Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Belmar, New Jersey

Set along the picturesque Jersey Shore, Belmar, New Jersey boasts a vibrant culinary scene that will delight even the most discerning food enthusiasts. This lovely town is a haven for seafood lovers, with its proximity to the Atlantic Ocean ensuring the freshest catches make their way to the plates of diners. From cozy bistros to trendy cafes, Belmar is a treasure trove of gastronomic delights waiting to be explored. Beyond its culinary offerings, visitors can also soak up the sun on Belmar’s beautiful beaches, stroll along the bustling boardwalk, or enjoy a day of fishing or boating. Get ready to discover the Best Restaurants in Belmar, where a blend of coastal charm and culinary excellence awaits.

1. Oliva

Oliva in Bethlehem is a Mediterranean gem that has stolen the hearts of locals and visitors alike with its exquisite offerings. From the fresh fig salad to the perfectly cooked sea scallops and the decadent pistachio gelato, each dish is a work of art crafted with love and care. The ambiance exudes a sense of calm sophistication, with white tablecloths setting the stage for a memorable dining experience. Noteworthy mentions go to the mouthwatering caramelized onion pizza, the flavorsome eggplant, and the succulent roasted chicken. With a modest yet impressive wine selection and top-notch service, Oliva is a must-visit spot for those seeking a culinary adventure in Litchfield County. Make sure to book a reservation and indulge in a night of upscale dining that promises to leave you craving more.

Rating:
Price:

2. St. Stephen’s Green Publick House

Located in Belmar, St. Stephen’s Green Publick House is not your average pub experience. With a lively atmosphere and top-notch Irish pub fare, this spot stands out among the crowd of Jersey Shore destinations. Rave reviews highlight their mouthwatering shepherd’s pie, a harmonious blend of beef and lamb smothered in savory gravy atop a bed of creamy mashed potatoes. Pair this with a perfectly poured pint of Guinness or explore their impressive selection of bourbons and ryes. The Celtic burger comes highly recommended, touted as the best burger along the shore. Live entertainment featuring artists like Steve Reilly adds to the vibrant ambiance, making each visit a memorable experience. Dive into the warmth and authenticity of St. Stephen’s Green for a true taste of Ireland on the East Coast.

Rating:
Price:

3. Meemom’s Wall

Located in Belmar, Meemom’s Wall is a vibrant hub for breakfast enthusiasts seeking a delightful culinary experience. As you step into this contemporary daytime gem with a stylish coffee bar, prepare to embark on a journey of delectable creations. Indulge in the hangover bowl for a hearty start or savor the dark knight French toast for a decadent treat. Pair your meal with a Gingerbread Chai latte or explore the menu’s impressive array of specialty coffees. With a reputation for accommodating even large parties with ease, Meemom’s Wall beckons you to revel in its friendly service and creative dishes. Whether you crave the sweetness of banana bread French toast or the savory allure of pork roll hash, this spot promises a breakfast adventure worth savoring time and time again.

Rating:
Price:

4. Nick’s Country Kitchen

In the heart of Bethlehem, Nick’s Country Kitchen stands out as a gem for all-day breakfast lovers and seekers of American comfort cuisine. Patrons rave about the best fish-n-chips in town and the delightful coleslaw that accompanies it, creating a harmonious symphony of flavors. From the friendly service, as highlighted by Linda, to the generous portions and burst of flavors in every dish, Nick’s is a clear winner. This cozy eatery offers a casual dining experience where the menu is filled with classics like cheeseburger deluxe and pastrami melt, alongside tantalizing blackboard specials. The steak fries steal the show with their golden crunch, while the juicy burgers and tender pastrami melts keep diners coming back for more. With prices that won’t break the bank and a welcoming atmosphere exuding small-town charm, Nick’s is a must-visit spot for a satisfying meal experience in Bethlehem.

Rating:
Price:

5. Mr Shrimp

Welcome to the oceanic oasis of Mr Shrimp in Belmar, where seafood sensations await to tantalize your taste buds. As a renowned seafood market and restaurant, the culinary voyage begins with their famous fish ‘n’ chips, a crispy delight that leaves a lasting impression. Dive deeper into their menu and discover a treasure trove of sandwiches and full meals that showcase the freshest catch of the day. Don’t be deterred by the buzz – whether you secure a reservation or cozy up at the bar, the seafood symphony at Mr Shrimp is an experience not to be missed. Join the ranks of satisfied diners who found themselves spellbound by the flavors, and make Mr Shrimp your go-to destination for a seafood escapade in Belmar.

Rating:
Price:

6. Playa Bowls

Situated in the vibrant town of Belmar, Playa Bowls emerges as a shining star among the dining scene, drawing raving reviews from locals and visitors alike. With a perfect fusion of flavor and beachy vibes, this place seems to effortlessly capture hearts – and taste buds. Boasting a menu as colorful as a beach sunset, their Goldie Mango bowl, Pink Flamingo Pitaya bowl, and Mango Pina Colada Smoothie stand out as crowd favorites, making each visit a tantalizing experience. Patrons shower praise on the friendly staff who sprinkle extra dashes of hospitality, going above and beyond to ensure each customer leaves with a smile. As one reviewer eloquently put it, a visit to Playa Bowls has swiftly turned into a tradition, promising a flavorful journey every time, with a side of ocean views and good vibes. So, if you’re seeking a taste of paradise in Belmar, look no further than this seaside gem that promises not just a meal, but a culinary getaway.

Rating:
Price:

7. Joe’s Surf Shack

In the vibrant town of Belmar, Joe’s Surf Shack is a must-visit gem for those craving a beachy vibe and delectable bites. Situated on a cozy residential street, this cool bar exudes a welcoming atmosphere with its cute beach-themed décor. The food here is nothing short of fantastic, as highlighted by the ginormous portions that left one reviewer and her boyfriend happily stuffed with leftovers to spare. With raving mentions of perfectly cooked wraps and attentive staff, Joe’s Surf Shack promises a memorable dining experience. It’s no wonder this local favorite gets packed, especially on summer weekends, offering a perfect blend of great food, cheap drinks, and amazing service. Whether you’re grabbing a bite or sipping on cocktails, Joe’s Surf Shack is your go-to spot for a good time in Belmar.

Rating:
Price:

8. Painted Pony Restaurant

Located in Bethlehem, the Painted Pony Restaurant is a culinary gem that promises an unforgettable dining experience. Boasting an array of delectable dishes, from pasta to surf ‘n’ turf options, this cozy spot exudes a casual charm that invites guests to unwind and indulge. Rave reviews highlight the exceptional service that goes above and beyond, setting the stage for an evening of pure enjoyment. With a menu that shines with flavorful delights like the chicken parm and perfectly cooked prime rib, it’s no wonder patrons keep coming back for more. The lively atmosphere, complemented by themed events like trivia nights and live bands, adds a layer of excitement to an already outstanding dining venture. For those seeking a place where great food and fantastic service converge, look no further than the Painted Pony Restaurant – a true culinary delight in the heart of Bethlehem.

Rating:
Price:

9. La Dolce Vita

La Dolce Vita in Belmar is a gem that embodies the epitome of seaside dining perfection. With a menu brimming with generous portions of delectable Italian and seafood delights, this oceanfront establishment promises an unforgettable culinary experience. Guests rave about the avocado burrata, pairing it with a glass of Inscription Pinot Noir to kick off a meal filled with tough decisions between pasta, seafood, and steak. The attentive servers, like the commendable Bill G., elevate the dining ambiance with their expert recommendations and warm hospitality. Don’t miss out on the tantalizing Branzino or the rich Rigatoni Bolognese, and be sure to indulge in their heavenly homemade desserts – especially the divine carrot cake. La Dolce Vita is a beacon of excellence in Belmar, where every bite is a celebration of flavors and every visit a feast for the senses.

Rating:
Price: