Best Restaurants in Plain, Ohio

In the heart of Plain, The Eagles Villa Pizza is a true gem serving up delectable Italian-American fare that has captured the hearts (and taste buds) of many. With rave reviews highlighting their mouthwatering pepperoni pizza and flavorful meatballs in sauce, it’s clear this longstanding establishment knows how to please. The generous toppings on their meat pizza and the innovative Mexican Pizza have left patrons raving about the explosion of flavors in every bite. From the welcoming atmosphere to the option of taking home a fresh pizza to bake, The Eagles Villa Pizza has undoubtedly earned its spot as a go-to spot for both locals and travelers alike. Next time you find yourself in Plain, don’t miss out on the chance to savor a slice of perfection at this classic corner pizza shop!

Elliot’s Wood Fired Kitchen & Tap in Plain is a culinary gem waiting to be discovered! Boasting a charming patio where you can savor delights, from crispy yet fluffy wood-fired pizzas to delectable bruschetta, this restaurant offers an unforgettable experience. The menu features a delightful array of dishes, including mouthwatering meatballs, cheeseburgers, and house-made chips with salsa that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. With a cozy ambiance that blends a sports bar feel with comfortable lounge booths, Elliot’s ensures a relaxed dining atmosphere perfect for any occasion. The exceptional service, highlighted by genuine human interaction, adds a personal touch to your visit, making it a must-return spot for locals and travelers alike. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to indulge in their culinary creations and top-notch hospitality – Elliot’s Wood Fired Kitchen & Tap is a hidden culinary treasure worth exploring!

Located in Plain, Hudson 29 Kitchen + Drink exudes a cozy yet vibrant ambiance perfect for any occasion. With a menu as diverse as it is mouthwatering, this restaurant has earned rave reviews for its delectable dishes. From the savory Cheers stuffed butter Rolls to the tantalizing SURF & TURF and the exquisite Slow Roasted Prime Rib, each plate promises a culinary journey like no other. Pair your meal with a Side Car cocktail or maybe a Blood Orange Margarita, and you’re in for a treat! The attention to detail extends to the impeccable service highlighted by Trinity, who goes above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. With ample parking and the option for outdoor patio seating, Hudson 29 is a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts seeking a top-notch culinary adventure in Plain. Make sure to secure your spot by booking a reservation online for a seamless dining experience that promises to delight all your senses!

Located in the charming town of Plain, Fox in the Snow Cafe is a must-visit gem for breakfast and lunch enthusiasts. Guests rave about the generous portion sizes that will leave you satisfied and coming back for more. Whether you’re indulging in the morning bun or savoring the mouthwatering egg sandwich, every bite is a delight. Don’t miss out on their specialty drinks like the heavenly mocha or the invigorating New Orleans iced coffee. With a cozy atmosphere and a menu filled with delectable pastries and sandwiches, Fox in the Snow Cafe is the perfect spot to start your day in Plain.

Located in the charming town of Plain, Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern is a casual dining gem that promises a delightful culinary experience. Boasting a sports-bar atmosphere, this establishment offers a mouthwatering array of comfort food favorites that will leave you craving more. Indulge in their legendary fish and chips, described as “surpassing the quality of old bag of nails'” by impressed patrons. Pair it with the fabulous street corn and a serving of their delicious French onion soup for a truly unforgettable meal. Whether you’re hosting a private event in their cozy Private Room or simply stopping by for a quick bite, Rusty Bucket guarantees impeccable service and top-notch dishes that will keep you coming back for more. Your taste buds will thank you for discovering this hidden culinary treasure in the heart of Plain.

Located in Plain, Mellow Mushroom New Albany is a funky and art-filled pizzeria that promises a creative culinary experience. Dive into their specialty BBQ pizza, a true masterpiece according to one reviewer who couldn’t resist taking photos after devouring the slices. Another patron raved about the outstanding pizza varieties and exceptional service, emphasizing the joy of customizing orders. With a vibrant ambiance and a dedication to top-notch ingredients, Mellow Mushroom New Albany seems to be a must-visit spot for pizza lovers craving a memorable dining adventure.

In the vibrant town of Plain, there’s a culinary gem that’s been causing quite a stir among food enthusiasts. Blue Agave, a lively Mexican restaurant and bar, has been winning hearts with its flavorful dishes and zesty margaritas that are not to be missed. Visitors rave about the mouthwatering tacos and the refreshing pitchers of margaritas that perfectly complement the spicy flavors. The lively ambiance and attentive service seem to be a recurring theme in the glowing reviews, making Blue Agave a go-to spot for those craving a fiesta for the taste buds. So, if you’re on the hunt for a culinary fiesta, Blue Agave is the place to be in Plain!

Located in Plain, The Goat New Albany is a vibrant eatery that promises a top-notch dining experience. Known for its creative cocktails, elevated pub fare, and lively ambiance featuring frequent live music, this spot is a gem for foodies and fun-seekers alike. Patrons rave about the impeccable service from staff members like Angie and Chad, who go above and beyond to ensure a memorable visit. The menu shines with delectable dishes like the impossible Mac, which, despite its popularity, manages to cater to various dietary needs with finesse. With such a winning combination of great food, fantastic service, and a lively atmosphere, The Goat New Albany is undoubtedly a must-visit for those in search of a memorable dining adventure in Plain.

Located in Plain, BrewDog New Albany is a no-nonsense haven for craft beer enthusiasts. With a focus on Scottish brewery’s creations and a rotation of guest brews, this chain bar promises a flavorful journey for your taste buds. The rave reviews speak for themselves, with patrons praising the attentive bartender who effortlessly juggled a bustling restaurant and a large party, ensuring each guest felt special. The standout dish seems to be the colossal, crunchy wings, served with tempting sauces like honey adobo and spicy buffalo, making them a must-try for any visitor. With a welcoming ambiance and a promise of a great time, BrewDog New Albany is definitely on the radar for those seeking a relaxed dining experience paired with exceptional brews.

Located in Plain, Roosters is a bustling outpost that has captured the hearts (and taste buds) of both locals and visitors alike. This casual chain’s specialty in American comfort food, particularly their mouthwatering chicken wings, has garnered quite the fan base. With reviews raving about the 🔥🔥 wings and the delightful option to have the sauce on the side, Roosters seems to have mastered the art of wing perfection. Patrons also appreciate the swift service and delicious offerings like the Big Bobs Burger. While there might be a wait, the lively atmosphere and delectable dishes make it a must-visit spot, especially for any game or event. So, if you’re craving a crispy, flavor-packed experience, Roosters is the place to be for a memorable dining adventure in Plain.