Best Restaurants in Rumson, New Jersey

Step into a world where history meets modern-day cool at Murphy’s Tavern in Rumson. Tucked away in a basement within a residential neighborhood, this hidden gem is a playground for those seeking a unique experience. With a speakeasy past, the bar exudes an old-school charm that’s hard to resist. Bartenders serve up a plethora of drink options while the menu boasts mouthwatering bites like the famous bar pie. Whether you’re there for bingo night or a casual evening, the fun atmosphere and friendly owner make each visit a memorable one. Discover the essence of a true neighborhood bar at Murphy’s Tavern – a must-visit hotspot for those in search of a low-key yet captivating dining adventure in Rumson.

Situated in Rumson, Anjelica’s Restaurant is a vibrant gem that beckons both locals and visitors with its classic Southern Italian fare and delectable seafood dishes. Stepping into this cozy BYOB eatery, you’re enveloped by an enchanting atmosphere buzzing with a lively vibe. The reviews sing praises of exceptional service and creative culinary delights, with standout dishes like the heavenly fresh pasta and divine meatballs. Patrons rave about the abundant salad options, particularly highlighting the flavorful beet salad. With both indoor and outdoor seating, Anjelica’s offers a prime location for a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, the consistent excellence in food, service, and ambiance makes this restaurant a must-visit destination in the realm of Italian cuisine. Experience the magic of Anjelica’s and indulge in a culinary journey that promises to delight your taste buds with every bite.

Located in Rumson, Moo Yai Thai Restaurant is a culinary jewel that has captured the hearts of both locals and travelers alike. With a menu that celebrates the vibrant flavors of Thailand, this eatery has been hailed as a standout in Monmouth County, drawing praise for its authenticity and warm hospitality. Customers rave about the papaya salad, a refreshing must-try, and the pad basil with pork that’s simply irresistible. The Moo Yai sampler is a crowd favorite, featuring an array of delightful treats like curry puffs, chicken satay, and dumplings bursting with flavor. From classics like Pad Thai to specialties like crispy duck and garlic shrimp, each dish is a culinary journey worth savoring. Whether you’re a Thai food aficionado or a newbie to the cuisine, Moo Yai Thai Restaurant promises a dining experience that will keep you coming back for more. Indulge in their coconut soup with chicken, pineapple fried rice, or the seafood fried rice, boasting generous portions of crab meat. For a sweet ending, the fried bananas and mango sticky rice are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Get ready to embark on a culinary adventure that will transport you straight to the streets of Thailand at Moo Yai Thai Restaurant in Rumson.

Situated in Rumson, Yumi Sea Bright is an Asian gem that promises a culinary journey like no other. Boasting a stylish space and a menu brimming with small and large plates, sushi delights, and lunch bento boxes, this BYOB restaurant has garnered a loyal following for all the right reasons. Diving into the raving reviews, it’s evident that Yumi Sea Bright is a haven for food enthusiasts seeking an extraordinary dining experience. Patrons rave about the impeccable flavors, warm staff, and the sheer talent exuding from the chefs. With dishes so good that even a non-sushi eater was won over and a menu filled with innovative creations, Yumi Sea Bright stands out as a must-visit destination for those craving a top-notch culinary adventure in Monmouth County. A blend of exceptional service, stunning waterfront views, and a vast, diverse menu sets the stage for a dining experience that’s nothing short of perfection. Cheers to Yumi Sea Bright for continually raising the bar and delighting taste buds with each visit!

Located in the vibrant town of Rumson, Val’s Tavern is more than just a restaurant; it’s an experience. Boasting a laid-back yet lively atmosphere, this enduring outpost is a haven for both families and late-night revelers. From specialty pizzas to classic Italian dishes, Val’s menu caters to all tastes, ensuring everyone leaves satisfied. Rave reviews highlight the exceptional service, with mentions of the attentive event planner, John, and the accommodating staff, like Courtney, who go above and beyond to make every visit memorable. Whether you’re savoring a beer salad with shrimp or diving into a mouth-watering burger, Val’s Tavern offers something for everyone, making it a must-visit destination in Rumson for delectable bar food and top-notch hospitality.

In the charming town of Rumson, Alice’s Kitchen is a culinary gem that has garnered a loyal following for its delectable breakfast and lunch offerings. With a warm and welcoming ambiance, guests are greeted by the delightful host, Alice, whose personal touch adds an extra layer of charm to the dining experience. The attentive and friendly service shines through in every interaction, making patrons feel right at home. Diners rave about the fresh and scrumptious dishes that arrive promptly, promising a delightful culinary journey with every visit. Whether you’re a longtime local or a newcomer to Rumson, Alice’s Kitchen is a must-visit destination that promises to leave a lasting impression on your taste buds.

Located in Rumson, Tommys Tavern + Tap is a vibrant hub for those seeking a culinary adventure. The industrial-chic ambiance sets the stage for a lively dining experience, where a vast menu awaits exploration. Reviewers rave about the diverse offerings, from sushi to pizza and everything in between. Standout dishes like the pulled pork sandwich and steak salad have left diners singing praises. The attentive staff, exemplified by Daniella and Anthony, elevate the experience with their warmth and expertise. Whether you’re savoring a pumpkin martini or indulging in the savory apple salad, a visit to Tommys is sure to leave you planning your next return to this gastronomic gem in Rumson.

Gigi’s Pizza in Sea Bright, Rumson, is more than just your average pizza joint—it’s a culinary gem that has locals and newcomers alike raving. From mouthwatering chicken piccata over linguine to inventive pizzas topped with everything bagel seasoning, this Italian eatery goes above and beyond in flavor and creativity. The welcoming staff adds a personal touch, ensuring each visit is not just a meal, but an experience to remember. Whether you’re craving a traditional slice or feeling adventurous with a General Tso’s Pizza, Gigi’s diverse menu guarantees a delightful culinary journey every time. As one reviewer aptly put it, “Do yourself a favor and visit this amazing pizzeria/restaurant” for an unforgettable dining experience by the beautiful beaches of Sea Bright. A must-visit spot that promises to satisfy all taste buds!

Situated in the vibrant town of Rumson, Victory Park Tavern is a culinary gem waiting to be discovered. Boasting a menu that caters to all tastes, this spot has been garnering rave reviews from patrons near and far. From the delectable mussels appetizer to the enticing lobster risotto and perfectly cooked flank steak, each dish is a testament to the chef’s culinary prowess. Guests love the cozy booths with trendy pillows adding a touch of comfort to their dining experience, and the option to customize their burgers adds a fun twist to the meal. And let’s not forget about the sweet endings – the bread pudding and chocolate brownie with vanilla ice cream are simply divine. Whether you’re a local looking for a new favorite spot or a visitor wanting a taste of Rumson’s finest, Victory Park Tavern promises a memorable dining experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Located in Rumson, Donovan’s Reef is a vibrant beachside gem that effortlessly combines a relaxed pub vibe with the allure of a seaside escape. Boasting an outdoor tiki bar, a charming patio, and a lineup of live bands, this spot is a surefire hit for those seeking a laid-back hangout with fantastic offerings. Dive into their pub menu, where each dish is crafted to perfection, echoing the sentiments of patrons who rave about the delicious food and drinks. With a location that allows you to sip on a drink while feeling the sand between your toes, Donovan’s Reef beckons you to unwind and indulge in the ultimate beach experience. Whether you’re drawn in by the DJ spinning hits for all generations or the welcoming staff, this spot promises an excellent time for all who visit. A must-try for those in search of a beachside sanctuary where good vibes and great flavors converge.