Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Middletown, New York

Discover the gastronomic delights of Middletown, New York, a charming town bursting with culinary creativity and diverse flavors. This quaint town is a haven for food enthusiasts, boasting a vibrant dining scene that caters to every palate. From cozy cafes to elegant eateries, Middletown is a treasure trove of gastronomic delights waiting to be explored. Pairing its culinary prowess with an array of captivating attractions, Middletown offers a delightful blend of dining experiences and cultural charm. Join us as we uncover the Best Restaurants in Middletown, where every bite tells a story of culinary excellence.

1. Seoul Sizzle

Seoul Sizzle in Middletown is a gem waiting to be discovered by food aficionados searching for a culinary adventure. Patrons rave about the simplicity of the menu, focusing on quality over quantity, making choices a delightful breeze. The Jeyook Bokkeum promises a tantalizing spice, while the Bulgogi delights with its robust flavors. Guests have marveled at the exquisite presentation of dishes, with a special mention of the homemade kimchi that stole the show. The owner’s personal touch in explaining the menu adds a welcoming charm to the dining experience. Seoul Sizzle is not just a restaurant; it’s a rendezvous with Korean gastronomy that promises to leave a lasting impression on your taste buds. A must-visit spot in Middletown for an unforgettable dining escapade.

Rating:
Price:

2. YiShan Korean Restaurant

Located in Middletown, YiShan Korean Restaurant is a true gem offering an authentic dining experience that will leave your taste buds singing with delight. From the juicy and tender lamb and beef skewers to the flavorful corn with a special chewy texture, every dish is a culinary masterpiece. The staff, like the professional John and the knowledgeable and accommodating Marie, elevate the dining experience to new heights. With generous portions perfect for sharing and a welcoming atmosphere that strikes the perfect balance between cozy and spacious, YiShan is a must-visit spot for both Korean food enthusiasts and first-timers alike. Don’t miss out on this culinary adventure that promises great value for your money and a guaranteed return for a second, third, and many more visits.

Rating:
Price:

3. Oak & Reed

Located in the vibrant town of Middletown, Oak & Reed is a rustic-chic gem that promises an unforgettable dining experience. Amidst the amber tones and moderate buzz of conversation, this eatery serves up elevated seasonal American dishes that have left patrons raving. From the halloumi fried with a whisper of honey to the indulgent Ancho Pork Tenderloin and Horchata Rice Pudding, each dish is a delightful fusion of flavors. The menu, though compact, surprises with its creativity and attention to detail, ensuring a unique culinary adventure with every visit. With outstanding service and a cozy atmosphere, Oak & Reed beckons both locals and travelers alike to savor its delectable offerings. Get ready to delight your taste buds and elevate your dining experience at this must-visit spot in Middletown.

Rating:
Price:

4. House of Birria Tacos & Cantina

If you’re on the hunt for a culinary adventure in Middletown, look no further than House of Birria Tacos & Cantina. This vibrant hotspot is a feast for the senses, offering a culturally rich atmosphere that sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. The star of the show here is undeniably the Birria, a dish that consistently steals the spotlight with its rich, savory flavors that transport you straight to the heart of Mexico. Whether you opt for the Birria tacos, pizza, or nachos, each bite is a symphony of taste that will leave you craving more. The staff, including notable mentions of Diana and Alan, elevate the experience with their friendly service, ensuring that your visit is nothing short of spectacular. Don’t miss out on this gastronomic gem – House of Birria is a must-visit for those in search of authentic Mexican cuisine that’s as delightful as it is delicious.

Rating:
Price:

5. The bagel Corner and Cafe

Located in the vibrant town of Middletown, The Bagel Corner and Cafe has quickly become a local favorite. With a stellar 4.6 overall rating, this charming spot boasts delicious food, a friendly staff, and a convenient location—ideal for both visitors and regulars alike. Patrons rave about the delightful neighborhood atmosphere, clean and airy space, and a menu featuring must-try items like the bacon egg n cheese on a toasted everything bagel. The cafe’s commitment to exceptional service shines through in every interaction, making it a welcoming haven for bagel aficionados and newcomers alike. Whether you’re hankering for a classic lox smear or a fresh cup of coffee by the corner windows, The Bagel Corner’s warmth and quality are bound to keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

6. DeStefano’s Olde Erie

Located in Middletown, DeStefano’s Olde Erie is a culinary gem that seamlessly blends traditional Italian and American flavors to create a dining experience like no other. With a cozy dining room adorned with twinkling lights and separate rooms for private gatherings, the restaurant exudes warmth and hospitality. Diners rave about the generous portion sizes, highlighting dishes like the mouthwatering pasta, juicy burgers, and succulent steaks that are sure to satisfy even the heartiest appetites. Standout items like the battered Calamari with Romano Cheese and the Cajun seafood dish showcase the chef’s creativity and skill, while the attentive service, exemplified by server Donna’s personalized touch, elevates the overall dining experience. Whether you’re a garlic aficionado indulging in the bread with garlic oil or a fan of festive decor, DeStefano’s Olde Erie promises a memorable culinary journey that leaves you planning your next visit before you’ve even left the table. Get ready to be wowed by the flavors and hospitality that make this restaurant a standout in the area!

Rating:
Price:

7. Aaojee

Aaojee is an Indian culinary oasis in the bustling town of Middletown, offering not only a treasure trove of authentic grocery items but also a culinary experience that is unrivaled in the area. With a humble yet well-stocked store, this hidden gem surprises patrons with freshly made samosas that are hailed as the best in town. From aromatic spices to irresistible chutneys, Aaojee’s shelves are a haven for food enthusiasts seeking to elevate their culinary creations. It’s not just about the groceries; it’s about the 10/10 food experience that beckons visitors to indulge in their freshly stored delights. Discover the magic of Aaojee, where every bite tells a tale of flavor, tradition, and culinary excellence.

Rating:
Price:

8. Hanami Japanese Restaurant

Hanami Japanese Restaurant in Middletown is a true gem that promises a delightful dining experience. With a plethora of rave reviews highlighting the phenomenal food and attentive service, it’s no surprise that this spot is a standout in the culinary scene. From the mind-blowing fried rice to the mouthwatering bento boxes offering a variety of tastes, every dish seems to hit the mark. The spicy garlic edamame and Bear Mountain Roll are must-tries, showcasing the perfect blend of flavors that keep customers coming back for more. The staff’s kindness and attention to detail further elevate the dining experience, making Hanami a top contender for anyone seeking quality, delicious sushi in Middletown. Don’t miss out on this culinary treasure!

Rating:
Price:

9. Equilibrium Brewery- Taproom and Bonfire Restaurant

Equilibrium Brewery- Taproom and Bonfire Restaurant in Middletown is a true gem waiting to be discovered by foodies and beer enthusiasts alike. The rave reviews speak for themselves, with patrons praising the wide variety of beers available, from sweet dragon fruit creations to robust stouts. The culinary offerings also shine, with standout dishes like pork belly sliders and succulent smoked ribs stealing the show. The cozy yet vibrant atmosphere, complete with a dog-friendly outdoor area, sets the stage for an experience that goes beyond just dining—it’s a journey for the senses. Whether you’re a local looking for your new favorite hangout spot or a traveler making a special pilgrimage, Equilibrium promises a memorable time filled with great vibes, excellent food, and, of course, top-notch craft beers. Cheers to a must-visit spot that blends warmth, flavor, and a touch of magic in every sip and bite.

Rating:
Price:

10. The Switch Inn

In the vibrant town of Middletown, The Switch Inn stands out as a gem for both locals and visitors alike. Boasting a lively atmosphere with a team that goes above and beyond, this spot is a must-visit. The rave reviews are no joke – with mentions of Jimmy’s top-notch cooking skills and Sarah’s wings that have patrons coming back for more. Whether you’re swinging by for a casual night out or a heartfelt gathering, like the touching memorial shared recently, The Switch Inn offers a warm embrace, hearty dishes, and a sense of community that’s hard to beat. Don’t miss out on their award-winning boneless wings – a true crowd pleaser that will have you savoring each bite. Raise a glass to good times and great company at The Switch Inn – a true standout in Middletown’s culinary scene.

Rating:
Price: