Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Newtown, Ohio

Set against the charming backdrop of Ohio, Newtown beckons with a delightful array of culinary delights waiting to be savored. Known for its rich gastronomic tapestry, this lovely town is a treasure trove for food enthusiasts seeking a culinary escapade. Situated in Ohio, Newtown boasts a diverse dining scene that caters to every palate, making it a haven for foodies near and far. Embark on a gastronomic journey and explore the ‘Best Restaurants in Newtown,’ where each eatery promises a unique dining experience. Beyond its culinary offerings, Newtown also invites visitors to explore its cultural attractions and scenic beauty, adding a touch of allure to this gastronomic haven.

1. Lobsta Bakes of Maine

Located in Newtown, Lobsta Bakes of Maine is a seafood haven that has locals buzzing. With rave reviews pouring in, it’s no wonder this spot boasts the best fish n’ chips in town, featuring freshly fried, thick cuts of fish alongside high-quality fries and a smoky tartar sauce that’s a hit with both kids and adults alike. Known for their legit seafood offerings, from crab cakes to flaky fish, this joint’s outdoor seating is the cherry on top for a delightful dining experience. And let’s not forget the welcoming staff, with Robert earning a special shoutout for his top-notch service. If you’re seeking a taste of fresh seafood bliss, Lobsta Bakes is the place to be – where fish, chips, and cold beer collide to create pure happiness. Dive into a meal that promises to make your taste buds sing!

Rating:
Price:

2. Newtown Village Tavern Pizza

Newtown Village Tavern Pizza in Newtown is a must-visit gem for those craving a laid-back dining experience with a touch of local flair. With rave reviews painting a picture of crispy mozza sticks, flavorful pub-style pizza, and a juicy chicken bacon ranch sammy, this spot seems to have the recipe for success down pat. The welcoming atmosphere seems to be a recurring theme, with mentions of friendly staff and ample parking adding to the overall charm. Whether you’re in the mood for a cold beer, great service, or simply a fantastic slice of pizza, Newtown Village Tavern Pizza appears to tick all the boxes for a memorable dining escapade in the heart of Newtown.

Rating:
Price:

3. The Quarter Bistro

Located in Newtown, The Quarter Bistro is a culinary gem that beautifully blends Latin and French influences to create a truly global dining experience. Their patio seating offers a snazzy and comfy ambiance for patrons to savor their flavorful dishes. Regulars rave about the menu consistency and top-notch service, with standouts like the mouthwatering steak frites, delectable tuna tartar, and savory flatbread stealing the show. While some dishes like the “bean” loaf may not hit the mark for all, the swordfish with its sweet kick glaze receives high praise. Guests appreciate the attentive staff, with mentions of friendly bartender Caroline and Chef Chris adding personal touches to the dining experience. For those looking to indulge in a delightful meal with European charm and impeccable service, The Quarter Bistro is a must-visit spot in Newtown. Don’t miss out on the seasonal changes to discover new culinary delights in this cozy culinary haven!

Rating:
Price:

4. Main Street Cafe

Situated in the heart of Newtown is Main Street Cafe, a beloved gem serving up classic American comfort food with a twist. The rave reviews speak for themselves – from the best burgers and fish sandwiches in town to the addictive fried pickle chips and mozzarella sticks, every dish is a hit. The cozy ambiance with its big windows provides the perfect backdrop for a relaxing dining experience, while the attentive and kind servers ensure top-notch service. Don’t miss out on the ranch dressing that’s been hailed as amazing by patrons. Whether you’re a local looking for a new favorite spot or just passing through, Main Street Cafe is a must-visit for delicious food at reasonable prices.

Rating:
Price:

5. Anderson Township Pub

Located in Newtown, Anderson Township Pub is a local institution renowned for its hearty pub grub and impressive selection of brews. As one reviewer raved about the “Hanky Spankys” appetizer, featuring a delightful combination of wonder cheese and sausage on pumpernickel toast reminiscent of homemade comfort food, the menu clearly holds treasures waiting to be discovered. The Top Gun burger, described as a flavorful smash burger with a generous serving of pickles, tantalizing sauce, and a perfectly toasted bun, stands out as a must-try. With attentive staff ensuring a top-notch dining experience, Anderson Township Pub is a vibrant hub for delicious eats and good times.

Rating:
Price:

6. Patron Mexican Grill (Mariemont)

Located in Newtown, Patron Mexican Grill is a culinary gem not to be missed. Boasting a stellar reputation for its delectable fare, this vibrant spot has captured the hearts (and taste buds) of many diners. Diving into their menu reveals rave reviews about their impeccable rice that’s hailed as the best in town, alongside the flavorful black beans that effortlessly steal the show. The chips and guacamole receive a special mention for their thick, smooth, and irresistible appeal. Whether you opt for the veggie meals or the tantalizing chicken taco salad with a crispy edible shell, Patron Mexican Grill promises a dining experience that hits all the right notes. It’s no surprise that patrons are already planning return visits with friends in tow, eager to share the joy with their fellow food enthusiasts. Get ready to embark on a culinary journey that promises to delight your senses and leave you craving more.

Rating:
Price:

7. Mio’s Pizzeria

Mio’s Pizzeria in Newtown is a culinary treasure trove waiting to be explored. Dive into a world where deep-dish pizzas reminiscent of Chicago’s finest are baked to perfection, each bite a symphony of flavors. From the crispy crust adventures to the savory ham and bacon delights, Mio’s exceeds expectations at every turn. The garlic bread, a prelude to the main act, sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. Whether you’re savoring the creamy garlic dressing, indulging in goat cheese fritters, or relishing the lasagna, every dish at Mio’s whispers tales of culinary mastery. With attentive service and generous portions ensuring no craving is left unsatisfied, Mio’s Pizzeria is a must-visit for any discerning food enthusiast seeking a slice of pizza paradise in Newtown.

Rating:
Price:

8. LaRosa’s Pizza Mariemont

If you find yourself in Newtown craving a slice of heaven, look no further than LaRosa’s Pizza Mariemont. This bustling pizza joint has garnered quite the reputation for its friendly service and top-notch eats in the realm of Italian cuisine. Regulars sing praises of the impeccable management, with one reviewer marveling at a near-flawless takeout experience where even a slight mishap was swiftly rectified with grace and a discount. The cherry on top? The outdoor seating area and the exceptional customer service provided by the ever-helpful manager, John, who transforms any dining inconvenience into a delightful culinary escapade. LaRosa’s Pizza Mariemont isn’t just a place to grab a quick bite—it’s a welcoming haven where every visit promises a warm reception and a slice of perfection.

Rating:
Price: