Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Sullivan, New York

Unveiling the culinary treasures of Sullivan, New York! Situated in the heart of the Empire State, this charming town boasts a vibrant dining scene that will tantalize your taste buds. From cozy cafes serving up artisanal pastries to upscale eateries dishing out gourmet fare, Sullivan is a haven for foodies seeking a gastronomic adventure. Beyond its culinary delights, this lovely town is also home to picturesque parks, historic landmarks, and a thriving arts scene. Join me as we explore the Best Restaurants in Sullivan, NY, and discover the flavors that make this destination a must-visit for any discerning traveler.

1. Chittenango Pizza

Located in Sullivan, Chittenango Pizza is making waves as a standout eatery for pizza enthusiasts in Syracuse. The buzz around this place is palpable, with patrons raving about the phenomenal ingredients, warm hospitality, and irresistible menu offerings. From crispy yet chewy crusts to tangy, robust sauces, every bite at Chittenango Pizza is a flavor explosion that keeps customers coming back for more. The wings are hailed as the best in Central NY, cooked to perfection and offering a tantalizing array of flavors. Whether you’re into gluten-free options or classic pepperoni pies, this place has something for everyone. Don’t miss out on the chance to indulge in truly large pizzas served in a clean and inviting environment – Chittenango Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers looking to elevate their dining experience in Syracuse.

Rating:
Price:

2. DeMario’s Eatery

Located in the charming town of Sullivan, DeMario’s Eatery is a culinary gem not to be missed. Boasting a stellar selection of mouthwatering dishes, from the freshest seafood on Fridays to the hearty Texas burger that will leave you satisfied, this eatery has something for every palate. The staff here are not just kind but work tirelessly to ensure a memorable dining experience for all patrons. Whether you’re craving a homemade deli sandwich or a decadent brownie for dessert, DeMario’s is the perfect spot to indulge in delicious comfort food. Don’t just take my word for it, let your taste buds do the talking and savor the flavors at this must-visit establishment in Sullivan.

Rating:
Price:

3. Buck’s Pizzeria

Located in Sullivan, Buck’s Pizzeria is a culinary gem that has captured the hearts (and taste buds) of locals and newcomers alike. With a reputation for serving up mouthwatering pizzas and delectable subs, this spot has become a go-to destination for those craving a slice of perfection. Rave reviews highlight the impeccable quality of ingredients, particularly the savory sausage and meatballs that adorn their creations. Don’t miss out on the fan-favorite garlic knots that have patrons singing their praises. And for those craving a saucy kick, the everything wings are a must-try, offering the perfect balance of spicy, sweet, and tangy flavors. Beyond the extraordinary menu, Buck’s Pizzeria stands out for its unwavering commitment to its community, making it not just a place to eat but a place to feel at home. Next time you’re in Sullivan, make sure to swing by Buck’s for a slice of pizza paradise that promises to delight your taste buds and leave you craving more.

Rating:
Price:

4. The North Pole Ice Cream

Located in Sullivan, The North Pole Ice Cream is a charming spot that’s garnering attention for its delectable treats. With offerings ranging from classic cones to inventive shakes like the Dark Chocolate Raspberry Truffle, this place is a true gem for dessert enthusiasts. Despite occasional waits, the friendly staff and revamped menu under new ownership make it a must-visit. The recent transformation has elevated the experience, with specialty drinks and sundaes stealing the show – don’t miss out on the crowd-favorite Strawberry Sunday that has patrons raving. Indulge your sweet tooth and dive into a world of delightful flavors at The North Pole Ice Cream!

Rating:
Price:

5. La Cocina

Located in the charming town of Sullivan, La Cocina is a Mexican restaurant that truly transports your taste buds south of the border. With complimentary chips and salsa to kick off your dining experience, the menu offers a plethora of authentic Mexican dishes that are sure to tantalize your palate. From generous portions to prompt and friendly service, the inviting atmosphere adds an extra layer of enjoyment to your meal. Whether you’re a fan of sizzling fajitas, flavorful tacos, or zesty enchiladas, La Cocina has something for everyone. With rave reviews highlighting the exceptional food quality and top-notch service, this gem is a must-visit for anyone craving a genuine taste of Mexico in Sullivan.

Rating:
Price:

6. Darlene’s Kitchen

Darlene’s Kitchen in Sullivan is a culinary gem that has captured the hearts (and taste buds) of locals and visitors alike. Renowned for serving the biggest and best Friday Fish Sandwich on the planet, this cozy diner has become a hotspot for food enthusiasts seeking a mouthwatering experience. Not only does Darlene’s Kitchen boast delicious fare like fries and pie, but the attentive service and welcoming atmosphere make it a must-visit establishment. With a dedicated following of returning customers who are treated like old friends, it’s no surprise that this village diner has solidified its reputation as a beloved culinary destination. Whether you’re stopping by for a birthday breakfast or simply craving a satisfying meal, Darlene’s Kitchen is sure to leave you craving more of their delectable offerings.

Rating:
Price:

7. Nina’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

Located in Sullivan, Nina’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant is a hidden gem, garnering rave reviews for its delectable offerings and charming hospitality. Patrons can’t get enough of the speedy service and warm staff, making every visit a delight. The menu boasts hearty classics like chicken parm, ravioli, and mouthwatering pizza loaded with cheese. Whether you’re in the mood for a Chicken Parm sandwich or a crispy haddock fish fry on Fridays, Nina’s has you covered. With reasonable prices and a cozy mom-and-pop ambiance, this spot is a must-visit for those craving authentic Italian fare in Sullivan. Plan your visit early to snag a spot and savor the flavors that have foodies singing Nina’s praises!

Rating:
Price:

8. Fat Bottom Grill

Located in Sullivan, the Fat Bottom Grill is a rock ‘n’ roll haven that offers more than just a dining experience – it’s a celebration of music and fantastic flavors. Embracing a quirky and vibrant ambiance adorned with 80’s pop culture decor, this grill serves up a feast for both the palate and the senses. Delight in their “flight of wings” with a tantalizing array of sauces, from spicy ranch to the must-try “trash” sauce, while sipping on a signature Bloody Mary that’s breakfast in a glass. The Cajun Shrimp and Cheesy Grits Eggs Benedict promises a symphony of fresh, grilled perfection. With a welcoming and inclusive ethos, Fat Bottom Grill is not just a place to eat; it’s a destination to revel in delicious dishes, friendly service, and a rockin’ good time. Whether you’re a local looking for a new favorite spot or a traveler passing through, this spot is a culinary gem that demands a repeat visit.

Rating:
Price:

9. New China King

Located in the vibrant town of Sullivan, New China King is a shining gem for those craving delectable Chinese cuisine. With a reputation for great food and excellent value, this spot is a top contender for takeout aficionados. Dive into their menu to experience flavors that will transport you to the bustling streets of Beijing. Indulge in their signature dishes and let New China King take your taste buds on a memorable journey through the rich tapestry of Chinese flavors.

Rating:
Price: