Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Mamaroneck, New York

Situated in the vibrant state of New York, Mamaroneck is a culinary paradise waiting to be explored. This lovely town boasts a diverse array of dining options that cater to every palate, making it a haven for food enthusiasts. From cozy cafes to upscale eateries, Mamaroneck has something for everyone. Beyond its gastronomic delights, this charming town offers a rich tapestry of attractions, including scenic waterfront views and cultural landmarks. Join me on a culinary journey through the Best Restaurants in Mamaroneck, where every bite tells a story of flavor and excellence.

1. Walter’s Hot Dogs – Mamaroneck

Walter’s Hot Dogs in Mamaroneck has solidified its spot as a local treasure since 1928, charming patrons with its unassuming art deco pagoda setting. Serving up iconic comfort eats, this roadside gem has become a go-to for hot dog aficionados and food enthusiasts alike. The menu boasts simplicity done right, with hot dogs that hit the mark and sides like crispy potato puffs and perfectly seasoned curly fries that keep visitors coming back for more. Don’t miss out on their delectable milkshakes or the loaded clam chowder for a truly satisfying meal. While enjoying the outdoor dining experience, keep an eye out for the fearless squirrels adding a touch of whimsy to the ambiance. Walter’s Hot Dogs is a must-visit destination for those craving a taste of history and a bite of culinary excellence in Mamaroneck.

Rating:
Price:

2. Augustine’s Salumeria e Pasta Joint

Located in the vibrant town of Mamaroneck, Augustine’s Salumeria e Pasta Joint is a culinary gem that has quickly captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. With rave reviews praising their homemade pasta that’s described as nothing short of perfection, it’s evident that a dining experience here is sure to impress even the most discerning pasta aficionados. Dishes like the cabbage-wrapped duck and pasta ripiena (ravioli) have left patrons raving about the innovative flavors and impeccable execution. The friendly and knowledgeable staff, like the standout Kaia, elevate the overall dining experience, making each visit memorable. Don’t miss out on their delightful wine selection to complement your meal, and be sure to save room for their delectable homemade cannoli, a sweet ending that will linger on your taste buds long after you’ve left. Augustine’s is a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts seeking an unforgettable Italian culinary adventure in Mamaroneck.

Rating:
Price:

3. Sal’s Pizza Mamaroneck

Located in the vibrant town of Mamaroneck, Sal’s Pizza Mamaroneck is a culinary gem serving up delectable NY- and Sicilian-style slices that have stood the test of time. Rave reviews highlight the consistently great pizza, with a special mention of the mouthwatering pepperoni variation that even the younger generation can’t resist. The friendly staff adds a welcoming touch to the experience, making it a cozy spot for families to indulge in a classic pizza outing. Don’t fret about the cash-only policy; an ATM on-site ensures you can savor every cheesy bite stress-free. Join the legacy of satisfied customers who have made Sal’s a tradition, and taste a slice of history for yourself.

Rating:
Price:

4. Modern on the Rails

Situated within a historic train station in Mamaroneck, Modern on the Rails offers a dining experience that goes beyond exquisite Italian cuisine and craft cocktails. Glowing reviews highlight its versatility as a premier wedding venue, with guests lauding the romantic ambience, impeccable service, and delectable dishes. From perfectly cooked steaks to mouthwatering pasta dishes, this restaurant exceeds expectations at every turn, providing a unique and charming atmosphere with exposed brick and elegant chandeliers. Whether you’re planning a wedding, bridal shower, or simply craving a memorable dining experience, Modern on the Rails promises to elevate any special occasion with its top-notch staff and unforgettable culinary creations. This gem is a must-visit for those seeking a perfect mix of elegance and gastronomic delight in Mamaroneck.

Rating:
Price:

5. Mamaroneck Beach & Yacht Club

Located in the picturesque town of Mamaroneck, the Mamaroneck Beach & Yacht Club is a hidden gem that promises an unforgettable dining experience. The rave reviews speak for themselves – from hosting dream weddings to extravagant parties, this venue exudes excellence in every detail. The panoramic water views, meticulously manicured outdoor spaces, and top-notch service led by Bob and his dedicated team set the stage for perfection. Guests can’t stop talking about the Michelin-worthy food that elevates any event held here. Whether you’re planning a wedding, party, or a special celebration, Mamaroneck Beach & Yacht Club is a must-visit destination that guarantees a magical and unforgettable experience for all.

Rating:
Price:

6. Nonna Carola Ristorante and Bar

Located in Mamaroneck, Nonna Carola Ristorante and Bar is a gem that promises an unforgettable dining adventure. Patrons rave about the exceptional service and delectable dishes that elevate any special occasion, from birthdays to bridal showers. The ambiance is described as elegant yet inviting, perfect for a romantic date night or a fun girls’ night out. Guests are treated to a symphony of flavors, with standout dishes like the mouthwatering calamari, heavenly chicken parmigiana, and divine veal martini stealing the show. This Italian culinary haven is a must-visit for those craving an experience that seamlessly blends exquisite cuisine with top-notch customer care. Indulge in a night of culinary delights that will leave you planning your next visit before you’ve even left the table.

Rating:
Price:

7. Green Life

Nestled in the vibrant town of Mamaroneck, Green Life is a culinary oasis for those seeking a healthy and flavorful dining experience. Boasting a menu that caters to all, including the little ones with their beloved Cauliflower pizza, this family-owned establishment is a hit among locals and visitors alike. The rave reviews speak volumes about the freshness and deliciousness of their offerings, from the winter comfort of chicken and rice soup to the innovative cauliflower crusted pesto pizza. With a focus on wellness and convenience, Green Life’s dedication to quality shines through in every meal, making it a top contender in the realm of Westchester’s fast-casual dining scene. Whether you’re in for a quick bite or diving into a juice cleanse, Green Life is a must-visit destination that promises a delightful culinary journey every time you step through its doors.

Rating:
Price:

8. DonJito

Located in Mamaroneck, DonJito is a culinary gem that has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Boasting a vibrant atmosphere and top-notch service, this hotspot has become synonymous with unforgettable dining experiences. From the innovative Lomo saltado sushi to the refreshing mango margaritas expertly crafted by Christian, the menu is a delightful fusion of flavors that promises to tantalize your taste buds. With a diverse array of events like vallenato nights and live music, every visit to DonJito unfolds a new layer of excitement. Whether you’re seeking a romantic evening or a lively gathering with friends, this restaurant guarantees a memorable time filled with mouthwatering dishes and fantastic drinks. DonJito is undeniably a must-visit destination for anyone craving a gastronomic adventure in Mamaroneck.

Rating:
Price:

9. Sedona Taphouse

Situated in the vibrant town of Mamaroneck, Sedona Taphouse offers a haven for beer enthusiasts and foodies alike. Boasting an impressive array of around 30 taps and a diverse selection of bottles and cans, this spot is a beer lover’s paradise. Standout dishes like the bacon-wrapped jalapenos and the Hangover burger made with Wagyu beef and a fried egg are not to be missed. The friendly and attentive service, as highlighted by patrons, adds a welcoming touch to the dining experience. Whether you’re popping in for a quick bite or a celebratory Happy Hour, Sedona Taphouse promises a memorable and flavorful time. Cheers to good times and great flavors at this gem in Mamaroneck!

Rating:
Price:

10. SmokeHouse Tailgate Grill – Mamaroneck

In the bustling town of Mamaroneck, SmokeHouse Tailgate Grill emerges as a beacon for BBQ enthusiasts seeking a top-tier dining experience. Nestled in the heart of the town, this gem boasts a menu that tantalizes taste buds and leaves patrons craving more. From the brisket sandwich paired with velvety Mac N Cheese to the tantalizing pulled chicken sandwich, every bite is a harmonious symphony of flavors. Diving deeper, their signature smoke pulled pork, delicately nestled in a brioche bun with crunchy pickles and red onions, is a true standout, perfectly complemented by a side of crisp fries and homemade coleslaw. The culinary journey continues with the tomahawk burger, a juicy masterpiece crowned with crispy onions and mushroom-like jam, all embraced by a perfectly toasted brioche bun. Amidst the savory delights, the service shines bright, mirroring the warm and attentive care provided by dedicated staff members like Taish, ensuring every visit is nothing short of exceptional. SmokeHouse Tailgate Grill isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an experience to savor and cherish, making it a must-visit destination for BBQ aficionados in Mamaroneck.

Rating:
Price: