Best Restaurants in Shelter Island, New York

Located in Shelter Island, Shelter Island Slice is a pizza paradise that boasts a variety of mouthwatering options. With glowing reviews praising the inventive toppings and accommodating staff, it’s no wonder this spot stands out as a pizza lover’s dream. From the unique chicken bacon ranch with marinara to the gluten-free cauliflower crust for those with dietary restrictions, Shelter Island Slice caters to all tastes. Dive into a slice of nostalgia with their ever-changing menu that keeps patrons coming back for more, even surpassing famous pizza destinations like New Haven, Connecticut. Stop by this clean, welcoming space and savor the unbeatable crust while catching a game on the big screen – a perfect combination of good vibes, great food, and friendly service that’s sure to make Shelter Island Slice your top pick for a pizza night.

In the vibrant town of Shelter Island, The Eccentric Bagel stands out as a beacon of bagel brilliance, drawing in natives and travelers alike with its unparalleled offerings. Renowned for its New York style bagels, this gem has garnered rave reviews for its dense, chewy crumb and crackly crust, making it a must-visit spot for bagel enthusiasts. The breakfast bagel sandwiches, described as “huge and should be shared,” are a testament to the generosity and flavor bursting from each bite. From the classic everything bagel topped with cream cheese, avocado, and lox to the innovative Jalapeno-Cheddar and Smoked Bacon varieties, each creation is a work of art. The whimsical decor and friendly staff only add to the allure, making The Eccentric Bagel not just a restaurant, but a culinary adventure waiting to be explored in the heart of Shelter Island. With each visit promising a delightful experience, this spot is undoubtedly a jewel in the Long Island dining scene, beckoning all to indulge in its savory delights.

Located in Shelter Island, Maria’s Kitchen is a vibrant gem that has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike with its diverse Mexican menu and affordable prices. The restaurant’s commitment to quality and speedy service is evident as work trucks frequent the place, hinting at consistent excellence. From the impeccable Baja shrimp tacos overflowing with goodness to the tantalizing grilled fish burrito that should earn a spot on a renowned food show, Maria’s Kitchen truly impresses. The fresh ingredients, generous portions, and friendly staff create a welcoming atmosphere that beckons diners to indulge in delightful dishes like the flavorful chicken tacos and mouthwatering nachos. Don’t miss out on the patio dining experience surrounded by a charming garden while savoring the top-notch rice and beans. For an unforgettable culinary journey, Maria’s Kitchen is undoubtedly a must-visit destination that will leave you craving more.

Located in the charming town of Shelter Island, Kyle’s is a culinary gem not to be missed when exploring the local dining scene. With raving reviews highlighting their must-try Beef Brisket sandwich on ciabatta, cooked to mouthwatering perfection, and generously portioned Chicken quesadilla bursting with flavors, it’s clear that Kyle’s excels in crafting delectable dishes that leave patrons coming back for more. The inviting porch provides a relaxing ambiance for enjoying their consistently excellent food, including the standout sweet potato fries and top-notch frittata. Whether indulging in their famous jelly donut or savoring the best pancakes in town, Kyle’s promises a memorable dining experience where friendly service, like that from the lovely Gabriella and Shelley, elevates each visit to a delightful culinary journey. For a stellar breakfast or brunch adventure, Kyle’s is the ultimate destination that promises a perfect start to any day!

Located in Shelter Island, Vine Street Café is a culinary gem that promises a delightful experience for both locals and visitors. The eclectic menu celebrates the best of local produce, seafood, and wine, served in a quaint American cottage setting. Dishes like the gluten-free scallops, prawns over asparagus, and unique tuna tacos have garnered rave reviews, while the perfectly blended flavors of the skirt steak and duck have left patrons craving more. Despite the occasional distraction from neighboring guests, the attentive service and vibrant atmosphere make Vine Street Café a must-visit spot. Indulge in the extraordinary duck confit and miso salmon, paired with an excellent selection of wines by the glass. With such standout dishes and friendly staff, this charming restaurant is sure to become a top dining destination in Shelter Island for food enthusiasts seeking a memorable culinary adventure.

Situated in the picturesque Shelter Island, SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill offers a culinary experience like no other. The ambiance seamlessly merges indoor and outdoor spaces, perfect for savoring creative dishes while enjoying waterfront views. Boasting a 4.4-star rating, this gem has diners raving about the impeccable service, with Jackie shining as a standout server, elevating the dining experience with her friendly demeanor. Patrons can’t stop raving about the lobster roll, hailed as the best one they’ve ever tasted. SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill is a must-visit destination for those seeking delectable cuisine and top-notch hospitality in Shelter Island.

Commander Cody’s Fish Shoppe on Shelter Island is a seafood haven that promises a symphony of flavors. Drawing locals and visitors alike, this gem boasts a menu brimming with the freshest catch. Diners rave about the succulent shrimp cocktail, a crowd-pleaser that has saved impromptu gatherings and delighted taste buds with its freshness. Embracing a soulful ambiance, this spot not only serves real seafood but also serves up a side of blues and soul music, creating an atmosphere that resonates with every bite. It’s no wonder patrons are already planning their swift return to this island favorite.

Located in Shelter Island, The Islander is a culinary gem offering a delightful array of American breakfast-to-dinner options that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Raving reviewers commend this low-key outpost for its mouthwatering menu featuring standout dishes like the irresistible fried chicken, flavorful shrimp tacos, zesty buffalo wings, and juicy burgers. With a charming outdoor seating area perfect for enjoying your meal al fresco, it’s no wonder that patrons praise the friendly service and consistent quality that make The Islander a must-visit spot during your island adventures. Don’t miss out on this cash-only or Venmo-friendly establishment that promises a memorable dining experience every time you drop by.

Located in Shelter Island, Léon 1909 is a culinary gem that has quickly captured the hearts of food enthusiasts. Step into this elegant establishment and you’ll find yourself transported to a bygone era, where sophistication meets warmth in perfect harmony. The menu is a true work of art, boasting dishes meticulously crafted with the freshest ingredients and innovative techniques. Each bite is a revelation of flavors, from delicate appetizers to succulent mains and decadent desserts, promising a dining experience like no other. The impeccable service only adds to the charm, with staff members like Zach going above and beyond to ensure every guest feels pampered. Be sure to try the off-menu bone-in Ribeye with a chermoula spice or the tantalizing Chicken Liver Mousse. With a blend of French, Italian, and Mediterranean influences, complemented by seasonal cocktails and a captivating view, Léon 1909 is a must-visit destination for those craving an unforgettable culinary journey. Whether you’re seeking a special occasion indulgence or a memorable night out, Léon 1909 is where unforgettable dining memories are made.

Nestled in the charming town of Shelter Island, the Shelter Island Whale’s Tale is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered by food enthusiasts of all ages. Boasting a lively atmosphere and a diverse menu, this eatery offers more than just a meal—it provides an experience. Rave reviews highlight the friendly staff catering to every need with a smile, ensuring each visit is memorable. From delectable ice creams that melt in your mouth to a whimsical mini-golf course that transports you to another world, it’s evident that this spot is a hotspot for families and fun-seeking individuals. So, if you’re seeking a culinary adventure that combines nostalgia with a touch of whimsy, the Shelter Island Whale’s Tale is a must-visit destination on your gastronomic journey through Shelter Island.