Best Restaurants in Montague, New Jersey

If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Montague, look no further than Candy’s Pizza. Nestled in the heart of the town, this gem is a true hidden culinary treasure. Their Sicilian pie is a masterpiece of cheese, sauce, and crispy crust that will have your taste buds dancing with delight. Despite its unassuming exterior, once you step inside, you’re greeted with a warm and spacious ambiance perfect for casual dining or family get-togethers. The owner’s hospitality shines through in every bite, making each visit feel like a homecoming. Don’t miss out on this local favorite that consistently delivers on flavor and quality. Candy’s Pizza is a must-visit for pizza aficionados in search of a slice of perfection in Sussex County.

Located in Montague, YiaYia’s Greek Kitchen is a culinary treasure waiting to be discovered in Sussex County. Boasting fresh, homemade Greek meals that have visitors returning time and time again, this hidden gem is a must-visit spot for food enthusiasts. From the irresistible chickpea fritters to the generously portioned Greek salad with chicken, every dish is bursting with flavor and made with the utmost care. The cozy atmosphere, complete with a charming fireplace, adds an extra touch of warmth to your dining experience. Run by a delightful husband and wife team, the magic that happens in YiaYia’s kitchen is evident in each bite, making it a destination worth seeking out for a truly memorable meal. Don’t miss the chance to indulge in authentic Greek cuisine that promises to exceed your expectations!

Get ready to tantalize your taste buds at Tequila Sunrise in Montague! This vibrant gem is a culinary delight that’s not to be missed. The friendly owner/chef sets the tone by personally curating an exceptional dining experience, highlighted by the best guacamole you’ll ever taste – a real game-changer. From the “Mexico City” combo platter showcasing a symphony of flavors to the flavorful and non-spicy seasonings that elevate every dish, this place is a definite must-stop for Mexican food enthusiasts and culinary adventurers alike. Don’t miss out on the savory chicken burrito brimming with peppers or the unforgettable Mole dish that’s been winning hearts one bite at a time. Whether you’re a local looking for a new favorite spot or a traveler seeking an authentic dining experience, Tequila Sunrise is the place to be. Embark on a flavor-packed journey and savor the magic of this hidden culinary treasure!

Situated in the charming town of Montague, La Posada & Felix Cantina is a true culinary treasure waiting to be discovered. Step inside this unassuming restaurant, and you’ll be transported to a cozy Mexican haven, as described by delighted diners. The warm and inviting ambiance sets the stage for an exceptional dining experience, where generous portions and top-notch service take center stage. From authentic Mexican flavors to delightful salsa nights on select Thursdays, every visit promises to be a flavorful adventure worth savoring. Don’t let its unassuming exterior fool you; La Posada & Felix Cantina is a must-visit destination for those seeking an unforgettable dining escapade in Montague.

Located in the charming town of Montague, the Blue Heron Bar and Grill offers not only a feast for the senses with its awesome views but also a culinary experience that won’t break the bank. Diners rave about the Blue Heron chicken sandwich with its unique seasoned mayo sauce that even mayo haters can’t resist. The patio is a hotspot for those seeking both great food and beautiful scenery, with attentive staff like Linda Jean ensuring a pleasant dining experience. Whether you’re savoring the lake view or enjoying the poolside ambiance, Blue Heron Bar and Grill promises a delightful retreat for both locals and visitors alike.

In the heart of Montague, J & J Pizzeria Inc is a gem for pizza aficionados looking for a delightful culinary experience. Recent reviews highlight the improved food quality over the years, making it a standout choice among the array of pizza places in the area. Customers rave about the thin and crispy pizza, coupled with a flavorful sauce that sets this eatery apart. The cozy and clean setting adds to the charm, making it a go-to spot for those craving a satisfying slice or a delectable pasta dish. With a welcoming staff and affordable prices, J & J Pizzeria Inc is a must-visit for those seeking an authentic and delicious pizzeria experience in Montague.