Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Amsterdam, New York

Situated in the heart of New York, Amsterdam beckons with a culinary scene as vibrant as its rich history. This lovely town boasts a delightful array of eateries, making it a haven for foodies seeking an unforgettable dining experience. From cozy cafes to upscale bistros, Amsterdam offers a diverse selection of gastronomic delights sure to tantalize every palate. Beyond its gastronomy, this charming town also features attractions like historic sites, scenic parks, and cultural venues, making it a must-visit destination for travelers craving a perfect blend of food and exploration. Join me as we embark on a journey to uncover the Best Restaurants in Amsterdam, New York.

1. Lorenzo’s Southside

Located in Amsterdam, Lorenzo’s Southside is a culinary gem that has been captivating diners with its delectable offerings. Picture this: a cozy ambiance with heat lamps adding just the right touch, a warm greeting from the owner, and complimentary bites like tomato pie that will leave you craving for more. The menu boasts a variety of options, from mouth-watering pasta dishes like gnocchi pomodoro to crowd-pleasing favorites like the make-your-own pasta experience. Pair your meal with a seasonal brew or indulge in an Italian Old Fashioned. Whether you’re a local looking for your new favorite spot or a traveler passing through, Lorenzo’s Southside promises a dining experience that is as delightful as it is delicious. Don’t miss out on this culinary haven – your taste buds will thank you!

Rating:
Price:

2. Europa Cafe

Europa Cafe in Amsterdam is a delightful find that truly embodies the charm of a small independent diner. The menu boasts delectable offerings like eggs over easy with corned beef hash, perfectly paired with a thoughtful touch of asking if you’d like the eggs on top. The ambiance exudes intimacy and warmth, with strong, freshly brewed coffee that keeps guests coming back for more. From the friendly and attentive staff to the quirky details like a cute greeting from their resident cat, Europa Cafe promises a memorable dining experience. So, if you’re seeking a spot for a top-notch breakfast or brunch in Amsterdam, look no further than this gem of a cafe!

Rating:
Price:

3. Stewart’s Shops

Located in Amsterdam, Stewart’s Shops is not your average convenience store. Boasting its own delectable ice cream flavors, freshly brewed coffee, and a variety of snacks and groceries, this gem has clearly won over the hearts of patrons. From the rave reviews about the exceptionally kind manager Justina to the friendly staff and top-notch service, Stewart’s Shops goes above and beyond to create a welcoming atmosphere for customers of all ages. Dive into a scoop of their renowned ice cream, sip on a piping hot cup of coffee, and explore their array of convenience items – a visit to Stewart’s is sure to leave you craving more of their delightful offerings.

Rating:
Price:

4. Slice

Situated in the vibrant heart of Amsterdam, Slice is a top contender for the title of the cleanest pizza haven in town. Boasting wood-fired pies that are nothing short of perfection, this spot has patrons raving about its impeccable crust with a tantalizing Maillard reaction and cheese featuring delightful leoparding. The house-made mild sauce adds a zesty kick to the already flavorful chicken wings, making for a memorable dining experience. With a staff that makes you feel right at home and a cozy ambiance, this gem is a must-visit for food enthusiasts looking for a slice of pizza paradise in Amsterdam.

Rating:
Price:

5. Russo’s Grill

Located in the vibrant town of Amsterdam, Russo’s Grill is a longstanding gem for pizza aficionados. Boasting a signature chunky sauce that bursts with flavor, their pizzas are hailed as top-notch by loyal patrons. The menu showcases a delightful array of options, from gluten-free mushroom & sausage pizzas to delectable sausage and chicken wings paired with a refreshing house salad. Quick service, delectable dishes, and a friendly staff make dining at Russo’s an absolute pleasure for both locals and passersby. Whether you’re a fan of traditional classics or eclectic combinations, this charming spot is a must-visit for a satisfying culinary experience in Amsterdam.

Rating:
Price:

6. Shorty’s

Located in the vibrant town of Amsterdam, Shorty’s is a bustling local gem that has captured the hearts of food enthusiasts with its American comfort fare and delectable pizzas. The outpouring of love for this cozy joint is palpable – from patrons raving about the warm hospitality of owners Chris and Jamie to the mouthwatering weekend specials that keep them coming back for more. Whether you’re savoring a classic burger or delighting in the flavors of an Italian sandwich, Shorty’s promises a memorable culinary experience that leaves you planning your next visit before you’ve even finished your meal. With a welcoming atmosphere, top-notch service, and a menu that caters to both solo diners and families alike, Shorty’s is a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a taste of comfort and hospitality in Amsterdam.

Rating:
Price:

7. Bosco’s

Located in the vibrant city of Amsterdam, Bosco’s is a delightful Italian gem that has captured the hearts and taste buds of locals and visitors alike. With a cozy ambiance and a menu boasting old-world basics like delectable pizza and pasta, this simple Italian joint impresses not only with its food but also with its exceptional service. One reviewer praised the friendly staff, noting their attentiveness and the welcoming atmosphere. Another raved about the convenience of delivery, with the restaurant going the extra mile to ensure customer satisfaction. Whether you’re craving a satisfying pasta dish or a mouthwatering pizza, Bosco’s delivers on both fronts, accompanied by affordable wine and irresistible bread that keeps patrons coming back for more. Embrace the inviting “home vibe” and immerse yourself in a culinary experience that promises to delight your palate. Bosco’s is a must-visit spot for anyone seeking the best Italian fare in Amsterdam.

Rating:
Price:

8. Rosito’s Bakery

In the heart of Amsterdam, Rosito’s Bakery is a true gem for those seeking delectable treats and custom cakes. From whimsical wedding creations to mouthwatering bear claws, each bite tells a story of craftsmanship and dedication. The funfetti wedding cake seems to be a crowd favorite, leaving guests in awe of both taste and artistry. With glowing reviews praising the personalized service and top-notch quality, Rosito’s Bakery is a must-visit for anyone craving a sweet sensation in Amsterdam.

Rating:
Price:

9. Bottisti’s Pizzeria

Situated in the vibrant town of Amsterdam, Bottisti’s Pizzeria is a true gem for pizza enthusiasts. Rave reviews about their mouthwatering pies are flooding in, with customers praising the fresh ingredients, thin and crispy crust, and a delightful array of toppings that include extra cheese, mushrooms, sausage, bacon, and pepperoni. With a legacy spanning over 60 years, this pizzeria has mastered the art of crafting both thin and thick crust styles that keep patrons coming back for more. While the online menu might be a bit elusive, a quick visit to their bustling Facebook page will surely tantalize your taste buds. Indulge in their generously-sized circular pizza offerings at unbeatable prices, making Bottisti’s a top contender for the title of the best pizza joint in Amsterdam. Whether you’re a long-time fan or a newcomer to the pizza scene, Bottisti’s Pizzeria promises a culinary experience that’s bound to leave you craving another slice.

Rating:
Price:

10. Sharp Shooters Billards Pub

Situated in vibrant downtown Amsterdam, Sharp Shooters Billards Pub is a quintessential gem that embodies the essence of a welcoming neighborhood haunt. The buzz around this place is palpable, with reviewers raving about the consistent quality of the food and the friendly, attentive staff that make you feel right at home. From savoring a perfectly spiced Buffalo chicken wrap with piping hot fries to enjoying flawlessly poured drinks amidst the lively ambiance, every visit promises to be a delightful experience. With a stage set for great events, brand new pool tables, and a bar offering fantastic prices on beer, Sharp Shooters Billards Pub is a must-visit destination for both locals and visitors alike. Get ready to immerse yourself in the Cheers-like atmosphere and indulge in a culinary journey that will leave you planning your next return before you’ve even left.

Rating:
Price: