Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Allendale, New Jersey

Exploring the vibrant culinary landscape of Allendale, New Jersey reveals a delightful array of dining options that cater to every palate. This lovely town boasts a charming mix of eateries, from cozy cafes and family-owned bistros to upscale dining establishments that showcase culinary artistry. Nestled in the heart of Bergen County, this quaint town is a delightful destination for food enthusiasts, offering a medley of flavors that celebrate both tradition and innovation. Beyond its culinary delights, Allendale also beckons visitors with its picturesque parks, historic landmarks, and vibrant community spirit, making it a must-visit for those seeking a taste of small-town charm in the Garden State.

1. L’Arte della Pasticceria

Located in Allendale, L’Arte della Pasticceria is a hidden culinary treasure that’s a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Italian coffee, pastries, and gelato. With a wide selection of delectable treats, this pastry cafe shop has garnered rave reviews for its friendly and attentive staff who make every visit a delightful experience. From mouthwatering gelatos to heavenly pastries and cookies, each bite is a flavorful journey to Italy. Chef Andrea’s cooking classes have also been praised for their innovative dishes and approachable instruction, making L’Arte della Pasticceria not just a cafe, but a culinary hub where even novice cooks can hone their skills and elevate their gastronomic prowess. So, whether you’re starting your day with a coffee and a light breakfast or indulging in the best Italian pastries around, this charming spot promises a delightful experience with every visit.

Rating:
Price:

2. Saddle River Inn

In the charming town of Allendale, the Saddle River Inn offers a truly exceptional dining experience that will leave you enamored. Set inside a beautifully restored barn, this romantic BYOB restaurant serves upscale French-American cuisine that will tantalize your taste buds. Revel in the cozy cabin atmosphere, accented by delightful Christmas decor, as you embark on a culinary journey crafted by Chef Jamie. From the perfectly cooked 20oz sirloin to the tender and flavorful Kurobuta Pork chops, each dish is a masterpiece. Don’t miss the burrata appetizer and the indulgent smores sundae, both recommended by patrons for a reason. With impeccable service from staff like Matt and TY, your evening at Saddle River Inn promises to be an unforgettable celebration of exquisite flavors and warm hospitality. For a truly memorable dining affair in Allendale, make your way to this culinary gem that promises nothing short of culinary excellence and a cozy ambiance by the fireplace.

Rating:
Price:

3. Savini Restaurant

Savini Restaurant in Allendale is a culinary gem that beckons both locals and travelers seeking an exquisite Italian dining experience. Boasting a diverse menu brimming with traditional delights, this establishment has garnered a stellar reputation for its exceptional cuisine and top-notch service. Rave reviews sing praises of the accommodating staff, the mouthwatering dishes like the honeycrisp apple + arugula salad, gnocchi, and Chilean seabass, and the delightful dessert options, notably the canoli cream & berry creation. Whether you’re planning a romantic date night or a small company gathering, Savini’s lively bar scene and extensive wine list promise an unforgettable experience. Don’t just take my word for it, let your taste buds embark on a culinary journey at Savini Restaurant for an evening that blends sophistication with savory delights.

Rating:
Price:

4. CAVA

Located in Allendale, CAVA is a Mediterranean gem that takes the concept of customizable bowls and salads to a whole new level. With a menu boasting fresh ingredients and generous portion sizes, it’s no surprise that this spot has amassed a loyal following. Customers rave about the lemon chicken and harissa chicken options, praising the friendly staff who go above and beyond to provide a top-notch experience. Cleanliness is clearly a priority here, with mentions of a spotless environment and quick service. One standout mention even details a hilarious mishap turned memorable experience, showcasing the staff’s quick thinking and exceptional customer service. CAVA in Allendale is a must-visit for those craving delicious Mediterranean fare in a welcoming atmosphere.

Rating:
Price:

5. Ramsey Golf & Country Club

Situated in Allendale, the Ramsey Golf & Country Club is not just a venue – it’s an experience that leaves a lasting impression on all who step foot inside. Radiating expertise and genuine passion, the team led by Michael ensures that every moment, from weddings to awards ceremonies, is flawlessly executed. The stunning landscapes and elegant interiors provide the perfect backdrop for any occasion. With a seamless fusion of nature and celebration, impeccable service, and delicious cuisine that guests can’t stop raving about, Ramsey G&CC sets the bar high. Whether you’re saying “I do” or celebrating an achievement, this venue is where unforgettable memories are crafted with precision and care. Elevate your event experience at Ramsey Golf & Country Club and let Michael and his exceptional team work their magic!

Rating:
Price:

6. Varka Restaurant

Situated in Allendale, Varka Restaurant is a buzzing Greek seafood gem that has tongues wagging for all the right reasons. With a fresh fish display and upscale ambiance, this place clearly knows how to make a lasting impression. Diners rave about the Lobster Gyros, Octopus, Lamb Chops, and the exquisite Organic Salmon and Tuna Aegean. The menu is a symphony of flavors, from the mouthwatering appetizers like baked clams and oysters to the show-stopping fish dishes that are hailed as true masterpieces. The attentive service and cozy atmosphere make it ideal for a family gathering or a romantic dinner. Don’t forget to make a reservation; this hot spot fills up fast with food this good!

Rating:
Price:

7. Mezza Luna Bistro

Located in Allendale, Mezza Luna Bistro is a hidden gem for Italian cuisine enthusiasts. With a lineup featuring homemade pasta dinners, succulent chicken, veal, and fresh fish dishes, this traditional eatery has garnered rave reviews for its impeccable service and delectable food. Patrons can’t help but gush over the personalized attention received, making it a go-to spot for special occasions like baby showers and family gatherings. The garlic bread appetizer and decadent chocolate cake are hailed as must-tries, while regulars swear by the Chicken Marsala and Chicken Francese. The BYOB policy adds a charming touch, allowing diners to elevate their dining experience with their favorite wine selections. Whether you’re a local or willing to travel for a standout meal, Mezza Luna Bistro promises a flavorful journey that will keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

8. Gao Thai Kitchen

Located in Allendale, Gao Thai Kitchen is a vibrant bistro that has caught the attention of both locals and newcomers. Renowned for its traditional curry, rice, and noodle dishes, this cozy spot has garnered high praises for its gluten-free options. Diners rave about the flavorful sampler appetizer, featuring a tantalizing mix of spring rolls, curry puffs, chicken satay, and spare ribs, paired with delectable side sauces. The menu’s standouts include the fiery chicken ka prow and the savory chicken with Thai broccoli and noodles, both generously portioned and bursting with authentic flavors. Don’t miss out on their decadent desserts, like the chocolate peanut butter sundae and the homemade chocolate lava cake. Gao Thai Kitchen is a must-visit for a delightful culinary journey that will keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

9. Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

In the vibrant town of Allendale, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings emerges as a true gem in the world of casual dining. With a knack for satisfying all sorts of cravings, this modern eatery serves up charred-crust pies, mouthwatering wings, savory subs, and delightful Italian plates that keep patrons coming back for more. The rave reviews speak volumes about the exceptional service – from accommodating a busload of Varsity football players with ease to warmly welcoming furry friends at the outdoor seating area, complete with a thoughtful water bowl for four-legged companions. With a menu that boasts a delectable 10-inch traditional pizza topped with Prosciutto and a standout Italian plum sauce that’s nothing short of heavenly, each visit to Anthony’s promises a culinary adventure worth savoring. So, whether you’re looking to indulge in a slice of pizza perfection or sample their tantalizing wings, this restaurant is a must-visit hotspot that truly captures the essence of Allendale’s vibrant food scene.

Rating:
Price:

10. Brady’s At The Station

Located in Allendale, Brady’s At The Station is a vibrant 2-story pub exuding vintage charm and serving up a delightful fusion of hearty American and Irish fare. As you step inside this former Erie RR freight house, you’re enveloped in a nostalgic ambiance that sets the stage for an exceptional dining experience. Regulars rave about the prime rib night, showcasing the chef’s prowess, with standout dishes like the flavorful French onion soup and the tantalizing bang bang shrimp stealing the show. The attentive and friendly staff, including Marc and Steve, add a personal touch, making you feel right at home. Whether you choose to bask in the outdoor seating on the ground floor or soak in the sights from the upper deck, Brady’s At The Station promises a feast for the senses that keeps patrons coming back for more. A true gem in Allendale’s culinary scene, this eatery is a must-visit for those seeking a memorable meal in a welcoming setting.

Rating:
Price: