Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Horseheads, New York

Located in upstate New York, Horseheads is a charming town bursting with culinary delights waiting to be savored. This lovely town boasts a vibrant dining scene, making it a haven for food lovers seeking the Best Restaurants in Horseheads. From cozy cafes serving up artisanal coffee to upscale eateries offering farm-to-table fare, this quaint town has something for every palate. In addition to its gastronomic wonders, Horseheads also beckons visitors with its historical landmarks and picturesque parks, making it a destination brimming with both flavor and culture.

1. Fat City

Located in Horseheads, the renowned Fat City restaurant is a must-visit gem for barbecue enthusiasts. A standout among the best in the region, this spot has left patrons raving about their flavorful dishes. The Fat Daddy sandwich and the brisket on wick are crowd favorites, offering a taste that rivals top BBQ joints across the nation. With a menu that excels in both meats and sides, including tender burnt ends, succulent brisket, and delectable apple coleslaw, each bite is a symphony of flavors. The quaint space exudes a cozy charm, with outdoor seating available for those perfect sunny days. Don’t miss their daily specials like the smoked chicken wings or the Carolina Pork Platter, a delightful combination of smoky pork, crunchy slaw, and warm cornbread. The attentive and friendly staff elevate the dining experience, making Fat City a go-to spot for a satisfying meal. Whether you’re a BBQ aficionado or just looking for a memorable culinary adventure, Fat City promises a delightful experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

2. The Diner

Located in Horseheads, The Diner offers a unique dining experience inside a converted train carriage, adding charm to your mealtime. As a popular spot for locals and travelers alike, this historic diner dishes out delicious American breakfasts with prompt service and generous portions. The vibrant atmosphere buzzing among the friendly staff and patrons creates an energy that’s simply infectious. From the mouthwatering Cuban sandwich to the tantalizing cinnamon French toast, every bite at The Diner is a culinary delight worth savoring. Whether you’re passing through or a local looking for a standout dining experience, The Diner promises a memorable visit filled with delectable delights and warm hospitality.

Rating:
Price:

3. Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

If you find yourself in Horseheads, Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard is an absolute must-visit. Renowned for its delectable milkshakes, with flavors like strawberry shortcake and Oreo that are simply to die for, this spot promises a sugar rush like no other. The Italian ice and frozen custard combo creates a symphony of flavors that will transport you back to summer days spent enjoying frozen treats. From Blendinis that combine Italian ice with custard to Misto Shakes that offer a unique twist, Rita’s menu is a playground for your taste buds. The staff, known for their humor and helpfulness, will make sure your experience is nothing short of delightful. Don’t miss out on this gem for a sweet retreat that won’t break the bank.

Rating:
Price:

4. Salsa’s

Located in Horseheads, Salsa’s is a vibrant gem that promises a fiesta for your taste buds. The homemade salsa and tortilla chips, bursting with fresh cilantro, set the stage for an unforgettable culinary experience. Dive into the Chiles rellenos, described as outstanding, or savor the Azteca salad featuring grilled chicken, shrimp, avocado, and mushrooms. Cap off your meal with the decadent flan draped in caramel sauce, whipped cream, and a cherry on top. Boasting attentive service and generous portions, this Mexican eatery is a must-visit spot for those craving authentic flavors and a lively ambiance. With rave reviews pouring in, Salsa’s is a top contender in the realm of Mexican cuisine, earning its stripes among the best restaurants in Horseheads.

Rating:
Price:

5. Louies Hanover Square

Louies Hanover Square in Horseheads is a culinary gem that delights with its classic and contemporary Italian dishes. The menu, brimming with tantalizing options, boasts standout items like garlic knots that are simply divine and desserts that are a sweet conclusion to any meal. While some may find the sausage or meatballs in the Louieā€™s Pasta not their absolute favorite, the portions are so generous that even sharing is a breeze for two diners. The cozy yet industrial decor sets the stage for a memorable dining experience, especially when paired with a good bottle of wine. For those seeking a savory adventure, opting for one of their delectable pizzas might just be the perfect choice to round out a fantastic meal at this charming bistro.

Rating:
Price:

6. Sugar & Spice Restaurant

Located in Horseheads, the Sugar & Spice Restaurant is a true gem for food enthusiasts seeking a delightful experience. Known for its phenomenal French toast that keeps guests coming back for more, this charming spot exudes an inviting old-timey ambiance complemented by top-notch service. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this family-owned eatery stands out for its consistently great food and efficient service, making it a go-to spot for breakfast dates or casual dining. From fluffy pancakes to savory sausage links, every dish bursts with flavor, leaving patrons like you craving for more. With a warm and cozy atmosphere and a team of friendly staff, Sugar & Spice is a must-visit for a memorable culinary escapade in Horseheads.

Rating:
Price:

7. Tanino Ristorante Italiano

Situated in Horseheads, Tanino Ristorante Italiano is a vibrant corner spot that beckons both locals and travelers alike with its authentic Italian flavors and inviting ambiance. Diners rave about the generous portions of traditional fare, including mouthwatering brick-oven pizzas that steal the show. The menu boasts a delightful array of small plates and martini options, keeping guests pleasantly surprised with each visit. From the well-prepared gnocchi to the flavorful Florentine Chicken with creamy pasta, every dish seems to be a hit here. Don’t miss out on their beloved Crab Rangoon or the heavenly warm bread that’s a crowd favorite. With a friendly staff and a cozy upscale casual vibe, Tanino promises to elevate your dining experience to new heights. Get ready to indulge in a culinary journey that blends comfort and sophistication seamlessly, with prices that won’t break the bank but will surely leave you satisfied and planning your next return.

Rating:
Price:

8. Nick’s Pub And Grill

Nick’s Pub And Grill in Horseheads is a gem for those seeking a local hangout with a vibrant atmosphere and top-notch service. With walls adorned with TVs, it’s the perfect spot to catch the game while relishing in some hearty comfort food. The menu boasts tantalizing options like the blue cheeseburger and the steakhouse burger, both hailed for their generous portions and mouthwatering flavors. Not to be missed are the crispy onion rings and the homemade ranch dressing that patrons rave about. The “Richter Wings” are a standout, featuring a fiery hot and garlic parmesan combo that promises a flavor explosion. Whether you’re grabbing a drink at the bar or enjoying a family meal in the cozy dining area, Nick’s Pub And Grill guarantees a memorable dining experience where good times and great food collide. A must-visit for both locals and visitors looking for a taste of the town’s culinary excellence!

Rating:
Price:

9. Thai Asian 119

Situated in Horseheads, Thai Asian 119 is a culinary gem that flawlessly intertwines Chinese and Thai flavors to create an unforgettable dining experience. With rave reviews about their generous portions and budget-friendly prices, this restaurant is a sure win for both your taste buds and your wallet. The enthusiastic mentions of the welcoming smiles from the staff paint a picture of a warm and inviting atmosphere that sets the stage for a delightful meal. From the heavenly sushi to the flavorsome Thai Tea with its unique depth, every dish seems to be a star on its own. With lightning-fast service and a dedication to customer satisfaction, Thai Asian 119 is not just a place for a meal but a destination for an all-encompassing dining treat. Whether you’re a sushi aficionado or a fan of traditional Thai cuisine, this spot comes highly recommended for its amazing food and outstanding service.

Rating:
Price:

10. Garcia’s Mexican Restaurant

Located in Horseheads, Garcia’s Mexican Restaurant is a vibrant culinary gem that has been turning heads and tantalizing taste buds. With rave reviews highlighting their generous portions and delightful drinks, it’s no surprise that patrons feel like they are being taken care of in the most delightful way. The Chori-pollo seems to be the star of the show, hailed as the best in the area, accompanied by a duo of salsas that have customers singing praises. From the crunchy and flavorful tacos to the well-crafted margaritas, Garcia’s delivers an Americanized menu with impeccable quality that keeps guests coming back for more. With ample parking and a welcoming atmosphere, Garcia’s is a must-visit for Mexican food enthusiasts looking for a memorable dining experience in Horseheads.

Rating:
Price: