Best Restaurants in Barnegat Light, New Jersey

Located in Barnegat Light, Jen’s Links at Lighthouse Cove is a gem waiting to be uncovered for those seeking a delightful dining experience. With raving reviews highlighting its well-kept courses, offering up to 36 holes of engaging play, this spot is a haven for both families and avid mini-golf enthusiasts. Dive into a ship-themed adventure, navigate challenging holes, and enjoy the thrill of the game while basking in the shaded outdoor dining area. Don’t miss out on their delectable pizza, a crowd-pleaser that adds a flavorful twist to your visit. At $13 to play, this spot promises not only a memorable game but also a satisfying culinary experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Located in Barnegat Light, 18th Street Kitchen + Takeout is a culinary gem that has been delighting diners with its delectable offerings for over 40 years. Boasting a menu filled with fresh seafood and perfectly cooked dishes, this family-run establishment has garnered rave reviews for its flavorful crab cakes, perfectly executed filet mignon, and mouthwatering lobster tail. Patrons have commended the friendly service and generous portion sizes, making it a top choice for both locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re craving a savory swordfish or a satisfying vegetarian option, 18th Street Kitchen + Takeout is sure to exceed your expectations and leave you planning your next visit. Don’t miss the chance to indulge in a culinary experience that promises to tantalize your taste buds and leave you coming back for more.

Located in Barnegat Light, Mustache Bill’s Diner is a delightful gem serving up homestyle breakfasts and lunches in a retro, 1950s-style setting. Boasting a 4.6 rating, this cash-only diner has garnered rave reviews for its fresh and flavorful dishes. Customers can’t stop raving about the omelets, with standout mentions of the liverwurst & onion sandwich and the potato skin omelette. The cozy ambiance and friendly service add to the charm, making it a must-visit spot on LBI. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Mustache Bill’s is the perfect stop for a delicious, reasonably priced meal that’s sure to leave you satisfied.

Located in Barnegat Light, Agnello’s is making waves with its signature sandwiches that are generously stuffed with high-quality meats, drawing rave reviews from patrons. The breakfast sandwiches have also emerged as a crowd favorite, earning the title of the best in town from satisfied customers. With a menu that boasts of ample portions and reasonable prices, dining at Agnello’s promises a delightful experience that showcases the essence of local island flavors. The friendly staff adds a welcoming touch to this culinary gem, ensuring that every visit is met with warmth and satisfaction. For those seeking a taste of the island life year-round, Agnello’s stands out for its commitment to serving delectable meals even when the island is at rest, truly embodying the spirit of hospitality and island living.

In the charming town of Barnegat Light, Kubel’s stands out as a must-visit gem for those craving a taste of authentic American eats with a side of seaside charm. Situated in a cozy space complete with a crackling fireplace and a lively bar, this place has quickly become a local favorite for its impeccable seafood offerings. From the iconic sunsets casting a golden glow over Barnegat Bay to the friendly service that goes above and beyond, Kubel’s is where culinary excellence meets island vibes. Dive into a bowl of hearty clam chowder, savor the fresh steamed clams, or indulge in the “clam-azing” fried clam strips that are sure to leave you craving more. With standout dishes like lobster bisque, lobster rolls, and lobster mac n cheese that are simply perfection, Kubel’s has set the bar high for a dining experience that’s as unforgettable as a coastal breeze. Whether you’re a local looking for your next go-to spot or a visitor seeking an exceptional meal, Kubel’s promises to deliver a culinary adventure that will have you coming back for more.

Nestled in the charming town of Barnegat Light, Viking Fresh Off the Hook is a seafood haven that’s creating quite a buzz among foodies. With glowing reviews praising their dishes, it’s no surprise that this spot stands out among the best restaurants in Barnegat Light. The warm lobster roll and Zuppa Di pesce seem to be crowd favorites, enticing diners with their fresh flavors and generous portions. Not to mention the scallop bisque, a hidden gem that begs to be tried. Offering a simple yet delectable menu, Viking Fresh Off the Hook ensures a memorable dining experience with every visit. So, if you find yourself craving top-notch seafood in a casual setting, this spot is a definite must-try!

In the heart of Barnegat Light stands Kelly’s Old Barney Restaurant, a hidden gem adored by locals and visitors alike. Nestled just steps away from the iconic Barnegat Light House, Kelly’s offers a warm welcome and a true taste of New Jersey hospitality. Whether you’re craving a classic Philly Cheese Steak or a hearty breakfast done to perfection, Kelly’s menu is sure to delight. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service, like the delightful Shana, make every visit feel like a homecoming. Don’t miss out on their exquisite chowders and the convenience of an attached Dairy Queen for a sweet treat. With cash-only transactions adding to the charm, Kelly’s Old Barney Restaurant is a must-visit for a genuine dining experience that captures the essence of Barnegat Light. Come for the food, stay for the memories – Kelly’s promises to leave you longing for more.

Located in Barnegat Light, Daymark is a rustic-chic gem that promises a culinary journey like no other. Embracing seasonal, globally inspired American fare, this spot stands out for its quality seafood dishes and inviting ambiance. With large windows that flood the space with natural light, Daymark offers a comforting atmosphere that pairs perfectly with their delicious menu offerings. From the flavorful calamari and goat cheese gnocchi appetizers to the mouthwatering crab cakes and organic chicken, every dish is a masterpiece bursting with taste. And let’s not forget about the well-balanced and strong drinks that elevate the dining experience. Whether you’re looking for a family-friendly outing or a cozy happy hour spot, Daymark is a must-visit destination for those seeking fine dining with a touch of charm in Barnegat Light.

La Riva in Barnegat Light has quickly become a local gem, drawing diners back for more with its exquisite dishes. The Margherita pizza seems to be a clear standout, hailed as a potential contender for the best pizza ever tasted by one enthusiastic patron. Even with a slight cheese critique, it still shines as a favorite. The Stacciatella salad also receives glowing praise, ensuring a well-rounded dining experience. The Jersey Corn Pizza seems to be a must-try, as recommended by their attentive server Sophie, adding a delightful touch to the menu. With rave reviews and dishes that leave patrons craving more, La Riva promises a culinary experience that’s bound to impress.