Best Restaurants in Painesville, Ohio

Located in Painesville, Bada Bing Pizza is a well-known gem that’s not to be missed when exploring the culinary scene. The charming interior of this old brick building sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. Renowned for their wonderful subs, calzones, and, of course, great pizza, this spot has garnered rave reviews for its top-notch quality at an affordable price point. The Buffalo chicken pizza and perfectly crispy fries stand out as must-tries, showcasing the culinary mastery of the chefs behind the scenes. With generous portions and a comfortable atmosphere that outshines typical chain pizzerias, Bada Bing Pizza has rightfully earned its spot as a local favorite. Whether you’re a Painesville local or making a special trip, this spot promises a delightful culinary journey that’ll keep you coming back for more.

Step into a culinary gem in Painesville with Bistro 70, a vibrant hotspot for those seeking top-notch New American cuisine and a cozy upscale-casual vibe. Indulge in the flavors that keep patrons raving, like the blackened grouper bites, smoked chicken pasta, and the delectable pork schnitzel, all culminating in a divine finale with the brown butter cake. The restaurant’s ambiance sets the stage for a perfect evening, complemented by attentive servers like Rachel and Cassey, who elevate the dining experience. From the warm greetings to the chef’s personal touch on each dish, Bistro 70 exudes a level of hospitality that keeps guests coming back for more. Whether it’s a romantic date night or a monthly ritual, this culinary haven promises not just a meal, but a memorable dining adventure in the heart of Lake County.

Located in Painesville, La Casita Market is a hidden gem that has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Boasting a vibrant atmosphere and a rich tapestry of flavors, this Mexican Market/Taqueria stands out for its authentic cuisine and fast, friendly service. Rave reviews highlight must-try items like the tantalizing horchata, fresh produce, and generous oxtail portions that put grocery stores to shame. The modern building exudes a welcoming vibe, while the dedicated staff elevates the dining experience to new heights. As one of the most authentic Mexican food spots in the Cleveland area, La Casita Market is a true culinary haven that promises a taste of Mexico without the need for a passport.

If you find yourself in Painesville craving authentic Mexican flavors that will transport your taste buds South of the border, look no further than Taqueria La Casita. Renowned for its mouthwatering street tacos, this gem of a restaurant offers a symphony of flavors that will make your palate sing. From the perfectly marinated meats to the fresh salsas and toppings that elevate each bite, every aspect of the taco experience here is crafted with care and attention to detail. The Al pastor taco, in particular, stands out with its incredible char and delectably balanced flavors. And don’t miss the chance to customize your meal with a variety of condiments, just be sure to ask for guidance if you’re feeling adventurous. With prices that won’t break the bank, Taqueria La Casita is a must-visit for anyone seeking an unforgettable culinary journey through Mexico’s vibrant cuisine in the heart of Painesville.

Located in the vibrant town of Painesville, Flavors Around The Square, affectionately known as F.A.T.S., is a hidden gem for breakfast enthusiasts. With a cozy ambiance in an old, beautifully decorated building, this spot offers a delightful morning experience. The breakfast menu seems to be the star here, with rave reviews about the homemade Corned Beef Hash and the fried biscuits and gravy. One reviewer even mentioned the joy of watching the yolk spread over their dish – a true testament to the attention to detail in their cooking. Despite a lunch hiccup with the burger, the overall consensus leans towards F.A.T.S. being the go-to breakfast joint in town, offering great value for money and friendly service. If you’re in Painesville and in need of a breakfast haven, Flavors Around The Square is the place to be!

Located in Painesville, Silvestro’s Depot Cafe Inc is a gem waiting to be discovered by food enthusiasts craving a cozy dining experience. Stepping into this family-run establishment feels like stepping into a warm embrace, with old photos adorning the walls, creating a nostalgic ambiance. The menu boasts ample portions of Italian fare, with standout dishes like ravioli that one reviewer claimed they’d savor sauce off a rusty bumper for. The steaks and seafood are cooked to perfection, with impeccable timing between courses even during peak hours. While it may be cash-only, the prices are reasonable for the quality offered. Silvestro’s is not just a restaurant; it’s a culinary journey that beckons you to return daily for a taste of home-cooked goodness that you won’t soon forget.

Located in downtown Painesville, the Local Tavern’s Fish Bar is a culinary treasure waiting to be discovered. With a menu full of fresh and delightful dishes, this place is a haven for seafood enthusiasts. Diners rave about the lobster bisque, hailed as one of the best in town, and the hearty jambalaya that promises a flavorful experience. Pair your meal with the must-try shroom fries and the refreshing Thai slaw for a complete gastronomic adventure. Whether you cozy up indoors during winter or bask in the summer breeze on the outdoor patio, the inviting ambiance and friendly staff add an extra layer of charm to your dining experience. Don’t miss out on this hidden gem where each bite is a testament to culinary excellence!

In the charming town of Painesville, Perkins Restaurant & Bakery shines brightly as a go-to spot for families seeking a delightful dining experience. Renowned for their delectable baked goods and hearty breakfast options, this establishment offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere that beckons guests to indulge in classic diner fare. Glowing reviews highlight the quick and friendly service, ensuring that patrons can enjoy their meals with ease. Diners rave about the club sandwich, boasting about its tantalizing flavors, while others reminisce about the unforgettable potato pancakes that left taste buds longing for more. Perkins Restaurant & Bakery in Painesville seems to have found the winning formula of great food, efficient service, and a cozy ambiance, making it a must-visit gem in the realm of dining pleasures.

Situated in the charming town of Painesville, The Sidewalk Cafe is a delightful culinary gem worth exploring. Boasting a cozy ambiance and friendly service, this cafe offers a unique dining experience that will surely tantalize your taste buds. As highlighted by enthusiastic visitors, the breakfast menu shines with must-try dishes like the gyro meat breakfast and the flavorful omelette wrap with feta cheese. Portion sizes here are generous, ensuring you leave satisfied without breaking the bank. The old pharmacy setting adds a touch of nostalgia to your meal, creating a memorable backdrop for enjoying hot, delicious food. Whether you’re a local looking for a new favorite spot or a traveler passing through, The Sidewalk Cafe promises a satisfying dining adventure that embodies the essence of good food and great service.

Step back in time and indulge in a culinary experience like no other at Rider’s Inn Since 1812 in Painesville. This historic gem boasts warm, antique-filled quarters within a charming 19th-century inn, housing a restaurant and a cozy pub. Diving into the enchanting reviews, guests rave about the Easter buffet – a flavorful feast where every dish shines hot and tasty, accompanied by attentive service that elevates the dining experience. But the surprises don’t stop there; this establishment also offers an ambiance perfect for live music events, showcasing acoustics that support various genres and a staff that exudes warmth and hospitality. Whether you’re drawn in by the delectable spread or the lively music scene, Rider’s Inn promises a delightful visit where you’ll feel right at home.