Best Restaurants in Pocatello, Idaho

Fifth Street Bagelry in Pocatello is a bagel haven waiting to elevate your breakfast game. Offering a delightful array of bagel choices, from the classic favorites to innovative spins, this spot has bagel aficionados raving. The 7 layer coconut block is a must-try, boasting a delectable sweetness that lingers on your taste buds. With a nod to healthy options and fresh produce, this gem stands out as a prime spot for a casual date or a laid-back hangout with friends. The friendly service and chill atmosphere only add to the appeal, making Fifth Street Bagelry a top contender in Pocatello’s culinary scene. Whether you’re a local looking for a new breakfast spot or a visitor wanting a taste of the city, this bagel joint promises a satisfying experience that’ll keep you coming back for more.

If you find yourself in Pocatello and craving a hearty, comforting meal, look no further than Jeri’s Jumbo’s Cafe. This low-key daytime spot is a hidden gem, serving up homestyle diner fare that will leave your taste buds singing. From the rave reviews of their biscuits & gravy to the mouthwatering chicken noodle soup that one patron claims is the best they’ve ever had, Jeri’s clearly knows how to whip up some culinary magic. The cafe’s cult following speaks volumes about the quality of their food, with everything being homemade, from the hash browns to the jam. Even though wait times can be lengthy, the consistency and deliciousness of the food make it worth every minute. Misty, the fantastic server mentioned in the reviews, ensures that your dining experience is top-notch, leaving you happily in a food coma by the end of your meal. Don’t miss out on this gem of a restaurant that has been pleasing patrons for close to 60 years – Jeri’s Jumbo’s Cafe is a must-visit for anyone looking for a memorable dining experience in Pocatello!

In the heart of Pocatello lies Red Hot Roasters, a culinary gem that beckons all coffee aficionados and food enthusiasts alike. Patrons rave about the impeccable coffee, with one reviewer highlighting it as “perfect.” The Reuben sandwich with potato salad seems to be a crowd favorite, leaving diners yearning for more delectable bites. And let’s not forget about the chai tea, touted as the best in Idaho, outshining even the big coffee chains. The warm and friendly atmosphere, coupled with top-notch service, sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re a solo coffee seeker or gathering a group for breakfast, Red Hot Roasters promises a feast that delights the taste buds and warms the soul. Start your day right and make this spot a must-visit on your culinary journey through Pocatello!

Located in Pocatello, the Outer Limits Fun Zone is a vibrant hub of entertainment and delicious dining. With a plethora of activities like laser tag, mini-golf, and arcade games, this place is a hit for families, date nights, and even work gatherings. The engaging atmosphere and diverse attractions, like the thrilling Krazy Darts, promise hours of fun and friendly competition. Don’t miss out on the tasty food offerings that have garnered rave reviews, showcasing the chef’s dedication to crafting delectable dishes. Whether you’re looking for a unique spot for photos, a delightful meal, or an action-packed outing, Outer Limits Fun Zone is a must-visit destination in Pocatello.

Located in the vibrant town of Pocatello, Xeus & Apollo’s beckons both seasoned gamers and food enthusiasts alike. The warm reception from the staff sets the tone for a delightful dining experience. Delve into their signature Pastrami Burger and fries, a crowd-pleaser for its quality and generous portions, offering great value for your money. For those with a sweet tooth, the Italian Sodas and Milkshakes are a must-try. With a bustling Friday Night Magic tournament and the promise of delectable pastries, this gem promises not just a meal but a memorable escapade. Xeus & Apollo’s is a haven where good food, great company, and fun games converge to create unforgettable moments.

Located in downtown Pocatello, Sumisu is a gem for sushi enthusiasts seeking an unforgettable dining experience. Boasting a fusion of Japanese-inspired flavors and artfully crafted specialty rolls, this informal eatery has left patrons raving. From the garlicky goodness of the edamame appetizer to the exquisite Tiny Dancer and Super Rainbow rolls, Sumisu’s commitment to using the finest ingredients and employing masterful chefs shines through in each bite. Whether you’re a sushi aficionado or a newbie to the scene, this spot is a must-visit for a blend of Americanized and traditional rolls, with standouts like the Yellowstone roll stealing the spotlight. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service, as praised by loyal customers, elevate Sumisu to a must-try destination for quality sushi in Pocatello.

Located in Pocatello, El Herradero is a culinary gem offering a fiesta of flavors that will transport you straight to Mexico. The Chile Verdi burrito, generously packed with succulent pork chunks and zesty green sauce, is a fan favorite, as attested by one satisfied diner who couldn’t resist taking some home for later. If nachos are more your style, the Super Nachos here are a must-try, according to another enthusiastic reviewer who dubbed them as the best in town. The attentive service, speedy delivery of piping hot dishes, and a lively ambiance make this spot a top pick for those craving authentic Mexican cuisine in Idaho. With horchata on the menu adding a sweet note to round off your meal, El Herradero is a must-visit for foodies seeking a true south-of-the-border culinary experience.

Located in Pocatello, Elmer’s Restaurant is a hidden gem for those seeking a hearty and delicious breakfast experience. With a diner-style setting and friendly staff, this quaint spot stands out for its generous portions and warm atmosphere. Customers rave about the fresh-made dishes, like the Dungeness crab eggs Benedict and perfectly cooked bacon. Families love the thoughtful touches like Crayons and activity book menus for the little ones, making dining here a relaxing and enjoyable experience. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Elmer’s Restaurant is a must-visit for a memorable breakfast in Pocatello that will leave you planning your next return.

Located in the heart of Pocatello, Buddy’s Italian Restaurant is a longstanding gem serving up authentic Italian cuisine and housemade pasta that keeps patrons coming back for more. With a cozy ambiance adding to its charm, this eatery has garnered a loyal following. Guests rave about the fettuccine Alfredo, a standout dish that consistently receives high praise. The attentive staff, exemplified by a waiter who goes above and beyond, ensures a pleasant dining experience. Don’t miss out on their delectable caramel ice cream, a sweet treat that perfectly rounds off a satisfying meal at this Italian hotspot.

Located in Pocatello, The Healthier Place To Eat is a casual haven for food enthusiasts seeking wholesome delights. With a warm and welcoming owner who radiates kindness, this spot exudes a cozy charm that’s hard to resist. Patrons rave about the empanadas, crafted with divine flour, and the innovative cauliflower crust pizza. Vegan diners rejoice in the plethora of plant-based options, with highlights like the cashew burger stealing the show. Whether you’re a health-conscious foodie or just looking for a flavorful bite, this gem promises a satisfying experience that keeps customers coming back for more.