Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Rome, New York

Nestled in the heart of New York state, Rome offers a charming and delightful culinary scene that belies its modest size. This historic town, rich with a past that echoes the grandeur of its namesake, provides a surprisingly diverse array of dining options that caters to both traditional and contemporary palates. From cozy, family-owned Italian bistros that pay homage to Rome’s ancient namesake, serving authentic dishes passed down through generations, to modern cafes offering farm-to-table freshness that mirrors the town’s surrounding verdant landscapes, Rome is a gastronomic treasure waiting to be discovered. The town’s commitment to celebrating its history, while embracing the present, is mirrored in its eateries, making every meal here not just a feast for the taste buds, but a journey through time and culture.

1. Sugarbeets

In the culinary landscape of Rome, nestled amidst the vibrant streets, lies Sugarbeets, a hidden gem brimming with delightful surprises. Upon entering, one is enveloped in a cozy ambiance where each detail, from the colorful aprons adorning the wait staff to the quaint table settings, adds a touch of whimsy. The menu, a fusion of classic and innovative offerings, beckons both locals and travelers alike to embark on a gastronomic journey. Indulge in the decadent Lobster Bisque, a creamy delight with a surprise crab cake center, or savor the Fried Artichoke wrapped in Prosciutto, a harmonious blend of flavors. Whether it’s the delectable Chicken Marsala or the tantalizing Miss Jenny, Sugarbeets exceeds expectations, leaving even the most discerning palate in awe. With a diverse wine selection and exceptional service, Sugarbeets is a must-visit destination for those seeking a culinary experience beyond compare in the heart of Rome.

Rating:
Price:

2. Big Jay’s Pizzeria

In the bustling town of Rome, situated in the heart of culinary excellence, Big Jay’s Pizzeria stands out as a true gem for pizza aficionados. Famed for their innovative creations, the chicken Mac and cheese pizza is a crowd favorite, setting the bar high for pizzerias in the area. Beyond the classics, indulge in the stir fry pizza or the steak sub with sweet chili and blue cheese, a tantalizing combination guaranteed to leave your taste buds singing praises. The dedication to quality shines through in every bite, with high-quality meats and crispy, generous slices stealing the show. As a newcomer, navigating the food scene can be daunting, but rest assured, Big Jay’s Pizzeria is a savory sanctuary worth the hunt. Don’t miss out on their delightful desserts, adding a sweet finale to your culinary journey. Whether you’re a local pizza enthusiast or a traveler seeking a slice of heaven, Big Jay’s Pizzeria is a must-visit hotspot, promising a culinary experience that is as colossal as their legendary pies.

Rating:
Price:

3. Eddie’s Paramount Diner

Nestled in the heart of Rome, NY, Eddie’s Paramount Diner emerges as a quintessential American dining experience, reminiscent of an era when hearty home-cooked meals and warm, welcoming atmospheres reigned supreme. With a genuine diner look and feel, Eddie’s has quickly become a beacon for both locals and travelers alike, promising an unforgettable culinary journey. Visitors rave about the generous portions of traditional favorites, from the turkey specials that evoke a sense of Thanksgiving any day of the week to scalloped potatoes and ham that taste like they’re straight out of grandma’s kitchen. The charismatic presence of Eddie himself, who seems to know everyone by name, adds a personal touch that makes dining here feel like a visit to a dear friend’s home. Eddie’s Paramount Diner isn’t just a place to eat; it’s a destination where every meal feels like a celebration of community and good food, leaving your wallet full and your stomach even fuller.

Rating:
Price:

4. Iron Kettle Restaurant

Located in Rome, the Iron Kettle Restaurant is a true gem for breakfast enthusiasts and families alike. With a bustling atmosphere, this spot has mastered the art of diner-style breakfast, as evidenced by the perfectly fluffy pancakes, expertly fried eggs, and impeccable toast that have patrons singing its praises. The cozy ambiance and friendly service create a welcoming environment where regulars and newcomers feel equally at home. Additionally, the efficient and attentive staff ensure that even during busy periods, like when the place is packed with eager diners, each dish arrives piping hot and in a timely manner. From Western omelettes to home fries, every bite at Iron Kettle Restaurant is a testament to their dedication to quality and customer satisfaction. Next time you find yourself driving through Rome, make sure to pull over and experience the delightful culinary journey that awaits at Iron Kettle Restaurant.

Rating:
Price:

5. Franklin Hotel

Nestled in the heart of history, the charming yet spartan dining room of this former hotel now serves as a beacon for Italian cuisine aficionados. The Franklin, as patrons fondly call it, crafts an unforgettable dining experience with its Chief’s Special, homemade pasta, and a turkey dinner that has become a tradition for many. The allure doesn’t stop at the main course; despite the generous servings, whispers of “fabulous desserts” can tempt even the fullest of guests. It’s a place where the simplicity of a salad dressed in Parmesan peppercorn or the complexity of a linguine with sausage and peppers finds a harmonious balance. Here, the passion for culinary excellence is palpable, from the garlic butter caressing fresh bread to the sweet and hot dance of homemade sausage. The Franklin isn’t just recommended; it’s a gastronomic pilgrimage for those seeking the heart and soul of Italian dining.

Rating:
Price:

6. Tony’s

Nestled in the heart of Rome, Tony’s emerges as a no-frills sanctuary for pizza aficionados. Upon my visits, it became abundantly clear why this modest establishment has garnered such acclaim. Tony’s elevates the simple pleasure of biting into a freshly made pizza into an art form, offering an array of toppings that cater to diverse palates, all at a price that beckons indulgence without guilt. The wings, a crispy counterpart to their doughy brethren, suggest a venture into thin crust territory could only elevate their culinary repertoire. The ambiance, though sparing in space, radiates a warmth matched only by the team’s earnest hospitality. Tony’s stands as a testament to the enduring charm of simplicity done right, making it a must-visit for those seeking the comfort of classic pizza with a touch of Rome’s generosity.

Rating:
Price:

7. Artani’s Pizzeria -Rome

Located in the heart of Rome, Artani’s Pizzeria is a culinary gem that truly stands out among the dining options in Rome, NY. This vibrant spot offers a delightful array of dishes that have left diners raving. From their piping hot and satisfying pizza slices to the fantastic bone-in wings that are cooked to perfection, Artani’s knows how to please a hungry crowd. The owner’s personal touch, evident in the gratitude expressed to customers, adds a warm and welcoming vibe to the clean and inviting atmosphere. Whether you’re in the mood for a delightful Buffalo chicken sub or craving fresh garden salads, Artani’s has it all. With generous portions that can easily feed a family, this pizzeria is a must-visit for anyone seeking quality service, delicious food, and a genuine dining experience in Rome.

Rating:
Price:

8. De Matteo’s

In the bustling city of Rome, De Matteo’s is making waves in the culinary scene with their mouthwatering burgers and Italian charcuterie that has garnered a loyal following. As highlighted by enthusiastic reviewers, their “Eastside” burger is a must-try, with its fresh ingredients, perfect bun, and harmonious blend of flavors that make it a standout dish. The addition of an all-new trivia night has injected a fun and vibrant energy into the establishment, drawing in a lively crowd of players and creating a one-of-a-kind dining experience. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to indulge in their legendary burgers and tantalizing Italian charcuterie – a true treat for the taste buds that will leave you craving more.

Rating:
Price:

9. Dicastro’s Brick Oven

Nestled in a cozy corner that feels like a slice of Rome, DiCastro’s Too charms with its casual yet stylish ambiance, offering a delightful escape for those in pursuit of authentic Italian cuisine. The brick-oven pizzas emerge with a perfect crust, a testament to the culinary prowess that pervades this establishment. The classic Italian entrees are a symphony of flavors, each dish crafted with care and presented with the kind of finesse that makes each meal memorable. But it’s not just the food that leaves an indelible mark; the wine and beer selection complements the dining experience, curated to enhance the flavors of Italy right on your palate. Hosting an event here elevates it to an extraordinary affair, thanks to the remarkable staff led by the phenomenal Lisa. DiCastro’s Too, indeed, is an underutilized gem that brings the spirit and taste of Rome closer to home.

Rating:
Price:

10. LaRoma Pizzeria & Restaurant

La Roma is a charming, family-run gem nestled in the heart of Utica-Rome, serving up some of the most delightful New York–style pizza and classic Italian fare that you’ll come across. From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted by a warm, authentic atmosphere that’s as inviting as the friendly staff ready to serve you. Whether you’re craving a crunchy, slightly thicker NY-style pizza, a Greek salad bursting with freshness, or a hearty Italian sausage sub jam-packed with flavor, La Roma has perfected the art of delivering consistently delicious food that keeps you coming back for more. The dining area, separate from the checkout, offers a clean and cozy setting to enjoy your meal. With its incredible deals, such as the 2 extra large pizza offer, and a menu that boasts everything from awesome wings to a perfect antipasto, La Roma stands out as a must-visit for anyone seeking an authentic slice of Italy in the Utica-Rome area.

Rating:
Price: