Best Restaurants in Chesilhurst, New Jersey

Located in Chesilhurst, Graziano’s Ristoranti is an old-school Italian gem that has patrons singing praises reminiscent of the Sinatra era. With dishes like Waldorf salad with chicken cutlet and Lobster & Shrimp Tetrizzini, this restaurant promises a culinary journey that transports diners to the heart of Italy. The ambiance, adorned with iconic photos and Sinatra’s classic tunes, sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. Guests rave about the efficient and friendly service, with standout mentions of staff members like Morgan. Graziano’s Ristoranti is a hidden culinary treasure waiting to be discovered by food enthusiasts seeking an authentic taste of Italy.

Tucked in the charming town of Chesilhurst, D & S Sub Shop is a hidden gem worth discovering. With rave reviews from locals and visitors alike, this eatery promises a flavorful escape for your taste buds. Indulge in their signature cheesesteak, hailed as a standout item that boasts a generous portion of meat, perfectly balanced flavors, and a lack of messiness—ideal for a satisfying, hassle-free meal. The Italian sub is also a crowd-pleaser, known for its ability to hold its form even as you savor each bite. While the pizza may taste even better the next day, the initial satisfaction is undeniable, with a loyal following attesting to its excellence. Step into this time portal to the 20th century, where Darryl crafts his legendary cheesesteaks with unwavering consistency and charm. Immerse yourself in the nostalgic ambiance and relish in the warm hospitality that keeps patrons coming back for more. If you’re in search of a quick and delicious dining experience, D & S Sub Shop is the go-to spot that guarantees not to disappoint.

Situated in the charming town of Chesilhurst, Zito’s Tavern is a hidden gem worth uncovering for any food enthusiast. With a menu that boasts generous portions and delectable dishes, this quaint establishment has garnered a loyal following. Guests rave about the impeccable service and the inviting atmosphere of this local spot. From savory entrees to mouthwatering desserts, Zito’s Tavern promises a culinary experience that will have you coming back for more. Discover the magic of this culinary haven and indulge in a dining adventure that promises to exceed expectations.

Located in Chesilhurst, Briglia’s Tavern is a hidden gem that boasts a cozy and intimate setting. Renowned for its diverse seafood offerings, this spot is a seafood aficionado’s dream with Buck A Shuck oysters hailing from different regions. The menu doesn’t stop there; from mouthwatering meatballs and marinara over penne to a delightful vanilla bean creme brulee, the flavors here are thoughtfully crafted and rich. Diners rave about the chef’s impeccable sauces, elevating seemingly simple dishes like mussels in red sauce to extraordinary levels. Despite its unassuming size, Briglia’s Tavern surprises with its warm ambiance, live music, and generous portions that leave guests planning their next visit. Whether you’re a fan of ribeye steak or crave a bowl of crab soup, this eatery guarantees a memorable culinary experience that celebrates the essence of family-owned restaurants. Unveil the culinary treasures of Chesilhurst at Briglia’s Tavern!

Francesco’s Cucina Italiana in Chesilhurst is a gem worth discovering for those craving authentic Italian cuisine. Renowned for its delectable meat, seafood, and pasta dishes, this unassuming eatery has garnered a loyal following. Guests rave about the cream of broccoli soup, clams casino, Chicken Picante over homemade spaghetti, and the zuppe di pesce in fra diablo sauce. The handwritten special menu offers a delightful surprise every visit, while the welcoming service from folks like Melissa and Donna adds a charming touch to the dining experience. With a cozy bar area and a menu that never disappoints, Francesco’s is a must-visit for anyone seeking a taste of Italy in Chesilhurst.

Located in Chesilhurst, Grilly Cheese is not your average food truck experience – it’s a flavor-packed adventure waiting to happen! Specializing in the art of grilled cheese, this spot has stolen the hearts of many with its unique creations that cater to every craving, including delightful gluten-free and vegan options. Rumor has it that their fries are so good, they should come with a warning label for being addictively crispy and perfectly salted. Whether it’s a wedding reception or a corporate event, Grilly Cheese brings the party with their lively team and mouthwatering menu that leaves guests raving. Trust me, this food truck is not just a meal; it’s an experience that will have you coming back for more!

Located in Chesilhurst, Elis’s Pizzeria & Family Restaurant is a hidden gem that has garnered rave reviews for its mouthwatering dishes and top-notch service. Patrons can’t get enough of the thin-crust pizzas that are said to be a standout feature. The pork sandwich and crispy fries have also left diners raving about the delicious flavors and quick preparation. It’s not just the food that shines here, but also the warm and friendly service that adds to the overall dining experience. With a large menu to choose from, Elis’s caters to a variety of tastes and occasions, even going above and beyond by delivering food for special events like wakes. This restaurant is definitely a must-try for those looking for a delightful culinary experience in Chesilhurst.

Located in Chesilhurst, Sum Place Else is a hidden gem that promises an extraordinary dining experience. Boasting an expansive menu that goes beyond the ordinary, this restaurant offers a culinary adventure like no other. The vibrant Bohemian ambiance of the outside bar and deck, reminiscent of a Key West vibe, sets the stage for unforgettable evenings filled with live music and delightful conversations. With a newly renovated interior bar that exudes sophistication and charm, Sum Place Else is the perfect destination for both warm summer nights and cozy winter evenings. Whether you’re a regular seeking a familiar escape or a first-time visitor ready to be enchanted, this establishment promises a unique and memorable dining experience that will keep you coming back for more. Indulge in the diverse menu, sip on expertly crafted drinks, and immerse yourself in the lively atmosphere that has captivated patrons time and time again. Sum Place Else is not just a restaurant; it’s an experience that beckons you to discover the magic within its walls.

Located in Chesilhurst, Bella Luna Pizza is a vibrant culinary gem that offers a delightful array of pizzas. With options like traditional cheese, mouthwatering cheesesteak, and the tantalizing white pizza, Bella Luna Pizza is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts. One enthusiastic reviewer even mentioned the excitement of pairing delicious slices with a car show experience nearby. Embrace the inviting atmosphere and savor the flavors of Bella Luna Pizza for a truly satisfying dining adventure in Chesilhurst.

Located in Chesilhurst, Wawa is a go-to spot for foodies looking for a satisfying meal that won’t break the bank. This convenience store chain’s sandwiches are a standout, with patrons raving about the delicious subs on offer. The breakfast options are described as otherworldly, making it a must-visit for early risers or brunch enthusiasts. With a reputation for cleanliness and quality, Wawa is a hidden gem for those seeking a quick, tasty bite in town.