Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Island Heights, New Jersey

Situated in the heart of New Jersey, Island Heights beckons food aficionados with its eclectic culinary landscape and charming ambiance. This lovely town boasts a delightful array of eateries that cater to every palate, making it a haven for gastronomes seeking the Best Restaurants in Island Heights. Beyond its culinary delights, this quaint town is a treasure trove of attractions, from scenic waterfront views to historic sites that offer a glimpse into the town’s rich heritage. Join us on a culinary adventure through Island Heights, where every meal is a flavor-packed journey waiting to be savored.

1. Dina’s Bistro

Dina’s Bistro in Island Heights is a culinary gem that embodies the essence of a family-operated restaurant. From the warm ambiance to the personalized service, every visit to Dina’s feels like a homecoming. The menu boasts an array of delights, with standout dishes like the succulent halibut and perfectly cooked salmon stealing the spotlight. Guests rave about the delectable appetizers, especially the shrimp and long hots, setting the stage for a memorable dining experience. The dedication of the owners, Jesse, Dina, and Richie, shines through in every detail, ensuring that patrons are not just customers but part of the extended family. Make sure to indulge in the heavenly desserts that are a testament to the culinary prowess of this hidden culinary treasure. With each visit, Dina’s Bistro promises a feast for both the senses and the soul, making it a must-visit destination in Island Heights for all food enthusiasts.

Rating:
Price:

2. Rosie’s Ocean Gate

Located in Island Heights, Rosie’s Ocean Gate is a culinary gem worth discovering in the dining landscape. With an elegant and cozy ambiance that surprises even the most discerning diners, Rosie’s sets the stage for an exceptional dining experience. The menu boasts an array of delectable options, from the mouthwatering hamburger – hailed as one of the best in town with flavorful meat cooked to perfection – to the exquisite pork belly and smoked bacon appetizer that promises a unique culinary journey. The attentive and knowledgeable staff, combined with heavy-pour cocktails and outrageously good food from appetizers to desserts, make Rosie’s a standout choice for any occasion. Embrace the inviting atmosphere, indulge in the visually appealing dishes, and let Rosie’s Ocean Gate become your year-round culinary sanctuary. Don’t miss out on the special entertainment nights – just ask when you make your reservation to elevate your dining experience at Rosie’s.

Rating:
Price:

3. Anchor Inn

Situated in the charming town of Island Heights, the Anchor Inn is a local treasure that has stood the test of time, drawing in patrons for generations. With a menu that boasts mouthwatering Crab Cakes, perfectly baked potatoes, and savory Bar Pies topped with a delightful array of sausage, peppers, and onions, this establishment truly knows how to tantalize the taste buds. The ambiance, described as unchanged for decades, adds a touch of nostalgia to the dining experience, creating a cozy and welcoming atmosphere for all visitors. Whether you’re craving a classic pizza or looking to indulge in a juicy Delmonico Steak, Anchor Inn promises a delightful culinary journey that keeps patrons coming back for more. So, if you’re seeking a family-friendly spot with exceptional service, reasonable prices, and a menu that never disappoints, Anchor Inn is a must-visit destination in Island Heights.

Rating:
Price:

4. Big Dogs Cafe (Toms River)

If you find yourself in Island Heights, make sure to swing by Big Dogs Cafe on rt 37 for a dining experience that hits all the right notes. Indulge in their generously portioned dishes that are not only delectable but also bursting with flavors that will leave you craving for more. Whether you opt for the mushroom blue burger, the all American burger, or dive into the mozzarella sticks that have been raved about, each bite promises to be a culinary delight. The convenience of its location paired with exceptional service adds an extra layer of charm to this gem of a cafe. Big Dogs Cafe is a must-visit for those on the lookout for a memorable meal that exceeds expectations. With such glowing reviews and mouthwatering options on the menu, this spot is sure to become a favorite haunt for food enthusiasts in search of a top-notch dining experience in Island Heights.

Rating:
Price:

5. Bandwagon Diner

Serving up hearty vibes and classic comfort dishes, Bandwagon Diner in Island Heights is a must-visit spot for food enthusiasts seeking a taste of nostalgia. Boasting a brand-new building with a chic diner-style interior, this family-owned gem has received rave reviews for its consistent food quality and welcoming atmosphere. From indulgent pancakes to mouthwatering burgers, every dish here hits the spot, drawing in patrons who appreciate a perfect blend of tradition and modernity. With a standout mention of the attentive service and the delightful addition of a soup with their sandwiches, Bandwagon Diner promises a satisfying culinary experience that keeps diners coming back for more. For those craving a dose of familiarity with a fresh twist, this eatery is a top contender in the vibrant food scene of Island Heights.

Rating:
Price:

6. Wawa

In the vibrant town of Island Heights, Wawa shines as a beacon of convenience and friendliness for locals and visitors alike. With a dedicated staff known for their warm smiles and eagerness to assist, this particular Wawa stands out as a favorite among patrons for its top-notch service. Despite the absence of a gas station, the ample parking and impressive selection of food items and snacks make it a go-to spot for quick bites and delicious treats. The cleanliness of the establishment is coupled with the charm of the people, creating an inviting atmosphere where you’ll always find what you need with a side of super-friendly service. So, the next time you’re in Island Heights craving a delightful experience, make sure to swing by Wawa and say hello to the lovely folks like Abby who embody the essence of outstanding customer service.

Rating:
Price:

7. Mia’s Pizza Toms River NJ

In the quaint town of Island Heights, Mia’s Pizza in Toms River, NJ is a gem that has captured the hearts (and taste buds) of locals and travelers alike. Hailing from the Big Apple, one delighted reviewer raved about Mia’s ability to deliver a slice reminiscent of NYC’s finest, with a crispy crust that’s a perfect canvas for generous toppings. Another patron praised Mia’s for consistently hitting the mark with their delicious offerings, from savory white slices to classic pepperoni, all while keeping wallets happy. The delivery service also shines, with mouthwatering dishes like chicken Alfredo and lasagna arriving hot and plentiful, ensuring a satisfying experience that stretches beyond a single meal. With Mia’s Pizza, a culinary journey awaits where every bite promises a symphony of flavors that will keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

8. Wawa

Located in Island Heights, Wawa is a beloved gem for both locals and travelers alike. Renowned for their delectable sandwiches and top-notch coffee, this spot offers a convenient stop for fuel and treats any time of the day or night. It’s clear from the rave reviews that Wawa is more than just a pit stop – it’s an experience. Guests praise the quick and friendly service, with one mentioning the helpful staff going above and beyond to assist with carrying out meals. Whether you’re in the mood for a speedy snack or a customized meal, Wawa delivers with a smile. With a reputation for cleanliness, efficiency, and a well-maintained space, it’s no wonder Wawa stands out as a must-visit spot in the area. If you’re seeking a seamless blend of convenience and quality, look no further than this Island Heights staple.

Rating:
Price:

9. Roy Rogers

Step into a culinary time capsule at Roy Rogers in Island Heights, where classic American fast food reigns supreme. With a nostalgic charm that transports guests back to 1979, this regional chain exudes a timeless allure, earning its spotless reputation. Dishing up favorites like crispy fried chicken paired with zesty horseradish sauce and creamy mashed potatoes, Roy Rogers satisfies cravings with a touch of retro flair. Friendly staff add a welcoming touch to the experience, making every visit a delightful trip down memory lane. Uncover a taste of yesteryear at Roy Rogers, a gem that defies the passage of time in culinary style.

Rating:
Price:

10. Enzo’s Caffe Italia

Enzo’s Caffe Italia, the culinary gem of Island Heights, exudes warmth and authenticity through its traditional Italian fare served in a cozy dining setting. The heartfelt accolades from patrons paint a vivid picture of the exceptional service and delectable dishes awaiting visitors. From tender fried calamari to flavorful clams on the 1/2 shell, the appetizers set the stage for a memorable meal. The entrees, including chicken francese, veal marsala, and penne vodka with chicken, showcase the chef’s commitment to quality and taste. With a BYO policy adding a personal touch and attentive, friendly servers ensuring a seamless dining experience, Enzo’s proves to be a top contender for hosting celebrations and intimate dinners alike. So, for those seeking an authentic Italian dining experience filled with charm and flavor, Enzo’s Caffe Italia beckons as a must-visit destination in Island Heights.

Rating:
Price: