Best Restaurants in McFarland, Wisconsin

Located in McFarland, Angelo’s McFarland is a culinary gem that promises a delightful dining experience. Offering a cozy and elegant atmosphere, this restaurant has garnered rave reviews for its mouthwatering dishes and top-notch service. Patrons have praised the appetizing sampler platter, the delectable spaghetti pie, and the deluxe baked mostaccioli pasta, all served with a side of warm hospitality. From the flavorful Bruschetta to the savory Chicken Pesto Pasta, each dish is prepared to perfection, leaving diners craving more. Not to be missed are the complimentary bread and butter, a thoughtful touch that adds to the overall charm of this establishment. Whether you’re a local looking for a new favorite spot or a traveler passing through, Angelo’s McFarland is a must-visit destination that promises a memorable dining experience.

McFarland House Cafe in McFarland is a delightful gem indeed! Patrons rave about the rich and velvety lattes that beckon with their high-quality syrups, creating a flavor symphony that tickles the taste buds. It’s not just a cafe; it’s a warm and welcoming community hub where every visit feels like a cozy embrace. Regulars can’t get enough of “The Loafer” sandwich – a must-try that keeps them coming back for more. With a menu brimming with delectable deli fare and the charming ambiance of an 1856 house, McFarland House Cafe is not just a destination; it’s an experience to savor. Whether you’re in for a quick coffee fix or a leisurely meal, this cafe is a true haven for food enthusiasts in search of something special.

Situated in McFarland, Palenque Mexican Bar & Grill is a hidden gem that promises a fiesta for your taste buds. Dive into the vibrant flavors of homemade salsa and outstanding guacamole that will have you craving more. Don’t miss out on the horchata, a true crowd-pleaser! The Molcajete is a hot favorite, and the chimichangas are a must-try delight. With engaging service and a welcoming atmosphere, this spot is a fast track to fresh, fun Mexican fare that keeps diners coming back for more. Whether you’re a seasoned Mexican cuisine aficionado or a newbie looking for an authentic experience, Palenque promises an enticing culinary adventure that will leave you planning your next return visit.

Located in the charming town of McFarland, Luke’s Cafe is a delightful gem that has locals and visitors raving. Situated conveniently on Hwy 51, this neighborhood spot offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for any occasion. Guests have praised the diverse menu, with standout dishes like the fancy grilled cheese sandwich filled with tomato and bacon, the comforting chicken dumpling soup, and the flavorful cole slaw. The attentive staff at Luke’s Cafe adds an extra layer of hospitality that keeps patrons coming back for more. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Luke’s Cafe promises a memorable dining experience that won’t break the bank.

Spartan Pizza, located in McFarland, is a hidden gem serving up mouthwatering thin-crust pies that will leave your taste buds tingling. Patrons rave about the flavorful sausage, pepperoni, and jalapeño toppings, as well as the innovative buffalo chicken pizza with its spicy ranch sauce. The menu also boasts unique creations like the seasonal BBQ Blue Berry pizza, a true culinary delight that’s not to be missed. With a cozy, local vibe and friendly staff, Spartan Pizza offers an affordable dining experience where you can savor every delicious bite. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic pie or feeling adventurous, this tavern is a must-visit for pizza lovers in search of a memorable meal.

Located in McFarland, Maple Tree Supper Club is a gem serving up homey American comfort food that will make your taste buds sing. The ambiance is filled with nostalgia and warmth, reminiscent of classic supper clubs where indulgence meets tradition. From perfectly cooked prime rib to a delightful appetizer platter featuring cheese curds and wings, every dish is a flavorful journey worth savoring. The salad bar, although with room for improvement, complements the hearty meals well. Pam, the charismatic server, adds a touch of sass and professionalism, enhancing the overall dining experience. Don’t miss out on the loaded mashed potatoes with cheese and bacon – a true standout that will have you coming back for more. Maple Tree Supper Club is a must-visit destination for those seeking a taste of classic American dining with a touch of modern flair.

Situated in the heart of McFarland, the Green Lantern Restaurant exudes a warm and inviting old-time charm that sets the stage for a delightful dining experience. Offering a diverse surf ‘n’ turf menu from sunrise to sunset, this American eatery has clearly won the hearts of both locals and visitors alike. Dive into their renowned fish fry, or tantalize your taste buds with the crab-stuffed grouper that has diners raving about its perfection. Don’t miss the chance to sip on their top-notch Old Fashioneds and indulge in the comfort of their small town ambiance, complete with a picturesque lake view that adds a touch of serenity to your meal. With a legacy spanning over three decades, Green Lantern is a culinary gem where every dish, from the burgers to the breakfast offerings, promises a truly memorable dining affair. Whether you’re a longtime patron or a first-time visitor, this restaurant is a must-visit for anyone seeking a taste of classic American fare done right in McFarland.

Located in McFarland, the Squirrel’s Nest is a true culinary gem worth discovering in the outskirts of Stoughton. Renowned for their Friday fish fry, this place is a seafood enthusiast’s paradise. Patrons rave about the expertly prepared catfish and cod, showcasing the chef’s mastery in seafood delights. For brunch lovers, the Crabcakes Eggs Benedict and Rum Chata French toast steal the show, promising a delightful morning indulgence. And let’s not forget the late-night cravings – their fried walleye and cheese curds are hailed as must-tries, making this spot a perfect stop for any time of day. With a diverse menu and reasonable prices, the Squirrel’s Nest is a local haunt that promises a delightful dining experience for all who venture in.

Situated in McFarland, Park Side Pub is a culinary gem that combines fantastic food, top-notch service, and a vibrant sports bar atmosphere. Revel in the delight of diverse menu offerings that promise a savory journey for your taste buds. From the rave-worthy daily specials to the delectable dishes that keep patrons returning, this pub excels in delivering a memorable dining experience. With a warm ambiance that invites both locals and visitors alike, it’s no surprise that Park Side Pub stands out as a must-visit destination for those craving a delicious meal in a lively setting.

McFarland Tavern in the heart of McFarland is much more than your average neighborhood bar. With a recent impressive remodel featuring a spacious patio area perfect for enjoying drinks and games like Bag Toss, this spot has quickly won over the locals. Whether you’re in the mood for some delicious Birria tacos on Thursdays or simply looking for a welcoming atmosphere with friendly staff willing to go the extra mile, McFarland Tavern has you covered. This is the place where great service, good drinks, and an inviting ambiance come together seamlessly, making it a go-to spot for a fun night out in McFarland.