Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Amherst, Ohio

Situated in the heart of Ohio, Amherst is a culinary paradise waiting to be explored. This quaint town boasts a vibrant dining scene that caters to every palate, making it a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts. From cozy cafes serving up artisanal coffee to elegant fine dining establishments, Amherst offers a diverse range of culinary experiences. In addition to its gastronomic delights, this lovely town is also home to charming boutiques, historic landmarks, and scenic parks, making it a delightful place to explore beyond its delectable eateries. Join me as we uncover the Best Restaurants in Amherst, Ohio, and discover the flavors that define this charming Midwestern town.

1. Cole’s Public House

Located in the vibrant town of Amherst, Cole’s Public House is a culinary gem not to be missed. Diving into their menu, one can’t help but be enticed by standout dishes like the elk chop, which has been described as truly fantastic by diners eager to savor unique flavors. The Apple and Brie burger is a fan favorite, accompanied by irresistibly good fries. With a cozy and clean ambiance, this spot strikes the perfect balance between a lively bar atmosphere and a quiet dining experience. The attentive staff, highlighted by server Ryan’s exceptional service, ensures a memorable visit, where every request is met with a smile. Fresh salads, flavorful entrees like the prime rib sandwich, and intriguing sides such as truffle fries and broccoli cauliflower salad with chicken, all contribute to the rave reviews of this establishment. Cole’s Public House is a must-visit for food enthusiasts seeking a delightful culinary adventure in Amherst.

Rating:
Price:

2. Olde Town Pizza House

Located in Amherst, Olde Town Pizza House has captured the hearts of pizza lovers far and wide with its mouthwatering creations. Dive into their menu and discover a world of flavors that extend beyond the ordinary, with classics like the veggie soup that packs a punch and a Pizza Hut that’s truly a slice of heaven. Whether you’re a fan of Midwest-style cheesy goodness or looking to indulge in colossal breadsticks, this spot is a must-visit. And if you’re feeling adventurous, don’t miss out on their renowned deep dish pizza. Olde Town Pizza House isn’t just a dining experience; it’s a flavorful journey waiting to be explored.

Rating:
Price:

3. Ziggy’s Pub & Restaurant

Located in Amherst, Ziggy’s Pub & Restaurant is a vibrant American bar and grill that’s a bustling hotspot for locals and visitors alike. With a diverse menu that includes mouthwatering dishes like chicken fajita wraps, chicken carbonara, and bacon cheddar burgers, along with tempting sides such as beer-battered fries and crispy pierogies, Ziggy’s offers a culinary experience that will leave your taste buds singing. The atmosphere exudes a cozy charm with its brick-lined walls and hardwood floors, creating the perfect backdrop for enjoying a delicious meal. Whether you’re looking to host a special event in their spacious party room or simply craving a satisfying lunch, Ziggy’s delivers top-notch service and flavors that will keep you coming back for more. Culinary excellence and a lively ambiance make Ziggy’s a must-visit destination in Amherst for food enthusiasts seeking a memorable dining experience.

Rating:
Price:

4. Blue Sky Restaurant

Located in the vibrant town of Amherst, Blue Sky Restaurant is a culinary gem that has captured the hearts (and appetites) of locals and visitors alike. With rave reviews highlighting the exceptional service, it’s no surprise patrons frequent this spot for its friendly and efficient staff. Diners can indulge in a variety of mouthwatering dishes, from flavorful omelets to hearty chicken salad plates, all made with fresh ingredients that stand out from the usual processed fare. If you’re looking for a change from the Thanksgiving leftovers, the “Big Bob” fish sandwich comes highly recommended, offering a generous portion of perfectly prepared fish, crispy fries, and a side of clam chowder, all at an unbeatable value. Whether you’re a regular or a first-timer, Blue Sky Restaurant promises a delightful dining experience that will keep you coming back for more. Time to treat your taste buds to a memorable meal at one of Amherst’s finest eateries!

Rating:
Price:

5. Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

Located in Amherst, Dairy Queen Grill & Chill is not your average fast-food joint. With a reputation for serving up hot and fresh delights, this establishment stands out for its attention to detail and quality. Customers rave about the friendly staff who go the extra mile to ensure that every order is spot on. Whether indulging in their signature shakes or savoring a classic burger and fries combo, Dairy Queen Grill & Chill promises a treat for your taste buds that’s served with a side of genuine care and exceptional service. A must-visit spot for those craving a delicious experience in Amherst!

Rating:
Price:

6. The Brew Kettle Amherst

In the vibrant town of Amherst, The Brew Kettle offers a delightful culinary experience that goes beyond the ordinary. Guests rave about the exceptional service provided by Kimmie and Jacob, setting the stage for memorable gatherings and events. The inviting patio, complete with a cozy “fire wall” and soothing water fountains, sets the scene for a perfect evening out. Whether indulging in the veggie mac, rosemary potatoes, or sipping on a refreshing Moscow mule, every dish promises to tantalize the taste buds. With a seamless blend of country music playing in the background and efficient service, The Brew Kettle in Amherst encapsulates the essence of a top-tier dining destination that leaves patrons eagerly anticipating their next visit.

Rating:
Price:

7. Hot Dog Heaven

Hot Dog Heaven in Amherst is a longstanding gem that has been dishing out mouthwatering hot dogs and burgers since 1976. Step into this casual, fast-food eatery that exudes nostalgia with a modern twist, as mentioned by diners revisiting after years and finding the same delicious flavors in an upgraded setting. The friendly vibes extend to the service, with one reviewer noting the patience and support given to new staff, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. Guests have raved about the classic offerings like “the works” and chili cheese hot dogs, paired perfectly with seasoned fries that are simply irresistible. Don’t forget to add a sprinkle of charm by using the seasoning provided on the tables. Hot Dog Heaven truly lives up to its name, beckoning patrons to come back for more of their beloved comfort food favorites.

Rating:
Price:

8. Dunkin’

Located in the vibrant town of Amherst, Dunkin’ stands out as a beloved go-to spot for a quick and satisfying meal. With a plethora of signature breakfast items and an array of coffee drinks, this long-running chain has perfected the art of convenience without compromising on quality. Raving about the friendly staff and the efficient service, customers appreciate the affordable prices and the seamless ordering process through the app. Whether you’re in need of a pick-me-up coffee or a flavorful treat, Dunkin’ guarantees a delightful experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

9. Moosehead BBQ Grill

Located in Amherst, Moosehead BBQ Grill offers a mouthwatering array of elevated pub grub in a cozy lodge setting. Dive into their juicy and flavorful chicken tacos, crispy wings, and unique take on poutine that won’t disappoint. The Spicy Mac is a must-try for mac n’ cheese enthusiasts, providing a deliciously hot twist on a classic dish. With attentive servers and a welcoming ambiance, this spot is not just a restaurant, but an experience. Whether you’re craving BBQ nachos, amazing ribs, or simply a friendly atmosphere after a cheer competition, Moosehead BBQ Grill is a top choice for hearty and satisfying meals in Amherst.

Rating:
Price:

10. Bob Evans

In the bustling town of Amherst, Bob Evans stands as a beacon of hearty farm-to-table delights. This casual gem, originating from an Ohio farm, has made a name for itself with its wholesome family-style fare and charming country atmosphere. Customers rave about the seamless experience, like one satisfied diner who effortlessly picked up their Thanksgiving platters, praising the fantastic feast and abundant portions. With such efficiency and deliciousness on offer, it’s no wonder Bob Evans comes highly recommended for those seeking a satisfying and fuss-free dining experience in Amherst.

Rating:
Price: