Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Stonington, Connecticut

Located along the picturesque coastline of Connecticut, Stonington is a charming town brimming with culinary delights waiting to be explored. Known for its rich maritime history and quaint New England charm, this lovely town beckons food enthusiasts to discover its culinary treasures. From seaside seafood shacks serving up the freshest catches to cozy cafes dishing out artisanal pastries, Stonington boasts a diverse culinary scene that caters to every palate. Step into the Best Restaurants in Stonington to embark on a gastronomic journey that showcases the unique flavors and culinary talents this welcoming town has to offer. In addition to its exceptional dining options, Stonington also boasts historic landmarks, scenic waterfront views, and a vibrant arts community, making it a must-visit destination for both foodies and explorers alike.

1. Waffle Pop Sweet Shop

Indulge your sweet tooth at Waffle Pop Sweet Shop in Stonington, where delectable treats await! This charming spot is a must-visit, offering a delightful array of waffle pops and gelato that are bound to satisfy even the most discerning taste buds. Dive into the heavenly Mama waffle topped with juicy strawberries or savor the luscious strawberry shortcake gelato that has patrons raving. With a sweet wall of Jelly Bellys and an assortment of local gift items, this shop is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make it the perfect spot for a family outing or a quick treat during your visit to the Velvet Mill. Don’t miss out on the chance to experience the best of both worlds at Waffle Pop Sweet Shop – a true gem in Stonington’s culinary scene!

Rating:
Price:

2. Flour Shop Bagels

In the heart of Stonington lies Flour Shop Bagels, a charming establishment that has locals and visitors alike buzzing with enthusiasm. The word on the street is that their Jalapeño Havarti bagel is a game-changer, striking the perfect balance between warmth, chewiness, and flavor. Customers are gushing over the delightful array of bagel options, with the Everything bagel stealing the show with its generous toppings. From the professionalism of the staff to the cozy ambiance, Flour Shop Bagels seems to have nailed the art of creating a welcoming breakfast haven. With custom-crafted drinks and an array of mouthwatering sandwiches like the Magic Garden, this spot is quickly becoming a go-to for those seeking a delicious and soul-warming start to their day. So, if you find yourself in Stonington craving an unforgettable bagel experience, Flour Shop Bagels should be at the top of your list.

Rating:
Price:

3. Whitecrest Eatery

If you’re seeking a culinary adventure in Stonington, look no further than Whitecrest Eatery. Situated in the vibrant Velvet Mill, this gem offers a limited menu bursting with flavorful surprises. From mouthwatering tacos with zesty salsas to a unique spin on the classic Cob Salad, every dish is a masterpiece. The Veggie Burger and Rasta Pasta are hailed as must-tries, while the fall-off-the-bone ribs and jerk cream sauce of the Rasta Pasta are described as pure bliss. Don’t miss out on their crispy potatoes or delectable sourdough bread, perfect for crafting a scrumptious French Onion soup at home. Whitecrest Eatery beckons with its inviting ambiance, friendly service, and a menu that promises a culinary journey worth savoring. A visit here is sure to leave you yearning for more tasty delights in this charming coastal town.

Rating:
Price:

4. Stonington Pizza Palace

Situated in Stonington, the Stonington Pizza Palace is a hidden gem that promises a culinary journey like no other. Boasting a menu that goes beyond the ordinary pie parlor, this place serves up a tantalizing array of grinders, pasta, seafood, and even some Greek delights. Whether you’re craving a mouthwatering calzone, flavorful wings, or the unexpected yet delightful spaghetti pizza that has patrons raving, every dish here is crafted to perfection. With loyal customers returning after years and newcomers instantly falling in love, it’s no surprise that this spot stands out as a must-visit. Indulge in their Philly Cheesesteak Eggrolls, savory sausage pizza, or hearty baked ziti for a dining experience that will leave you craving more. The Stonington Pizza Palace isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a flavorful memory in the making, beckoning you to savor every bite and create your own unforgettable story.

Rating:
Price:

5. Noah’s

Step into the cozy and inviting world of Noah’s, a gem located in the historic town of Stonington. This spot not only offers a delightful atmosphere with its mahogany bar and tin ceilings but also tantalizes taste buds with New England comfort food. Indulge in vegan-friendly options like oatmeal and fresh fruit, showcasing their dedication to catering to all diners. The menu boasts delights like Bulgogi lettuce wraps and baked haddock cooked to perfection, with a slight misstep in the dessert department easily forgiven in the grand scheme of a superb dining experience. Don’t miss out on the fresh and yummy local Oysters or the heavenly Wild Blueberry Pancakes for breakfast. With a reputation for excellent service and a relaxing ambiance, Noah’s is a must-visit hotspot in Stonington for a memorable culinary journey.

Rating:
Price:

6. Water Street Cafe

Water Street Cafe in Stonington is a culinary gem that truly delivers on flavor and ambiance. This New American cafe boasts a raw bar overflowing with the freshest local seafood and produce, creating a dining experience that is nothing short of sensational. Guests rave about the vegan options, with one reviewer highlighting the delectable vegan entrée that left taste buds tingling. Seafood aficionados will rejoice at the mention of the best salmon ever tasted, drawing food enthusiasts back time and time again. The lively atmosphere, complete with live music, adds a touch of magic to an already remarkable dining experience. With exceptional service and a menu that promises culinary delights, Water Street Cafe is a must-visit spot in Stonington for those craving a memorable meal.

Rating:
Price:

7. Milagro Cafe

Located in the charming town of Stonington, Milagro Cafe is a vibrant gem in the culinary scene. This cozy Mexican eatery has garnered praise for its classic dishes and specialty margaritas that leave taste buds tingling with delight. Guests rave about the impeccable service and the beautiful, clean atmosphere that sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. Patrons sing praises of the freshly fried corn tortilla chips paired with flavorful guacamole, setting the tone for a delightful culinary journey. From the mouthwatering chicken tacos to the authentic fish tacos, each dish showcases the chef’s dedication to delivering an exquisite taste of Mexico. Don’t miss out on their unique Mexican soda offerings like watermelon and mandarin, adding a refreshing twist to your meal. Whether you’re craving a cinnamon and sugar margarita or indulging in a decadent lava cake, Milagro Cafe promises to transport your taste buds on a delicious adventure that will have you coming back for more. A must-visit spot for Mexican cuisine enthusiasts in Stonington!

Rating:
Price:

8. BREAKWATER

Situated in the picturesque town of Stonington, BREAKWATER is a culinary gem that promises an unforgettable dining experience. Boasting an airy and contemporary waterfront setting, this restaurant offers a delectable array of refined seafood and New American fare that will tantalize your taste buds. From the rave reviews highlighting the mouthwatering gnocchi and daily specials like the swordfish steak, to the delightful atmosphere featuring both indoor and outdoor seating with stunning sunset views, BREAKWATER truly captures the essence of coastal dining. Indulge in their delectable clam chowder, share some truffle fries, and sip on expertly crafted cocktails while soaking in the waterfront ambiance. With friendly service and a relaxed vibe, this is the perfect spot to unwind and savor the flavors of the ocean. Get ready to immerse yourself in a culinary journey that perfectly blends flavors, ambiance, and hospitality at BREAKWATER.

Rating:
Price:

9. Woodfellas Pizza & Wings

Located in the charming town of Stonington, Woodfellas Pizza & Wings is a culinary gem that has been making waves with its delectable offerings. A must-try is the innovative Pizza Fries, a harmonious blend of fries, zesty pizza sauce, gooey cheese, and savory pepperoni, creating a flavor explosion in every bite. Their pizzas are a work of art, with a perfect balance of a crispy yet chewy crust, mouthwatering sauce, and high-quality toppings, earning them the title of serving some of the best pies in the area. Standout dishes like the One Eyed Cody and the unforgettable Potato Pizza showcase the chef’s creativity and dedication to culinary excellence. Embrace the experience and indulge in Woodfellas’ creations for a truly unforgettable dining adventure in Stonington.

Rating:
Price:

10. Stonington Fish & Lobster

If you find yourself in Stonington craving the freshest seafood the town has to offer, look no further than Stonington Fish & Lobster. This spot isn’t just a typical restaurant; it’s a seafood lover’s paradise where quality reigns supreme. Customers rave about the outstanding quality of the fish, some even comparing it favorably to top-notch restaurant fare. With a no-fuss, self-serve setup and a wide selection of frozen seafood, this gem stands out for its fantastic quality and service. Whether you’re a local seafood aficionado or just passing through, a visit to Stonington Fish & Lobster is a must for a true taste of the sea.

Rating:
Price: