Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Appleton, Wisconsin

Situated in the heart of Wisconsin, Appleton is a culinary haven waiting to be explored. This charming town boasts a vibrant dining scene with a diverse array of eateries, making it a must-visit for food enthusiasts. From cozy cafes and trendy bistros to upscale restaurants, Appleton offers a delightful mix of flavors to tantalize your taste buds. Beyond its gastronomic delights, this lovely town is also home to a variety of attractions, including picturesque parks, cultural landmarks, and bustling markets. Join us on a gastronomic journey through the Best Restaurants in Appleton, where every bite tells a story of culinary excellence.

1. Mill City Public House

Situated in Appleton, Mill City Public House is a culinary gem not to be missed in the Fox Valley. The reviews speak for themselves, with diners raving about the fantastic food, top-notch service, and inviting atmosphere. From the mouth-watering smoked ribs to the unique spinach and artichoke dip with a smoky twist, every dish seems to be a flavor-packed delight. The New York sour cocktail and gourmet entrees add a touch of sophistication to the experience, while Bob Ross vibes and attentive staff create a welcoming ambiance. With servers like Alex who elevate the dining experience with humor and expertise, every visit to Mill City promises to be a memorable one. Whether you’re craving a Prime Rib Philly Steak Sandwich or a perfectly seasoned Salmon BLT, this restaurant is sure to satisfy your culinary cravings. Don’t miss out on this hidden culinary treasure in Appleton, where every bite is a truly delightful experience!

Rating:
Price:

2. Sangria’s Mexican Grill

Situated in the vibrant town of Appleton, Sangria’s Mexican Grill is a colorful gem offering a taste of Veracruz right at your table. With a margarita happy hour that’s clearly a hit among patrons, this spot is celebrated for its Jalapeño margaritas and generous portions like the Al Pastor burrito and enchilada sampler. Guests rave about the fresh guacamole made tableside, along with the mouthwatering salsa that accompanies their crispy chips. The lively and attentive waitstaff at Sangria’s adds an extra layer of fun to the dining experience, leaving diners laughing and fully satisfied. If you’re seeking a top-notch Mexican dining adventure in Appleton, Sangria’s is where you’ll find yourself indulging in delicious food, great margaritas, and exceptional service that will have you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

3. Rye Restaurant

In the vibrant town of Appleton, situated within the chic CopperLeaf Hotel, lies Rye Restaurant, a gem offering an enchanting blend of New American cuisine and artisanal cocktails in a cozy, stylish setting. With an outpour of rave reviews, it’s evident that Rye is a culinary beacon not to be missed. Guests are captivated by the tantalizing cheese curds, described as a flavorful indulgence that could make taste buds sing with joy. The wagyu burger and root beer braised short ribs have been hailed as culinary masterpieces that promise a symphony of flavors, while the winter bread pudding leaves diners swooning with its perfect balance of sweetness. The Whisky Bacon Shrimp is a must-try, accompanied by a divine sauce that beckons for bread dipping. And let’s not forget the attention to detail in service, with staff members exuding warmth and attentiveness that elevate the overall dining experience. Whether you’re a local or a traveler in search of gastronomic delights, Rye Restaurant promises an unforgettable culinary journey that will have you planning your next visit before you’ve even left the table.

Rating:
Price:

4. Sai Ram Indian Cuisine

In the vibrant town of Appleton sits Sai Ram Indian Cuisine, a polished gem known for its delectable Indian fare. With a lunch buffet that’s a steal and a selection of craft beers and wines to complement your meal, this spot offers a culinary journey that’s hard to resist. Guests rave about the Chana Masala, Beef Vindaloo, and Chicken Makhani, all bursting with authentic flavors that will transport you straight to India. The welcoming ambiance, accommodating staff, and generous portions make dining here a delightful experience. Let’s not forget the star of the show – the naan bread, which has been described as “life-changing” and “amazing”. If you find yourself in the area, don’t miss the chance to savor the exceptional dishes at Sai Ram – a true culinary treasure in the Fox Valley!

Rating:
Price:

5. Katsu-Ya of Japan

Situated in the heart of Appleton, Katsu-Ya of Japan is a culinary gem that beckons all sushi enthusiasts and hibachi aficionados alike. With a flair for creativity and a nod to tradition, this contemporary chain outpost has garnered rave reviews for its inventive sushi rolls and flavorful hibachi grill fare. Diners have sung praises for the tender, well-marinated meats paired with delectable sauces like the garlic and spicy options. The Torched New Style Sashimi, a fan favorite, is a must-try delicacy that promises to tantalize your taste buds with its torched salmon and snapper topped with cilantro, fresh ginger, and ponzu. Beyond the impeccable gastronomic offerings, Katsu-Ya of Japan wins hearts with its outstanding service, speedy delivery of scrumptious dishes, and a chic ambiance perfect for any occasion, be it a cozy dinner for two or a lively group gathering. For a dining experience that seamlessly blends quality, variety, and a touch of entertainment, Katsu-Ya of Japan emerges as a top contender in Appleton’s vibrant culinary scene.

Rating:
Price:

6. Mark’s East Side

Located in the charming town of Appleton, Mark’s East Side is a gem for those seeking delectable German-American cuisine in a warm and inviting setting. Boasting a rich history and run by a dedicated family, this venue has captured the hearts of many with its exceptional service and inviting atmosphere. Diners rave about the schnitzel, hailed as a true standout on the menu, showcasing the culinary mastery behind every dish. The ribeye, though slightly undercooked for one patron, still managed to impress with its bold flavors. From the well-loved calamari appetizer to the generously portioned prime rib, every bite at Mark’s East Side is a testament to their commitment to delivering quality fare. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular patron, the experience here promises to be nothing short of extraordinary, making it a must-visit destination in the vibrant culinary scene of Appleton.

Rating:
Price:

7. The Red Ox Seafood and Steakhouse

In the heart of Appleton lies The Red Ox Seafood and Steakhouse, a classic supper club where time-honored charm meets top-notch quality. Step into a bygone era with a modern twist, where the prime rib is described as “bloody” in the best way possible, and the Midwest atmosphere adds to the treasure that this place truly is. Indulge in the Door County cherry haddock fillet or the flavorful 8oz tenderloin, cooked to perfection just as you like it. Don’t forget to start with the spinach and artichoke dip, a crowd-pleaser that’s best enjoyed spread on warm bread. With prompt and spectacular service that makes every visit feel like the first, The Red Ox is a true gem that never disappoints. Make sure to save room for dessert – it’s complimentary for birthdays, adding that extra touch of sweetness to an already memorable dining experience. Reservations are highly recommended, ensuring you secure your spot in the spacious and inviting dining area of this Wisconsin supper club. Come for the food, stay for the nostalgia, and leave with a satisfied appetite that will have you planning your next visit before you even finish your meal. A must-visit for anyone seeking a taste of tradition with a dash of modern flair in the bustling town of Appleton!

Rating:
Price:

8. Stone Arch Brewpub

Situated in the historic Appleton Brewery complex, Stone Arch Brewpub is a gem for both beer enthusiasts and foodies alike. The brewery’s revival of the flagship Adler Brau label adds a touch of nostalgia to the experience, while the diverse range of unique brews keeps things fresh. The ambiance, akin to a castle with its stone and brick interior, sets the stage for a memorable dining adventure. From the delectable Barley Wine Beer to the perfectly cooked scallops with a surprising pumpkin twist, each dish showcases a blend of creativity and skill. Don’t miss out on the beer flights and house vinaigrette made with their IPA – they’re true winners. While the cheese curds might fall slightly short, the promise of substantial and delicious schnitzel beckons for a return visit. With friendly service, a charming atmosphere, and standout dishes like the fried pickle chips, Stone Arch Brewpub is a must-visit destination in Appleton for a delightful culinary journey.

Rating:
Price:

9. Antojitos Mexicanos

Welcome to Antojitos Mexicanos, a vibrant gem in Appleton that promises a flavorful fiesta for your taste buds! Step into this colorful space and prepare to be dazzled by a modern Mexican menu that caters to all, including a plethora of vegetarian options that will make your heart sing with joy. Sip on Margarita flights while exploring their fantastic fare, like the Enchiladas Bajio bursting with flavor or the tantalizing Los Amigos tacos. The service here is top-notch, with friendly staff ensuring your dining experience is nothing short of exceptional. Don’t miss out on their signature Jalapeños Margarita if you’re feeling adventurous! With outstanding dishes and a lively ambiance, Antojitos Mexicanos is a must-visit spot for anyone craving quality Mexican cuisine in Appleton. Get ready to elevate your dining experience to new heights at this dynamic eatery!

Rating:
Price:

10. Tipsy Taco & Tequila Bar

In the vibrant town of Appleton, Tipsy Taco & Tequila Bar beckons with its lively atmosphere and tantalizing menu. Whether you’re seeking a night of margaritas or a culinary adventure, this spot promises an unforgettable experience. Diving into their creative vegetarian options is a must—the Brussels sprouts, cauliflower, and mushroom tacos are a flavorful revelation that even the most devout meat-eaters will savor. The spacious and welcoming setting, complete with a stunning bar area and ample seating, sets the stage for a memorable outing. With friendly staff ready to guide you through the menu and a recent menu refresh that has left patrons eagerly anticipating their next visit, Tipsy Taco & Tequila Bar is a gem waiting to be discovered in Appleton’s culinary scene.

Rating:
Price: