy, old-school joint where deep-dish and thin-crust pies reign supreme, alongside a medley of subs and wings that have patrons singing praises. Imaginative customization options, like swapping red sauce for pesto on pizzas, cater to even the most discerning palates. With nods to stellar service and diverse wing sauces, like the standout bourbon concoction, the reviews resonate with the sentiment of a hidden gem just waiting to be discovered. From the inviting family atmosphere to the homemade pasta marvels paired with delectable mozzarella wedges, each bite tells a story of culinary craftsmanship and community spirit. Whether you’re a local regular or a first-time visitor, Main Street Pizza Company beckons with open arms and a promise of unforgettable flavors that linger long after the last bite. Unearth this Batavia treasure trove and let your taste buds embark on a savory journey through this culinary haven.

Rating:
Price:

3. Bourbon & Burger Co.

Situated in Batavia, Bourbon & Burger Co. is a culinary gem offering a tantalizing array of specialty burgers and a remarkable selection of small-batch bourbons, making it a haven for foodies and spirit enthusiasts alike. The pub-style ambiance provides a welcoming backdrop for indulging in mouthwatering creations while savoring craft brews on tap. Guests rave about the California Avocado Burger, a flavorful masterpiece that promises to tantalize taste buds. Patrons also praise the attentive staff and the inviting decor, ensuring a memorable dining experience from start to finish. Whether you’re a burger aficionado or a bourbon connoisseur, Bourbon & Burger Co. promises a feast for the senses that is not to be missed when in Batavia.

Rating:
Price:

4. Settler’s Family Restaurant

Located in the quaint town of Batavia, Settler’s Family Restaurant is a true gem offering a delightful fusion of American and Mediterranean cuisine that will leave your taste buds dancing with joy. From their impeccably fast service to the homely ambiance where locals gather, this longtime family-run eatery has perfected the art of delivering a cozy dining experience. Indulge in their french dip sandwich, boasting thinly sliced roast beef on a fresh hoagie roll, paired perfectly with a side of crispy tater tots. Breakfast enthusiasts rejoice, as the menu is brimming with tempting options that promise to make every visit a memorable culinary journey. Whether you’re a local looking for a familiar spot or a traveler seeking a delicious meal, Settler’s Family Restaurant is a must-visit destination in Batavia for a heartwarming dining experience.

Rating:
Price:

5. Tully’s Good Times Batavia

If you’re searching for a lively spot to indulge in some classic American pub grub in Batavia, look no further than Tully’s Good Times. Nestled in the heart of the city, Tully’s exudes a vibrant atmosphere perfect for a family outing or a casual hangout with friends. The rave reviews speak volumes about their delectable chicken tenders, touted as a must-try on their menu. Pair these crispy delights with a wide array of drink options while soaking in the sporty ambiance that this local gem offers. With top-notch service and a free popcorn prelude, Tully’s Good Times stands out as a go-to dining spot for a satisfying and fun culinary experience in Batavia.

Rating:
Price:

6. Rancho Viejo Authentic Mex

Dive into a fiesta for your taste buds at Rancho Viejo Authentic Mex in Batavia! This colorful and festive Mexican restaurant has become a local gem, winning hearts with its traditional fare and top-notch service. Enchiladas seem to be a fan-favorite, hailed for their consistent deliciousness. And for those looking for a variety of flavors, the taco salad, burritos, rice, beans, and heavenly churros are a must-try. The vibrant atmosphere, paired with attentive staff, ensures an unforgettable dining experience. If you’re craving an authentic Mexican culinary adventure, Rancho Viejo is your ticket to flavor paradise in Batavia!

Rating:
Price:

7. T F Brown’s Restaurant

Located in Batavia, T F Brown’s Restaurant is not your average dining spot. This upbeat family-owned sports bar & grill is a gem for both locals and visitors alike. With over 20 TVs, a bowling alley, and a small arcade room, the entertainment options are endless. The menu boasts hearty pub grub that keeps customers coming back for more. From perfectly cooked steaks to delightful mac n’ cheese with bacon, each dish is a flavorful adventure. The vibrant atmosphere, quick and friendly service, and diverse beer selection make this place a standout in the area. So, if you’re looking for a spot with great food, entertainment, and a welcoming vibe, T F Brown’s Restaurant is a must-visit in Batavia.

Rating:
Price:

8. Alex’s Place

Welcome to Alex’s Place in Batavia, a hub of tantalizing American BBQ and juicy steaks that keep locals and travelers coming back for more. Nestled in cozy, old-fashioned quarters with a lively bar, this spot has garnered rave reviews for its mouthwatering dishes. Guests have praised the seafood pasta brimming with shrimp, scallops, and mussels in a scampi-style sauce, as well as the haddock stuffed with crab and the apple brandy chop. Don’t miss out on their homemade pies; the Coconut Cream and Apple varieties are simply irresistible. With exceptional service, reasonable prices, and a welcoming atmosphere, Alex’s Place is a must-visit for anyone craving a top-notch dining experience in Batavia.

Rating:
Price:

9. Dunkin’

In the bustling town of Batavia, the renowned Dunkin’ stands out as a beacon of breakfast brilliance and coffee connoisseurship. As echoed by one enthusiastic reviewer, the staff’s dedication to exceptional service shines through, with a heartwarming anecdote about kindness prevailing over a coupon mishap. This heartening tale not only speaks volumes about the team’s commitment to customer satisfaction but also serves as a gentle reminder to treat service staff with the respect and appreciation they deserve. With signature breakfast delights and a diverse array of caffeinated creations, Dunkin’ in Batavia emerges as a must-visit destination for those seeking not just a meal, but a memorable experience infused with warmth and goodwill.

Rating:
Price:

10. Batavia Downs Gaming

Located in Batavia, Batavia Downs Gaming offers a unique 1940s-era vibe that seamlessly blends live harness racing with over 600 gaming terminals and a vibrant sports bar & grill. Visitors rave about the energetic atmosphere, with one guest highlighting the thrilling experience that rivals larger casinos without traditional table games. The friendly staff and impeccably clean surroundings add to the overall charm, making it a standout destination. Guests also praise the spacious and modern hotel rooms, some offering picturesque views of the track where horses gracefully exercise in the morning, adding a touch of surrealism to the stay. The inclusive breakfast buffet, set against the backdrop of horses on the track, is a delightful way to start the day. With affordable and appetizing food options, coupled with a welcoming ambiance, Batavia Downs Gaming promises a memorable and enjoyable experience for all who visit.

Rating:
Price: