Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Menasha, Wisconsin

Situated in the heart of Wisconsin, Menasha is a culinary haven waiting to be explored. This lovely town boasts a vibrant dining scene that will tantalize your taste buds. From cozy cafes to upscale eateries, Menasha is a paradise for food enthusiasts seeking the Best Restaurants in the area. Beyond its culinary delights, this charming town also offers a plethora of attractions, including picturesque parks, scenic lakes, and historic landmarks. Get ready to embark on a gastronomic journey through Menasha, where every meal is a celebration of flavor and local charm.

1. WeatherVane Restaurant

Located in Menasha, the WeatherVane Restaurant is a charming American diner that has captured the hearts (and taste buds) of many visitors. Raving reviews echo the sentiment of delicious offerings, with standout mentions of their indulgent mimosas and strawberry pancakes that are touted as “very filling.” The breakfast buffet seems to transport diners back to nostalgic childhood memories, with fresh ingredients and perfectly cooked eggs stealing the show. Southern platters and a variety of breakfast staples like biscuits and gravy receive high praise, making it a go-to spot for a hearty and satisfying meal. The ambiance seems to add to the experience, with nearby waterfront walks and interesting sites creating a perfect backdrop for a delightful dining escapade at WeatherVane. Whether you opt for the AYCE brunch buffet or select from their classic menu, one thing is certain – this diner is a gem waiting to be discovered by food enthusiasts looking for a memorable meal experience in Menasha.

Rating:
Price:

2. Mihm’s Charcoal Grill

Located in Menasha, Mihm’s Charcoal Grill is a true gem for burger aficionados craving a mouthwatering experience. Specializing in sizzling charcoal-grilled burgers, this spot is a haven for those seeking classic American comfort food with a twist. The rave reviews speak for themselves – patrons praise the juicy steak butter burgers, stacked high with flavorful toppings and served on buttered buns. Don’t miss out on their delectable shakes and malts, a perfect complement to their hearty menu offerings, including cheese curds, chicken sandwiches, and bratwurst. With a retro diner vibe and exceptional customer service, Mihm’s Charcoal Grill stands out as a must-visit spot for a nostalgic yet satisfying dining adventure. And hey, if you’re a Pepsi lover, this place is your paradise!

Rating:
Price:

3. Great Harvest Bread Co. – Neenah

In the heart of Menasha, Great Harvest Bread Co. tantalizes taste buds with their specialty whole-grain breads and muffins crafted from Montana wheat. Revel in the sensory symphony as you savor sandwiches made with fresh bread that’s been lauded for its exceptional quality. Step into a warm, inviting ambiance adorned with floor-to-ceiling windows, rustic brick walls, and the comforting aroma of bread baking – an experience that’s both visually captivating and palate-pleasing. Whether you’re indulging in a breakfast sandwich while witnessing the bread-making process or exploring the vast array of warm and cold sandwiches, breads, and sweets, each visit promises a fusion of delectable flavors and friendly service. Great Harvest Bread Co. isn’t just a bakery; it’s a destination where every bite tells a tale of craftsmanship and culinary delight. So, be sure to swing by and experience the magic for yourself!

Rating:
Price:

4. Little Siam

Little Siam in Menasha is a true gem in the realm of Thai cuisine, with a striking reputation that precedes it. Guests rave about the aromatic and soul-satisfying curry Pad Thai, boasting about its exquisite blend of flavors that dance harmoniously on the palate. Additionally, the pork belly fried rice receives accolades for its luscious texture and generous portion size, making it a standout dish worth savoring. The ambience at this spot is described as enchanting, setting the stage for a delightful evening with friends or loved ones. With a staff that embodies warmth and efficiency, coupled with a menu that caters to varying preferences, Little Siam emerges as an unmissable culinary destination in the Fox Valley region. For those craving a culinary adventure that transcends the ordinary, a visit to Little Siam promises an experience that tantalizes taste buds and leaves a lasting impression.

Rating:
Price:

5. The Old Grog

Located in Menasha, The Old Grog is a culinary gem that has been making waves with its mouthwatering dishes. From perfectly seasoned half-pound cheeseburgers served with crispy edges and fresh buns to a tantalizing array of cheese curds that even self-proclaimed curd nerds rave about, this spot is a definite must-visit. The haddock meals, complete with flavorful coleslaw and tangy tartar sauce, have also captured the hearts of patrons. With a commitment to quick service without compromising on quality, The Old Grog is a hotspot for seafood lovers and burger enthusiasts alike. Don’t miss out on their renowned fish fry – a true treat for your taste buds!

Rating:
Price:

6. Broken Tree Pizza

Located in Menasha, Broken Tree Pizza is a hidden gem that promises an unforgettable culinary experience. This family-friendly pizza spot has gained quite the reputation for its wood-fired pies that are simply out of this world. Boasting a modern setting and hosting lively trivia and music nights, this eatery offers more than just a meal – it’s an event! Customers rave about the friendly staff, with one enthusiastic reviewer loving the addition of honey sauce on their select pizza, giving it a perfect score. Another patron highlighted the exceptional customer service, mentioning how they were pleasantly surprised by the personalized attention and the delicious pizzas and breadsticks that defied the norm. With a new Appleton location on the horizon, Broken Tree Pizza is undoubtedly a must-visit for those seeking a slice of perfection.

Rating:
Price:

7. Greene’s Pour House

Greene’s Pour House in Menasha is a vibrant tavern that’s more than just your average pub spot. Boasting a pet-friendly outdoor seating area and a warm, inviting atmosphere, this place has won the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Dive into their menu, where the Richter Scale Burger steals the show with its mouthwatering freshness, paired perfectly with a hand-muddled whiskey old fashioned. Whether you’re craving a delectable pizza made in-house or a comforting plate of Mac and Cheese, Greene’s Pour House has it all. With a rotating cocktail menu, stellar beer selection, and friendly service, this spot in downtown Neenah is a gem not to be missed for a lively dining experience.

Rating:
Price:

8. Solea Mexican Grill

Located in Menasha, Solea Mexican Grill is a vibrant gem serving up mouthwatering Mexican classics that keep patrons coming back for more. Rave reviews highlight the speedy service that doesn’t compromise on flavor, with dishes like sizzling fajitas and hearty burritos stealing the show. The festive atmosphere, complete with a full bar and happy hour specials, sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. Guests particularly appreciate the attentive staff who go the extra mile, like expertly boxing up leftovers without skipping a beat. With affordable prices and standout items like jumbo margaritas and fish tacos on the menu, Solea Mexican Grill promises a fiesta for your taste buds that you’ll want to relive time and time again.

Rating:
Price:

9. Luigis Pizza & Pasta

In the vibrant town of Menasha, Luigi’s Pizza & Pasta is a culinary gem waiting to be discovered. Savor the flavors of their signature Philly cheese steak, overflowing with onions and mushrooms, as one enamored diner commended its perfection. Dive into a slice of their legendary pizza, whether on a classic crust or a gluten-free cauliflower base, a true crowd-pleaser for all dietary preferences. Amid heartfelt gatherings, Luigi’s shines in providing comfort through their delectable Italian fare, leaving guests raving about the outstanding food and impeccable service. Discover a slice of culinary heaven at Luigi’s, where every bite tells a story of passion and dedication to creating memorable dining experiences in the heart of Menasha.

Rating:
Price:

10. Third Street Diner

Located in Menasha, the Third Street Diner is a hidden gem that promises a delightful dining experience. Patrons rave about the seasonal pancake flavors that add a unique twist to the breakfast and brunch menu, with special mentions for the scrumptious potato pancakes. The generous portions and reasonable prices make it a hit, ensuring you leave with a satisfied belly. The friendly and efficient service adds to the charm of this cozy diner, offering a “down home” feel amidst the bustling city. From the overflowing coffee cups to the mouthwatering dishes, Third Street Diner is sure to become your go-to spot for a fulfilling and delicious meal experience in Menasha.

Rating:
Price: