Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Jamestown, New York

Nestled in the southern reaches of New York State, Jamestown offers a surprisingly vibrant and diverse culinary scene that belies its modest size. This town, known for being the birthplace of the legendary Lucille Ball, has, over the years, cultivated a dining experience that reflects both its rich heritage and contemporary flair. From cozy, family-run eateries offering mouthwatering classic American comfort food to innovative restaurants that showcase a modern twist on traditional dishes, Jamestown’s food landscape is as varied as it is delightful. Whether you’re in the mood for the heartiness of an Italian feast, the spicy kick of authentic Mexican cuisine, or the refined flavors of gourmet dining, this charming town has a table waiting for every type of food lover.

1. Forte

Nestled in an enchanting nook with dim lighting and captivating red walls, Forte instantly sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. It’s not merely a restaurant; it’s a culinary adventure that blends the familiar with the exotic, offering an array of global dishes that will whisk your taste buds from the cozy comfort of poutine to the refined elegance of sushi. The cocktails, a masterpiece of mixology, are equally deserving of applause, with each sip promising a journey of its own. The dedication to culinary perfection is evident in every dish, particularly the steak, which is celebrated for its flawless sear and cook—a testament to the skill and passion that pulses through the kitchen. With an atmosphere that beckons for impromptu date nights and evenings where dining transcends into an experience, Forte stands as a beacon of gastronomic excellence, affordable luxury, and heartwarming hospitality.

Rating:
Price:

2. Labyrinth Press Company

Stepping into the Labyrinth Press in Jamestown is like finding an eclectic sanctuary for the senses, combining a vibrant atmosphere with a delectable array of vegetarian and vegan cuisine. From the cozy, slightly-below-ground dining room bathed in light to the upstairs Brazil Lounge, this eatery ticks all the boxes for those seeking comfort food with a creative twist. The menu is a journey of flavors, offering everything from hearty chili and warm rice bowls to inventive flatbreads and the much-loved cauliflower appetizer with just the right kick. Service here is more than just a transaction; it’s an invitation into a warm, homey setting where every dish, whether it’s the Butternut Squash Ravioli or the layered nachos, is prepared with care. The Labyrinth Press isn’t just a dining destination; it’s a vibrant hub of culinary creativity where every visit promises something deliciously unexpected.

Rating:
Price:

3. Crown Street Roasting Company

Situated in the charming town of Jamestown, Crown Street Roasting Company is a gem worth discovering. Boasting a serene atmosphere and exceptional service, this local coffee shop stands out for its meticulously crafted coffee, delectable pastries, and mouthwatering bagels. Whether you’re seeking a peaceful place to savor a perfectly brewed cortado or looking to dive into a Ham Apple Gouda sandwich, Crown Street has you covered. The staff’s dedication to excellence shines through their attention to detail, making each visit a delightful experience. Don’t miss out on this welcoming and refined local business that’s sure to become your favorite spot for a morning pick-me-up or a relaxing work session.

Rating:
Price:

4. Brazil Craft Beer and Wine Lounge

Stepping into this easygoing lounge feels like uncovering a hidden gem, especially for those with a penchant for vegetarian cuisine. The atmosphere effortlessly blends a relaxed vibe with a touch of sophistication, thanks in part to a wine list that impresses with its depth and variety. The food, from the butternut squash ravioli to the innovative African Peanut Burger, is a delightful exploration of flavors that caters to both vegetarians and gluten-free diners without sacrificing taste or creativity. The standout, however, might just be the Korean Beer Fries – a dish that alone makes a return visit a tempting promise. Whether you’re dining under the stars on their picturesque patio or enjoying the warm, inviting interior, this lounge in Jamestown, NY, is a celebration of great food, excellent service, and an atmosphere that lingers with you, long after the meal is over.

Rating:
Price:

5. Allen Street Diner

Nestled in the heart of Jamestown, the Allen Street Diner embodies the quintessence of a hometown gem that’s not just serving meals but doling out experiences. From the perfectly folded mushroom Swiss omelette that could easily become any morning’s highlight to the novelty of a French onion soup burger that surprises with its burst of flavors, this diner takes pride in its freshly prepared fare and hand-cut French fries. The ambiance is as inviting as the food, with a warm dining area where conversations flow as freely as the coffee, thanks to the fun, chatty owner and the exceptional staff who treat everyone like family. Whether you’re in town chasing the echoes of Lucy or seeking that rare blend of delightful food and genuine hospitality, Allen Street Diner promises an encounter that’s both heartwarming and satisfyingly tasty.

Rating:
Price:

6. Landmark Restaurant

Embarking on a culinary adventure at the Landmark feels like stepping into a haven of comfort food paired with an elegance that surprises and delights. The moment you cross the threshold, the welcoming atmosphere sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. Their mastery in crafting dishes like the Stockyard Ribeye and Chicken Florentine, alongside an array of gluten-free options, showcases a dedication to both quality and inclusivity. The bread, often heralded as a must-try, hints at the magic happening in the kitchen, making every bite a testament to the chefs’ prowess. From the meticulous presentation to the generous portions, Landmark proves itself as a culinary gem where every visit promises a fusion of homey vibes with a sprinkle of gastronomic sophistication, ensuring that an anniversary or any day merits a celebration here.

Rating:
Price:

7. Lena’s Pizza

Nestled in a cozy, casual setting, this long-standing family-owned pizzeria has managed to capture the hearts and palates of pizza aficionados far and wide, including those who’ve sampled the iconic pies of Naples, Italy. Regarded by many as a culinary treasure, patrons make it a point to visit Lena’s for their unparalleled pies, even if it means a lengthy drive. Not to be overlooked, their appetizing wings and delightful fried mushrooms accompanied by a flavorful blue cheese sauce also receive high praise. Whether you’re a local or passing through, Lena’s pizzeria promises an unforgettable experience that’s bound to leave you planning your next visit before you’ve even left.

Rating:
Price:

8. The Chop House on Main

Situated in the vibrant town of Jamestown, The Chop House on Main exudes excellence in every bite. Diners rave about the impeccable service that elevates special occasions, like birthdays, to unforgettable moments. While steak and seafood shine here, even non-traditional connoisseurs find delight in dishes like the chicken caprese bursting with colorful veggies. The exquisite beef cheek crostini appetizer sets the stage for an extraordinary culinary journey, complemented by a charmingly old-school service style. With live music adding a delightful touch to the ambiance, this gem guarantees a dining experience that’s a cut above the rest. If you’re in search of a culinary oasis, The Chop House on Main is your destination for a sensational gastronomic adventure in Jamestown.

Rating:
Price:

9. The Coffee Cup

Embarking on a culinary journey at this charming establishment is akin to being wrapped in a warm, welcoming hug, thanks to the super friendly staff that seems to treat everyone like family. From the cozy ambiance that makes you want to curl up with a coffee to the generously sized portions that ensure you leave more than satisfied, every visit feels like a special occasion. The dedication of the team shines through, especially during challenging times, making it a beacon of comfort and deliciousness through the pandemic. Whether you’re popping in for a quick bite or settling in for a leisurely meal, the unwavering commitment to accommodating every request with a smile ensures a delightful dining experience that tantalizes the taste buds and warms the heart.

Rating:
Price:

10. The Pub

Located in the bustling town of Jamestown, The Pub is a cash-only gem renowned for its hearty American fare and vintage charm. A standout dish that keeps patrons coming back is the Goat Cheese and Cranberry salad with chicken, a delightful mix of flavors that left one reviewer in awe. Another diner raved about the St. Patrick’s Eve experience, highlighting the mouthwatering ravioli with Mary’s red sauce and the heavenly chocolate brownie with minty frosting. The Pub also shines with its Italian offerings, with customers praising the sausage ravioli, Beef on weck, and homemade soups, all served up by the friendly and efficient staff. For a cozy and satisfying dining experience, make sure to stop by The Pub in Jamestown.

Rating:
Price: