Best Restaurants in Portage, Indiana

Located in Portage, Macri’s Italian Bakery is a true gem that promises an unforgettable culinary experience. With a legacy of crafting authentic Italian desserts and deli fare, this family-run establishment has left a lasting impression on locals and visitors alike. The buzz around their seasonal Pączki is not to be ignored, drawing crowds from far and wide for a taste of their limited-time treats. From the heavenly cannolis to the delectable almond cake, every bite at Macri’s is a delightful journey into the heart of Italian pastry perfection. The rave reviews speak for themselves, celebrating not only the exceptional baked goods but also the warm and welcoming service that sets this bakery apart. If you find yourself in Portage, a visit to Macri’s is a must to indulge in their delectable offerings and savor a slice of bakery heaven.

In the charming town of Portage sits Fiddler’s Hearth, a gem that embodies the essence of a classic pub intertwined with a splash of old-world charm. Patrons rave about the authentic dishes that teleport tastebuds to another level. Indulge in the must-try Scotch eggs, traditional fish and chips, and the mouthwatering bangers and mash that leave diners yearning for more. This lively joint not only offers a wide array of premium scotches and proper pints but also serves up live music, adding an extra layer of ambiance to an already vibrant setting. From the outstanding service highlighted by the lovely Vanessa to the top-notch quality ingredients, Fiddler’s Hearth is more than just a restaurant, it’s an experience worth savoring in Portage.

Situated in Portage, Carmela’s Restaurant is a hidden gem that promises a taste of Italy right in the heart of the city. With a charming Tuscan decor and big windows allowing natural light to flood in, this eatery offers a perfect blend of intimacy and elegance. The rave reviews speak volumes about the impeccable service and warm hospitality that guests receive, making it an ideal spot for a romantic date night or a cozy dinner with friends. Dishes like the pasta with shrimp, spinach, mushrooms, and tomatoes are highlighted as absolute must-tries, along with the decadent stuffed mushrooms and delightful Italian desserts. The ambiance, described as cozy and European, sets the stage for a memorable dining experience where every bite is a journey to the heart of Italy. Carmela’s Restaurant is a culinary haven where fine dining meets comfort, leaving patrons like Samantha and other satisfied diners already planning their next visit. Get ready to indulge in authentic flavors and create unforgettable moments at this Portage treasure.

Rocco’s Restaurant in Portage is a culinary gem that has been enchanting taste buds since 1951. This cozy establishment, filled with nostalgic memorabilia, is a haven for Italian cuisine enthusiasts. From authentic pasta imported from Italy to mouthwatering pizza and subs, each dish is a symphony of flavors that transport you to the streets of Italy. The cheese toast is a must-try, setting the perfect tone for a delightful meal ahead. Amid the bustling energy of the restaurant, the attentive servers ensure that every detail is taken care of, from timely refills to checking on your dining experience. Rocco’s commitment to quality shines through in every bite, making it a top contender in the search for the best restaurants in Portage. A visit to Rocco’s is not just a meal; it’s a journey through culinary excellence that leaves a lasting impression.

Located in the vibrant town of Portage, Cafe Navarre offers a culinary journey like no other in the area. With global fare and an extensive selection of fine wines, this upscale restaurant is a gem for food enthusiasts seeking a memorable dining experience. Guests rave about the impeccable service, with mentions of attentive staff members like Cesar, Prince, and John who truly elevate the meal. The menu is a masterpiece of flavor combinations, from the delectable chocolate fondant to the perfectly prepared octopus, tartare, and lamb dishes. Whether you’re planning a romantic date night or a group gathering, Cafe Navarre promises an unforgettable dining experience that will leave you planning your next visit before you’ve even left the table. Elevate your dining adventures in Portage and make Cafe Navarre your next culinary destination.

Located in Portage, the Crooked Ewe Brewery & Ale House is a culinary gem that promises a memorable dining experience. The menu boasts a tantalizing array of dishes that cater to all tastes, including the must-try vegan mushroom melt that has been described as the best sandwich in town. The smoked wings and lemongrass chicken sandwich are standout options that have left patrons raving. Pair your meal with a craft beer flight featuring unique brews like Peggy Lee and the Amber Ale called What’s My Name? The family-friendly trendy vibe and top-notch customer service add to the overall charm of this hotspot, making it a definite must-visit for foodies and craft beer enthusiasts alike. So, if you find yourself in Portage, do yourself a favor and indulge in the delightful offerings at Crooked Ewe Brewery & Ale House – your taste buds will thank you!

In the heart of Portage lies The Lauber, a casual dining spot with a flair for serving up finger-licking goodies that keep patrons coming back for more. The buzz around their brunch is well-deserved, with a mix of traditional staples and a touch of contemporary charm that comes through in dishes like the “Lauber Favorite” – a tantalizing chicken and biscuits combo that hits all the right notes of comfort and flavor. The menu’s whimsical variety, along with the seamless service from staff like Joseph, adds to the overall appeal, making each visit a delightful culinary escapade. Whether you’re savoring the Mac with Pulled Pork under a cozy, covered patio or diving into a plate of Rigatoni Chicken in the inviting indoor setting, The Lauber promises a satisfying experience that charms both the taste buds and the soul. Don’t miss their specialty cocktails or the decadent brown sugar apple dessert – a sweet finale that’ll have you planning your next return before you’ve even left the table. For a memorable dining adventure in Portage, The Lauber is a must-visit gem that promises a feast for all the senses.

Situated in the vibrant town of Portage, LaSalle Grill is a gem that promises an exquisite dining experience. This upscale bistro boasts a menu brimming with tantalizing New American dishes, with a highlight on their wood-fired steaks that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. As per enthusiastic reviews, the service is nothing short of exceptional, with personalized touches such as bespoke menus and heartfelt gestures. The ambiance of the upstairs area seems to be a hit, offering live music to complement your dining experience. And let’s not forget the delectable Cream brulee that has patrons raving! LaSalle Grill is undeniably a must-visit destination for those seeking a perfect blend of top-notch cuisine and warm hospitality in Portage.

Portage’s culinary scene just got a whole lot tastier with South Bend Brew Werks. This gem on the outskirts of downtown has been creating quite a buzz among locals and visitors alike. From their flavorful salads to mouthwatering flatbreads, and let’s not forget about those pretzels and soups that leave you craving more, this spot has something for everyone. The brews, ranging from classic styles to a palate-pleasing 100 IBU IPA, are a testament to their craft. And with events, trivia nights, and a dog-friendly patio, South Bend Brew Werks is not just a place to eat; it’s an experience waiting to be savored. And now with the option for to-go crowlers, the goodness doesn’t have to end when you leave. If you’re searching for a casual spot to unwind with friends and family, South Bend Brew Werks is a must-visit hotspot in Portage!

Located in Portage, PEGGS is a delightful spot offering old-fashioned American breakfast and lunch in a modern setting with outdoor seating. With a warm and friendly staff, patrons rave about the fluffy and warm chocolate chip pancakes, the flavorful chicken and waffles (despite a slightly overcooked chicken exterior), and the wide selection of freshly squeezed juices. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick and reasonably priced breakfast or leisurely enjoying eggs benedict and mimosas during restaurant week, PEGGS seems to hit the spot for every occasion. Don’t miss their Carol’s hot chocolate, a perfect complement to a satisfying meal.