Best Restaurants in City of Orange, New Jersey

If you find yourself in the City of Orange craving authentic Italian flavors that feel like a warm hug for your taste buds, look no further than Just Like Nonna. This cozy Italian deli has been making waves with its mouthwatering sandwiches, with the eggplant, broccoli rabe, and fresh mozzarella combination receiving high praise for its crispy textures and flavorful harmony. The friendly atmosphere, generous portions, and the personal touch of the kind-hearted staff add an extra sprinkle of magic to your dining experience. And let’s not forget the desserts – they’re simply out of this world. Whether you’re swinging by for a quick bite or looking to indulge in a leisurely feast, Just Like Nonna promises a culinary journey that’ll have you coming back for more. Word on the street is, you might just discover your new favorite sandwich spot right here in Orange, NJ!

If you find yourself in the City of Orange craving a hearty and unique meal, look no further than Jimmy Buff’s Of West Orange Italian Hot Dogs. Renowned for their massive and flavorful Italian hot dogs, this no-frills establishment has captured the hearts (and appetites) of many. Dive into a hot dog experience like no other, where the dogs are stacked high with peppers, onions, and potatoes, promising a satisfying and filling meal that might just warrant a post-feast nap. With a delightful Tuesday special where you can snag two hot dogs for the price of one, Jimmy Buff’s is not only a treat for your taste buds but also for your wallet. So, if you’re in the mood for some classic Italian comfort food in a casual setting, Jimmy Buff’s is a must-visit spot in the West Orange area.

Star Tavern in the City of Orange is a bustling spot that’s gaining quite the reputation for its thin-crust pizzas and Italian specialties. As you journey to this gem, be prepared for a culinary experience that promises a mix of flavors and textures that’ll make your taste buds dance with joy. The Pesto pizza, a delightful blend of pesto, tomato sauce, and gooey mozzarella, is hailed as a must-try, with its crispy crust and perfectly balanced toppings leaving guests raving. Whether you’re a fan of bar pies or simply in the mood for top-notch pizza, Star Tavern is the place to be. With friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere, this eatery is clearly a standout in the New Jersey pizza scene, earning its place as a gold standard for pizza lovers near and far. Kevin, the stellar server mentioned in reviews, adds an extra touch of warmth to the dining experience, embodying the restaurant’s commitment to excellence. So, if you find yourself in the City of Orange craving a slice of perfection, make your way to Star Tavern and savor a taste of pizza paradise that’s sure to keep you coming back for more.

In the bustling City of Orange, The Appian Way is a true gem that embodies the essence of old-world Italian charm. Stepping into this culinary haven, you are warmly welcomed by the owner, setting the tone for a delightful dining experience. With a reputation for hosting unforgettable events like weddings and parties, this restaurant goes beyond just serving exceptional food – it creates everlasting memories. Dishes like the velvety veal, so tender it practically melts in your mouth, showcase the kitchen’s dedication to traditional Italian flavors. The love and attention to detail poured into each event, ensuring every guest leaves with hearts and stomachs full, is truly commendable. Whether you’re a local looking for a cozy dinner spot or planning a special celebration, The Appian Way is a must-visit destination in City of Orange for a taste of Italy right at your fingertips.

Libretti’s Restaurant in the vibrant City of Orange is a delightful gem for indulging in authentic Italian flavors and creating lasting memories. With a cozy lounge featuring karaoke and piano, this longstanding establishment offers a charming setting for any occasion. Diners rave about the mouthwatering antipasto selections, from tender calamari to savory clams, setting the stage for an exquisite dining experience. The menu boasts classic pasta dishes alongside innovative twists, ensuring there’s something for every palate. Praise is showered upon the attentive wait staff, with special mention of Peggy’s exceptional service, exemplifying a team that works seamlessly together. While the chef’s reluctance to accommodate a simple substitution raised eyebrows, it’s clear that Libretti’s dedication to providing top-notch cuisine shines through. Whether you’re craving traditional red sauce Italian or exploring new culinary horizons, this restaurant promises a delectable feast that’ll leave you eager for a swift return. Make your way to Libretti’s for a taste of Italian heaven in the heart of Orange!

Tantalizing taste buds in the vibrant City of Orange, Rj’s Spot is a culinary gem that has tongues wagging with excitement. Diners are raving about their flavorful dishes that hit all the right notes, leaving taste buds dancing in delight. From savory delights to decadent desserts, this spot seems to have mastered the art of satisfying cravings with finesse. A must-visit for those seeking a gastronomic adventure in the heart of the city.

Located in the vibrant City of Orange, Johnny’s Pizzeria is a gem not to be missed. With a large menu variety and a talent for crafting mouthwatering cheese steaks, this eatery has won the hearts of many locals and visitors alike. The friendly bilingual staff adds a welcoming touch to the experience, ensuring that every visit is as delightful as the last. Whether you’re craving a cheesy slice of pizza or their renowned cheese steak, Johnny’s Pizzeria promises a taste sensation that will keep you coming back for more. Don’t miss the chance to savor the flavors that have enchanted diners in West Orange and beyond.

Sandwiches Unlimited in the vibrant City of Orange has been a beloved staple since the 80s, attracting loyal patrons who swear by their mouthwatering creations. Regulars can’t get enough of the Italian Cheeseburger, a standout dish that has diners coming back for more. With a team that’s both courteous and professional, this eatery is known for its top-notch service, making every visit a delightful experience. Whether you’re planning a special event or just stopping by for a quick bite, Sandwiches Unlimited promises a warm and inviting ambiance that guarantees no regrets. So, why not indulge in a taste of nostalgia and savor the flavors of this iconic establishment?

Benji’s Taqueria Mexican Grill in the vibrant City of Orange is a must-visit gem for those craving authentic Mexican flavors with a no-frills twist. Renowned for their mouthwatering quesabirria, this spot has won the hearts of many with its tantalizing traditional plates. The vibrant decor sets the stage for a culinary journey, where every bite is a testament to the rich Mexican heritage infused into each dish. Despite some minor service hiccups, the overall experience is a fiesta for the taste buds, making it a destination worth returning to time and time again. Unleash your inner foodie and savor the essence of Mexico at Benji’s Taqueria Mexican Grill.

Located in the vibrant City of Orange, Mama Lola is a culinary gem waiting to be explored. Diners rave about the juicy NY Steak, perfectly paired with flavorful rice and beans that will transport your taste buds. The plantains are a standout, adding a delightful twist to your meal. Don’t miss the opportunity to try their green sauce, rumored to elevate every bite with a burst of flavor. And if you’re in the mood for something sweet, the fruit bowl offers a colorful array of options, from sweet grapes to tangy kiwi. With friendly service and a menu that hits all the right notes, Mama Lola promises a dining experience that will have you coming back for more. Your search for the best restaurant in City of Orange might just end here.