Best Restaurants in Utica, Indiana

Located in Utica, Cunningham’s Creekside offers a culinary experience that seamlessly blends efficient service with breathtaking views of the flowing creek. Patrons rave about the speed at which delectable dishes are served, ensuring a dining experience that doesn’t keep you waiting. The extensive menu boasts a colossal double burger that’s a must-try for burger aficionados, while the legendary fish sandwich comes highly recommended for those seeking a true taste of Southern hospitality. With a nod to their past brunch glory and a nod to furry friends being welcome on the dock, Cunningham’s Creekside promises a dining adventure that’s not just about the food but about embracing a slice of local charm and history.

Located in Utica, Seasoned Pub & Grill is a hidden gem that has been making waves among locals and visitors alike. Boasting a spotless interior and a welcoming ambiance, this spot sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. With a diverse menu that caters to even the pickiest eaters, their dishes have been leaving patrons raving. From mouthwatering grilled chicken salads to the irresistible pretzels with beer cheese, every bite at Seasoned Pub & Grill is a flavor-packed adventure. The attentive service and extensive drink selection, including a must-try Bloody Mary, add to the overall charm of this family-owned establishment. Whether you’re craving a classic BLT or one of their creative strombolis, Seasoned Pub & Grill promises to exceed your expectations and keep you coming back for more.

Situated in the vibrant town of Utica, Gracious Plenty is a hidden gem known for its delectable sandwiches that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Delight in their signature Turkey BLT sandwich, a crowd-pleaser that promises a symphony of flavors in every bite. Beyond the food, the exceptional service at Gracious Plenty elevates the dining experience, making it a must-visit destination for those craving not just a meal, but a memorable culinary journey. Embrace the warmth and charm of this spot, where good food meets great company, creating a perfect harmony that keeps patrons coming back for more. Uncover a true culinary delight at Gracious Plenty, a haven for food enthusiasts in Utica.

Located in Utica, DiOrio’s Pizza & Pub is a bustling hub of culinary delight. The A-Train pizza steals the spotlight with a tantalizing ensemble of tomatoes, feta, grilled chicken, and more, delivering a slice of pure genius. Amidst the lively atmosphere, the Gibbon Pizza impresses with a cheese pull that dreams are made of, leaving patrons with ample leftovers to savor later. The generous serving sizes and quality fare ensure a memorable dining experience, while the friendly staff and fair prices add a touch of warmth to every visit. Whether you’re a pickleball enthusiast or a pizza aficionado, DiOrio’s is a must-visit gem in Utica that promises to keep you coming back for more.

Located in Utica, Gustavo’s Mexican Grill is a hidden gem that promises to tantalize your taste buds with authentic flavors and vibrant dishes. Diners rave about the flavorful carne asada, perfectly seasoned with a hint of spice that keeps you coming back for more. The cozy ambiance and friendly staff only add to the dining experience, making it a must-visit for any Mexican food enthusiast. Don’t miss out on their delectable street tacos, which have garnered praise for their freshness and generous portions. Gustavo’s Mexican Grill is a culinary delight that will transport you to the streets of Mexico with every savory bite.

Located in Utica, The Pine Room is a culinary gem that promises a delightful dining experience. With a charming and cozy ambiance enhanced by live piano melodies, this place exudes warmth and hospitality. Diving into their menu reveals culinary wonders like their renowned fried chicken, served with delectable sides like Brussels sprouts and cauliflower. The attentive and knowledgeable staff, highlighted by standout mentions of Aaron, Jared, and Kenneth, ensure that your evening is not just a meal but a memorable culinary journey. Whether you’re a local swinging by for takeout or a visitor seeking a top-notch dining spot, The Pine Room beckons with its promise of exceptional food and service that will keep you coming back for more.

Located in Utica, Captain’s Quarters Riverside Grille is a must-visit gem for those seeking a classy dining experience with a picturesque view of the Ohio River. Boasting a multilevel terrace offering stunning vistas, this spot not only serves up delectable American fare but also crafts cocktails that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. From the mouthwatering shrimp and grits to the indulgent bourbon bread pudding, each dish is a culinary delight as mentioned by patrons who couldn’t help but rave about the warm and inviting atmosphere. Whether you’re savoring the flavors indoors or soaking in the sights of boats passing by during an evening meal, Captain’s Quarters Riverside Grille promises a memorable dining experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Dos Aztecas Mexican Restaurant in Utica has quickly become a local favorite, drawing patrons in with its delicious offerings and vibrant ambiance. Nestled in a spacious, festive setting, this casual spot boasts a stellar menu featuring must-try dishes like the Tacos Fajitas, a flavorful delight packed with steak, peppers, and onions, accompanied by sides of rice, beans, and Pico with sour cream. The attention to detail doesn’t stop there – free chips are the cherry on top of this culinary experience. Guests have raved not only about the delectable food but also the top-notch service, with servers going above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. And to add a musical flair, the restaurant occasionally hosts live entertainment, like a talented violin player on a recent Tuesday night, elevating the atmosphere to new heights. With dishes like the Montezuma platter stealing the show alongside a salsa that packs a punch, Dos Aztecas truly stands out as a gem in Utica’s culinary scene. Whether you’re a local looking for your go-to Mexican spot or a visitor seeking an unforgettable meal, Dos Aztecas promises a dining experience that hits all the right notes.

Situated in the picturesque town of Utica, The Blackstone Grille is a culinary gem not to be missed. Delight in a symphony of flavors with creative and traditional American dishes that will tantalize your taste buds. From perfectly cooked steaks to succulent grilled Berkshire Double-Cut pork chops, each dish is a masterpiece in itself. The exquisite Caesar salad with char-grilled salmon, the savory Chicken Scarborough with country ham Au Gratin potatoes, and the Springer Mountain Fried Chicken are just a few highlights from their diverse menu. With a dedicated and knowledgeable staff, including standout servers like Tish and Cameron, your dining experience at Blackstone Grille promises to be unforgettable. Whether you’re a local looking for a new favorite spot or a traveler seeking culinary excellence, Blackstone Grille is the perfect destination for a truly exceptional meal.

If you find yourself in Utica craving a sushi experience that transcends the ordinary, look no further than Arata Sushi. Renowned for its exquisite culinary creations, this gem stands out not just for its delectable sushi offerings but also for its impeccable service and inviting ambiance. Diners rave about the flawless execution of each dish, with a constant chorus of praise for the friendly servers and the overall delightful atmosphere. For those seeking a top-tier sushi destination in Utica, Arata Sushi is a must-visit spot that promises a culinary journey unlike any other in the city.