Best Restaurants in Pike, Indiana

Located in Pike, ELI’S CUISINE is a gem not to be missed when exploring the culinary scene in Indiana. The reviews speak for themselves – from the mouthwatering fish dishes that are said to be the best in the state to the flavorful jollof rice, fried plantains, and spicy goat that keep patrons coming back for more. The owner’s warmth and hospitality shine through, creating a welcoming atmosphere where every meal feels like a special occasion. With top-quality food and exemplary customer service, it’s no wonder guests find themselves returning time and time again. ELI’S CUISINE is truly a must-visit spot for those in search of delectable dishes and a memorable dining experience in Pike.

Located in the charming town of Pike, Manhattan Pizzeria is a slice of New York right in Indianapolis, serving up authentic and mouthwatering NY-style pizza that will transport you straight to the bustling streets of the Big Apple. With a crispy crust that perfectly balances chewiness and crunch, each slice is a flavor-packed delight topped with the right amount of sauce, cheese, and fresh toppings. Don’t miss out on their signature Cheese, Pepperoni, Buffalo Chicken, Margherita, White, and Meat Lover Rollover Pizzas, each a delicious tribute to the classic flavors of New York. The Garlic Breadsticks and Pepperoni Roll are also must-tries, accompanied by addictive garlicky dipping sauces that will have you coming back for more. Whether you’re a native New Yorker searching for a taste of home or a pizza aficionado looking for your next favorite spot, Manhattan Pizzeria is a savory gem that promises a delectable culinary journey through the heart of NYC.

Georgetown Natural Foods Market in Pike is a hidden gem for foodies and health enthusiasts alike. Boasting a locally owned charm, this market strikes the perfect balance between supplements and groceries, catering to every dietary need. Standout favorites include their elusive gluten-free blueberry muffins and top-notch fresh fruit smoothies that keep patrons coming back for more. With a reputation for sourcing rare items and offering a diverse selection of herbal supplements, Georgetown Market outshines its competitors, making it a must-visit destination for those seeking quality and variety in their culinary and wellness journey.

Located in the vibrant town of Pike, bbi Cafe & Sandwich Shop is a true hidden culinary oasis waiting to be discovered. Boasting a stellar 4.6 overall rating, this gem has been showered with praise for its impeccable catering services that make every event feel extraordinary. Customers rave about the warm and welcoming staff whose friendliness goes above and beyond, creating a dining experience that feels like a warm hug. The menu features delectable options like the must-try Ahi Tuna and Broccoli Salad, along with beautifully plated and fresh falafel appetizers that keep patrons coming back for more. With a charming interior and a family-like ambiance, bbi Cafe & Sandwich Shop is the perfect spot to enjoy delicious food while feeling right at home. If you’re searching for a cozy, friendly spot to indulge in delightful culinary creations, bbi Cafe & Sandwich Shop in Pike is a definite must-visit that promises to leave a lasting impression on your taste buds.

If you find yourself in Pike and craving a delightful Chinese dining experience, look no further than Imperial Palace. Renowned for its generous portions and flavorful dishes, this gem has been hailed as a top-notch Chinese spot in the area. From the massive Crab Rangoons that are a must-try to the aromatic Garlic Chicken that packs a punch, each dish at Imperial Palace is crafted with precision and care. The cozy atmosphere, adorned with bamboo plants, sets the stage for a memorable meal, while the friendly staff ensures a pleasant dining experience. Whether you’re a fan of classic favorites like egg rolls and pork fried rice or eager to explore the fusion creations, Imperial Palace promises a delectable journey for your taste buds. So, if you’re searching for the best fusion of American and Chinese cuisine in Pike, make sure to add Imperial Palace to your list of must-visit eateries!

Located in Pike, El Corcel Mexican Restaurant #2 is a true gem that promises a delightful dining experience. Boasting a menu that goes beyond the ordinary Tex-Mex fare, this spot offers authentic Mexican dishes that will transport your taste buds south of the border. From the stuffed shrimp burrito with a kick of spice to the tender steak burrito paired perfectly with salad and rice, every bite is a flavor explosion. Their attention to detail, like making guacamole fresh to order, is commendable, ensuring each dish bursts with freshness and authenticity. Whether you opt for the seafood options or go for classic favorites like enchiladas, each dish is a culinary journey worth savoring. With attentive service, a vibrant atmosphere, and a menu that keeps you coming back for more, El Corcel Mexican Restaurant #2 is a must-visit for those craving a taste of Mexico in Pike.

Located in Pike, Culver’s is a haven for burger aficionados and frozen custard connoisseurs alike. Boasting the signature Midwest touch in every bite, this fast-food gem has gained a loyal following for its mouthwatering offerings. Reviewers rave about the speedy service, ensuring you can savor your scrumptious meal in no time. The staff’s friendliness adds an extra layer of warmth to the dining experience, making each visit memorable. Don’t miss out on their delectable Atlantic cod, a dish that is not only flavorful but also keeps you on your toes with a surprising twist. With ample free parking and an easily accessible location, Culver’s in Pike stands out as a must-visit for those craving a blend of comfort and quality in their dining adventures.

Located in Pike, the Boathouse Grill is a true gem that shouldn’t be underestimated. Boasting a humble exterior, this spot offers ample parking, making it a stress-free dining destination. The reviews echo the outstanding service provided by the knowledgeable staff, with Cindy standing out for her efficiency and spot-on recommendations. While the menu covers a variety of dishes like clam strips, clam chowder, and fish submarine, it’s the Club sandwich that steals the show – meticulously grilled to perfection for a warm, hearty bite. The cozy ambiance and friendly vibe make it a go-to spot for locals, offering not just great food, but a welcoming atmosphere perfect for catching a game or enjoying a relaxing meal. With rave reviews for its thin-crust pizzas, flavorful fish and chips, and heavenly ranch sauce, Boathouse Grill is a must-visit for those seeking a memorable dining experience in Pike.

In the vibrant town of Pike, Kulture Bar & Bistro stands out as a gem for food enthusiasts seeking a delightful experience. Patrons praise the hot and fresh offerings, with generous portions and impeccable seasoning stealing the show. The deep fried catfish emerges as a clear favorite, alongside the tantalizing bbq sauce that elevates the wings to another level. Amidst the perfect lunch ambiance with toe-tapping music, guests savor crunchy wings and delectable catfish paired with cheesy grits. The diverse menu shines through with blackened salmon, shrimp, oxtails, gator bites, wings, and lamb chops all receiving high acclaim, promising a culinary journey that’s as diverse as it is delicious at Kulture Bar & Bistro.

Located in Pike, the Puerto Vallarta Restaurant is a vibrant eatery that promises a delightful Mexican dining experience. Boasting a laid-back atmosphere and colorful decor, this cafeteria-style gem serves up classic Mexican fare and daily specials that have garnered rave reviews. With friendly and knowledgeable staff who ensure a clean and welcoming environment, this spot is perfect for lunch, brunch, or dinner. From mouthwatering grilled chicken with rice, beans, and plantains to generous portion sizes and fast service, Puerto Vallarta Restaurant in Pike is a must-visit for those craving authentic Mexican flavors in the Indianapolis area. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this culinary hotspot is sure to leave you wanting more.