Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in New Ulm, Minnesota

Located in the heart of Minnesota, New Ulm beckons with its rich culinary tapestry and vibrant dining scene. This lovely town is a haven for food enthusiasts, boasting an array of diverse eateries that cater to every palate. From cozy cafes serving up delectable pastries to upscale restaurants offering a fusion of global flavors, New Ulm is a gastronomic paradise waiting to be explored. Beyond its culinary delights, this quaint town also boasts a wealth of attractions, from historic sites honoring its heritage to scenic parks perfect for leisurely strolls. Join me on a virtual tour as we uncover the Best Restaurants in New Ulm, Minnesota, and discover the flavors that define this charming Midwestern gem.

1. George’s Fine Steaks & Spirits

Located in the charming town of New Ulm, George’s Fine Steaks & Spirits is a culinary gem that promises a top-notch dining experience. The rave reviews speak volumes about the exceptional service, delightful atmosphere, and impeccable quality of the dishes served here. From the fluffy biscuits with whipped honey butter to the perfectly cooked steaks and fresh seafood, every bite is full of flavor and made with care. Don’t miss out on the house-favorite “George” potatoes and the decadent New York strawberry cheesecake for a sweet finish. With a warm and welcoming staff, including the legendary owner George, this restaurant exudes a familial vibe where every guest is treated like a professional food critic. Indulge in a variety of cocktails and wines from their extensive drink list, and savor the delicious meals prepared with attention to detail. George’s Fine Steaks & Spirits is not just a restaurant; it’s an experience that will leave you wanting to return for more.

Rating:
Price:

2. Lakes On 1st

Situated in the charming town of New Ulm, Lakes On 1st is a delightful find for food enthusiasts seeking a cozy dining experience. This small cafe has garnered a well-deserved reputation for its awesome sandwiches that leave patrons raving. From the deliciously seasoned fries to the mouthwatering phil burger, each dish bursts with flavor and is meticulously prepared. The loaded omelet seems to be a crowd favorite, paired perfectly with a steaming cup of coffee. With a loyal following returning regularly for the impeccable service and quality fare, Lakes On 1st promises a memorable culinary escapade worth savoring.

Rating:
Price:

3. Lola – An American Bistro

Lola – An American Bistro in the vibrant town of New Ulm is a culinary delight not to be missed. With a cozy brick-walled space exuding a relaxed ambiance, this gem offers a delectable array of New American fare that has food enthusiasts raving. Guests can indulge in the rich beef and mushroom flavor of the soup, savor the perfectly crafted chicken torta, and delight in the aromatic rosemary garlic fries paired with a divine aioli. Lola’s commitment to using locally sourced ingredients shines through in each dish, elevating the dining experience to new heights. Whether you’re craving a breakfast to die for like the biscuits and gravy or in the mood for a mouthwatering lunch option such as the hot mess, Lola’s menu has something for everyone. The friendly staff, inviting atmosphere, and standout dishes like the best Reuben in town make Lola a must-visit destination for food lovers seeking a memorable culinary experience in New Ulm.

Rating:
Price:

4. Joni’s Restaurant & Catering

Situated in the charming town of New Ulm, Joni’s Restaurant & Catering is a delightful gem that has locals buzzing with excitement. With a warm welcome that sets the tone for a memorable dining experience, this spot boasts a menu that’s both comforting and creative. Patrons rave about the fantastic food, especially the quick and delicious breakfast options that have become a hallmark of this small-town diner. From the friendly staff to the affordable lunch specials, Joni’s is a must-visit for anyone seeking an outstanding culinary adventure in New Ulm.

Rating:
Price:

5. Rodney’s Tavern

If you find yourself in New Ulm craving a delightful dining experience, look no further than Rodney’s Tavern. Boasting a staff that radiates warmth and charm, this gem is a haven for all kinds of food aficionados. From customized vegan pizzas to mouth-watering burgers, every dish is crafted with love and flair. The ambiance resonates with a sense of community, where every patron is greeted like an old friend. Don’t miss out on their famed popper pizza or the legendary Beef Commercial that keeps patrons coming back. Rodney’s Tavern is not just a restaurant; it’s a vibrant culinary journey waiting to be explored.

Rating:
Price:

6. Plaza Garibaldi

Plaza Garibaldi in New Ulm is a vibrant hub of flavor and fun that beckons both locals and visitors alike to indulge in a culinary fiesta. With a large outdoor patio that has become a sought-after gem, this spot seems to have mastered the art of transforming a meal into a memorable experience. The rave reviews about the margaritas are a testament to their unrivaled drink offerings that elevate any dining experience. From the complimentary chips and addictive salsa to the generously portioned enchiladas, every bite at Plaza Garibaldi seems to be a celebration of Mexican cuisine done right. It’s not just a restaurant; it’s a savory escape that promises not to break the bank but rather leave you loosening that belt with contentment. Embrace the drive and let Plaza Garibaldi’s flavors transport you to a culinary paradise in the heart of New Ulm.

Rating:
Price:

7. New Ulm Turner Hall

Located in New Ulm, the New Ulm Turner Hall is a culinary gem offering the best authentic German cuisine in town. Renowned for their succulent ribs and flavorful sauerkraut, this spot is a local favorite for a reason. Patrons rave about the cozy dining area, with some lucky diners even getting to enjoy their meal next to a warm fireplace. The menu boasts a wide variety of options, from classic dishes like steak and walleye to more casual fare like chicken strips and wraps. With top-notch service and a historic ambiance, dining here is a delightful experience for all, making it a must-visit spot for anyone craving a taste of traditional German flavors in New Ulm.

Rating:
Price:

8. Órale Authentic Mexican Tacos & More

Located in New Ulm, Órale Authentic Mexican Tacos & More is a vibrant gem that promises an unforgettable culinary fiesta. Known for its mouthwatering steak fajitas and chicken fajitas served with a special family flour tortilla recipe, this spot is a must-visit for Mexican food aficionados. The Orale margaritas steal the show with their fresh-squeezed juice and tantalizing taste, making them the perfect pairing to elevate your dining experience. While the birria tacos may be petite, the explosion of flavors will leave your taste buds dancing. Don’t miss out on this hidden culinary delight where every bite is a celebration of Mexican authenticity.

Rating:
Price:

9. 209 Pub & Grill

Located in New Ulm, the 209 Pub & Grill is a hotspot that seems to have captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. With a bustling atmosphere that speaks volumes about its popularity, this gem offers a menu that goes beyond the typical bar fare, ensuring a delightful dining experience. From the rave reviews, it’s evident that their chicken, baked potatoes, Cuban sandwiches, and cheeseburgers are a must-try, promising a mouthwatering journey for your taste buds. The attentive service, highlighted by server Lily, adds an extra layer of charm to this already inviting establishment. Whether you’re a regular or just passing through, the 209 Pub & Grill seems to leave a lasting impression, beckoning you to savor their delicious offerings time and time again.

Rating:
Price:

10. Happy Joe’s Pizza & Ice Cream – New Ulm

Tantalizingly situated in New Ulm, Happy Joe’s Pizza & Ice Cream is a vibrant hub of culinary delight that beckons to families and foodies alike. Step inside to discover a treasure trove of delectable pizza options, from the beloved taco pizza to the tantalizing Chicken and Swiss Panini that will have your taste buds dancing with joy. But the magic doesn’t stop there – imagine oversized sundaes that will make your sweet tooth sing! With a playful arcade for the little ones and a charmingly retro decor that exudes a nostalgic charm, Happy Joe’s creates an unforgettable dining experience that leaves guests planning their next visit before they’ve even left. Come for the food, stay for the fun – Happy Joe’s Pizza & Ice Cream is a culinary gem waiting to be explored in the heart of New Ulm.

Rating:
Price: