Best Restaurants in Cortland, Ohio

Brother’s Pizza & Restaurant in Cortland is a culinary gem waiting to be discovered! Boasting freshly baked rolls for their mouthwatering subs, this small local spot has garnered a devoted following over the years. With rave reviews spanning over four decades, it’s clear that the quality and taste are consistently top-notch. Guests can’t get enough of the NY-style pizzas, delectable stromboli, and standout Italian and meatball subs, all made with fresh ingredients that burst with flavor. Don’t miss out on the cheesesteak sub or the iconic plain pizza that keeps patrons coming back for more. Brother’s Pizza & Restaurant is a must-visit for those craving authentic, homemade fare in Cortland.

Located in the vibrant town of Cortland, Auntie V’s Pizzeria is a shining gem for both locals and visitors alike. From the tantalizing sheet pan style pepperoni pizza to the mouthwatering Italian sandwich with homemade light and crispy bread, every dish at Auntie V’s is crafted with love and care, as mentioned by the enthusiastic reviewers. The exceptional customer service, as highlighted by the kind and patient staff, adds an extra layer of charm to this establishment. With reasonable pricing and a convenient drive-thru option, Auntie V’s Pizzeria is a must-visit spot that promises a delightful culinary experience in Cortland.

If you find yourself in Cortland craving a taste of Italy, look no further than Vasilio’s Restaurant & Pizzeria. Known for its exceptional pizzas cooked to perfection in a traditional stone oven, this spot has garnered a loyal following. Guests rave about the stuffed cabbage and spaghetti with meatballs, praising the fresh homemade ingredients that elevate every bite. The aroma of freshly baked dough and grated Romano cheese fills the air as you step in, setting the stage for a culinary experience that’s reminiscent of a cozy family dinner. Whether you’re indulging in eggplant parm with a crispy twist or savoring their signature old world brier hill pizza, each dish is crafted with love and authenticity. With generous portions and friendly staff that make you feel right at home, Vasilio’s is a must-visit gem in Cortland for a truly satisfying dining affair.

Located in the vibrant town of Cortland, El Torero Mexican Restaurant is a true culinary delight that has captured the hearts of many food enthusiasts. With a reputation for exceptional service and mouthwatering dishes, this hidden gem has become a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. Guests rave about the speedy service and the fantastic quality of the food, with one reviewer highlighting the surprising affordability of a meal for three. The dedicated staff, including the phenomenal waiters, ensure a seamless dining experience where you won’t have to wait long for anything. If you’re craving authentic Mexican cuisine that won’t break the bank, El Torero is a must-visit destination in Cortland for a memorable dining experience.

Located in the charming town of Cortland, Top Notch Diner is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered by food enthusiasts. With a menu boasting mouth-watering dishes like the Crispy Chicken Sandwich, delectable French Toast, and irresistible French Fries, this diner is sure to delight your taste buds. The welcoming staff caters to families, ensuring a friendly environment for all diners. From the ample parking to the option of cozy booths or a lively bar setting, Top Notch Diner offers a diverse dining experience. Whether you’re craving a hearty breakfast like the flavorful Scrambler or a satisfying lunch, this diner promises a culinary journey that’s both delicious and affordable. Don’t miss out on this gem in Cortland for a memorable dining experience that’s top-notch.

Located in the bustling town of Cortland, Dunkin’ is a beloved gem offering a delightful array of signature breakfast items and an impressive selection of coffee drinks. Patrons rave about the mouthwatering pastries and the rich, aromatic coffee that sets the perfect tone for any morning. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff add an extra layer of charm to this longstanding establishment. With such glowing reviews, it’s no wonder Dunkin’ is a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike seeking a tasty start to their day in Cortland.

Located in the heart of Cortland, Ohio, Four Star Diner is a culinary gem that promises a delightful dining experience. This cozy diner boasts a varied menu featuring comfort foods that cater to all tastes, from scrumptious burgers and sandwiches to delectable breakfast, lunch, and dinner options. With a friendly and attentive staff, like the renowned Cieria and Heather, your dining experience is sure to be top-notch. Indulge in their famous Apple and Cream Cheese French Toast or savor the flavorful Pecan Pancakes and Chocolate Chip Pancakes mentioned in rave reviews. The quick service ensures your meal arrives hot and fresh, leaving you thoroughly satisfied. Don’t miss out on this hidden Cortland treasure that promises a memorable meal every time you visit.

Situated in the vibrant town of Cortland, Pizza Joe’s is a must-visit gem for food enthusiasts looking to tantalize their taste buds. With an extensive menu boasting specialty pizzas, mouthwatering subs, flavorful wings, and indulgent calzones, this regional chain truly offers something for everyone. Guests rave about the perfect crust-to-topping ratio on their pizzas, the savory flavors bursting in every bite of their subs, and the crispy perfection of their wings. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Pizza Joe’s promises to deliver a delectable experience that will have you coming back for more. Indulge in a slice of heaven at Pizza Joe’s and discover why it’s a top contender in the thriving culinary scene of Cortland.

Located in Cortland, Ohio, Iron House is a neighborhood gem that exudes a laid-back atmosphere perfect for catching the game while indulging in delectable comfort foods. The festive Christmas decorations add a cheerful touch, complementing the spacious parking lot for hassle-free visits. With a diverse menu featuring mouthwatering burgers, wings, and entrees, the bar & grill dazzles patrons with exceptional service and inventive drinks like the popular cherry pop. From the perfect fried cheese planks to the kickass burgers, every dish at Iron House is a culinary delight worth savoring. This Po’Dunk hole-in-the-wall joint not only offers ice-cold drafts but also delivers piping hot dishes, making it a must-visit spot for those seeking a memorable dining experience in Ohio.

Located in the vibrant town of Cortland, Cocca’s Pizza is a delightful gem that offers a mix of classic and innovative pizzas, along with mouthwatering subs and wings, all served in a laid-back atmosphere. One reviewer raved about the top-notch service and the skillful pizza spinning by the talented staff, ensuring a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular, Cocca’s Pizza promises a culinary adventure that will keep you coming back for more. Indulge in their signature pies and let your taste buds dance with joy, making this spot a must-visit on your list of the best restaurants in Cortland.