Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in New Shoreham, Rhode Island

In the heart of Rhode Island lies New Shoreham, a charming coastal town brimming with culinary delights and captivating attractions. Known for its picturesque vistas and vibrant community, this seaside haven boasts a diverse array of dining options that cater to every palate. From seaside seafood shacks to upscale eateries with farm-to-table fare, the ‘Best Restaurants in New Shoreham’ offer a gastronomic journey like no other. As you explore this lovely town, you’ll also discover historic lighthouses, pristine beaches, and quaint shops that add to its irresistible allure. So, pack your appetite and sense of adventure, and get ready to indulge in the flavors of this enchanting coastal destination.

1. The Lunch-Bucket Block Island

Located in the vibrant town of New Shoreham on Block Island, The Lunch-Bucket Block Island is a culinary gem that embodies the essence of coastal dining. Boasting a perfect 5-star rating, this charming spot has garnered praise for its delectable offerings and picturesque views. From the best bacon, egg, and cheese sandwiches to refreshing smoothies and indulgent hash browns, every dish is a flavorful delight. Step into this cozy establishment and savor the mouthwatering flavors while enjoying the breathtaking scenery. With outdoor seating and a dog-friendly atmosphere, The Lunch-Bucket Block Island is a must-visit destination for both locals and tourists alike. Unwind with a scrumptious meal, soak in the coastal vibes, and immerse yourself in the ultimate Block Island dining experience.

Rating:
Price:

2. Persephone’s Kitchen

Persephone’s Kitchen in New Shoreham is a vibrant and buzzing cafe that has captured the hearts (and taste buds!) of locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re seeking a delightful breakfast or a satisfying lunch, this charming spot near the town center is the place to be. With its cozy indoor seating and ample outdoor seating, you can soak up the island vibes while savoring their renowned blush smoothie that has left patrons raving. Known for serving the best cup of coffee on Block Island, this cafe offers an array of hot drinks, iced coffees, teas, smoothies, and even kombuchas that will surely hit the spot. And let’s not forget about their mouthwatering breakfast options – from the splendid egg sandwich to a plethora of delectable baked goods, Persephone’s Kitchen is a must-visit destination to kickstart your day in style. So, if you find yourself on Block Island, make sure to make a beeline to this hotspot for a culinary experience that promises to delight your senses beyond measure.

Rating:
Price:

3. Club Soda

Located in the vibrant town of New Shoreham, Club Soda stands out as a lively hangout where good times and great flavors collide. Boasting a wide array of libations from beer and wine to expertly crafted cocktails, this gem offers more than just drinks. The mention of pool and foosball games, live music, and a charming patio area adds an extra layer of fun to the dining experience. The rave reviews echo a consistent theme of superb service and mouthwatering dishes. From quick and delicious bar bites to family-friendly dining, Club Soda seems to effortlessly cater to all tastes. Don’t miss out on their renowned trivia nights that promise an evening of brain-teasing entertainment. With such glowing feedback, it’s no wonder this spot is a must-visit on every Block Island trip.

Rating:
Price:

4. Odd Fellows Cafe

Nestled in the vibrant town of New Shoreham, Odd Fellows Cafe is a true gem for both locals and island explorers. With rave reviews flooding in like a tidal wave, it’s no wonder this cafe has become a must-stop destination. From their renowned iced coffee that has become the stuff of legends to the delightful smoothies that even have the little ones begging for more, Odd Fellows Cafe has something for everyone. The whimsical and creative upstairs seating area offers a unique experience, making every visit a memorable one. So, whether you’re in need of a caffeine fix or a satisfying lunch, Odd Fellows Cafe is the perfect place to sip, savor, and soak in the charm of Block Island.

Rating:
Price:

5. Block Island Oyster Bar and Grill

Located in the charming town of New Shoreham, the Block Island Oyster Bar and Grill is a culinary gem that promises an unforgettable dining experience. Step into a world where every detail is crafted to perfection, from the fantastic ambience to the delectable food offerings. Indulge in a feast for the senses as you savor dishes like the miso-glazed cod and whole sea bass, expertly seasoned to tantalize your taste buds. Whether you choose to dine outside on the patio by the fountain under the night sky’s excellent lighting or opt for the side patio in the enchanting gardens, each bite is a symphony of flavors. Don’t miss the live music nights for an added touch of entertainment to complement your exquisite meal. Block Island Oyster Bar and Grill is a must-visit for those seeking a blend of culinary excellence and delightful surroundings in New Shoreham.

Rating:
Price:

6. Dead Eye Dick’s

In the vibrant culinary scene of New Shoreham, Dead Eye Dick’s stands out as a gem for both locals and visitors alike. Offering a delectable array of steak and seafood dishes, this casual eatery has garnered a reputation for its fresh and flavorful meals. Patrons rave about the personalized service and the tantalizing selection on the menu, with each dish exuding a homemade charm and bursting with quality ingredients. A must-visit spot on Block Island, where every bite feels like a culinary masterpiece. Indulge in their signature Lobster Avocado BLT for a lunchtime treat that will leave your taste buds singing with delight.

Rating:
Price:

7. McAloon’s Restaurant

Located in New Shoreham, McAloon’s Restaurant is a must-visit spot for those craving a delightful culinary experience. Offering a blend of local seafood and Irish-inspired delights, this casual and family-friendly eatery has garnered rave reviews for its mouthwatering dishes. From the savory shepherd’s pie to the stuffed salmon and Rueben sandwich, McAloon’s doesn’t disappoint in delivering flavors that leave taste buds tingling with delight. The quick and friendly service adds an extra layer of charm to the dining experience, ensuring that visitors feel warmly welcomed. With a well-rounded menu and a cozy bar setting, McAloon’s stands out as a top dining destination on the island, making it a definite recommendation for anyone seeking a memorable meal.

Rating:
Price:

8. Hotel Manisses

Located in New Shoreham, Hotel Manisses offers an elegant American dining experience that promises to tantalize your taste buds. With a raw bar and generous outdoor seating, this culinary gem has garnered rave reviews for its impeccable service and cozy ambiance. Patrons have praised the attentive staff, with special mentions to Faye and Tyrone, who go above and beyond to ensure a memorable visit. The menu boasts a delectable array of dishes, perfect for a romantic anniversary celebration or a gathering with friends. With the enchanting garden setting, complete with weeping willows and a charming fountain, coupled with the convenience of being within walking distance to town, Hotel Manisses is a must-visit culinary destination in New Shoreham, beckoning both locals and travelers alike to indulge in a truly unforgettable dining experience.

Rating:
Price:

9. Beachead

Situated in the picturesque town of New Shoreham, Beachead offers a delightful dining experience that perfectly blends surf ‘n’ turf flavors with a cozy country charm. As you savor each bite, you’ll be enchanted by the waterfront views from the porch, creating a serene backdrop for your meal. The menu is a delightful medley of fresh seafood and hearty meats, ensuring there’s something for every palate. Guests rave about the impeccable service and the inviting atmosphere, making it the ideal spot for a leisurely lunch or a relaxing dinner. With outdoor seating overlooking the ocean and a well-stocked bar, Beachead is a must-visit gem on Block Island for food enthusiasts seeking a memorable culinary adventure.

Rating:
Price:

10. Captain Nick’s Rock-n-Roll Bar (Seasonal May-Septemeber)

Located in New Shoreham, Captain Nick’s Rock-n-Roll Bar is not your average seasonal haunt – it’s a rustic watering hole that transforms into a lively hotspot from May to September. With an outdoor deck, live bands, piano bar, and disco nights, this place is where the party truly happens. Imagine indulging in delicious bites while enjoying the upbeat tunes of dueling pianists Neil & Danielle, as highlighted in the rave reviews. The ambiance is electric, the staff exuding awesome vibes, and the prices surprisingly reasonable, making it a must-visit spot for those seeking a good time. And let’s not forget the food shack at the back serving up a killer burger that’s garnered high praises. Captain Nick’s is not just a bar – it’s an experience worth discovering in the heart of New Shoreham.

Rating:
Price: